The first time Donald Sylvester Jones was tried for a 2001 slaying at a Westwood drug house, the jury reached an impasse and the judge declared a mistrial.

Yesterday, after two days of deliberation, a second jury convicted Mr. Jones of first-degree murder and the same judge sentenced him to life in prison. He also was convicted of two firearms violations and given an additional five to 10 years.

The jury forewoman shuddered as she read the verdict slip. She and another juror wept as a clerk polled the jurors, one by one, to ascertain that the nine women and three men agreed the defendant had the intent to kill and shot 42-year-old Anthony Wilkinson with malice. Each affirmed the verdict.

Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman then asked the 53-year-old Hazelwood man if he had anything to say.

Advertise with us

"You've got the wrong guy," he said calmly. "I don't know anything about this case. I don't know anything about these people. I believe the person that did this is still out there."

Mr. Jones was convicted of killing Mr. Wilkinson at a crack house in the 100 block of Kearns Avenue on Feb. 16, 2001.

A witness testified that she saw Mr. Wilkinson kneeling in the kitchen of the house with a man pointing a gun at him. She later heard gunfire. The woman reviewed suspect photos over several years but could never identify the gunman.

Allegheny County detectives had considered the homicide a cold case by the time Mr. Jones' nephew, William Grayson, came forward, identifying his uncle as the shooter. Mr. Grayson had been sentenced on morals charges and faced gun charges in federal court when he came forward with a statement, alleging that he drove his uncle to the house where he shot the victim.

Crime scene investigators had recovered a cap and a pair of glasses that police believed belonged to the shooter. A test of hair samples from the cap matched Mr. Jones' DNA. The glasses also matched Mr. Jones' prescription. After reviewing dozens of suspects, the witness identified Mr. Jones as the shooter from a photo array.

Judge Cashman sentenced Mr. Jones immediately after the verdict. None of his or the victim's relatives was present in court.