The intense manhunt for the second suspected gunman in the campus shooting of five Duquesne University basketball players ended yesterday afternoon when William Holmes surrendered to Pittsburgh homicide detectives.
Related article
Dukes forward Baldonado feeling better
Mr. Holmes, 18, and fellow Penn Hills resident Brandon Baynes, 19, who was apprehended Tuesday, face amended charges of five counts each of attempted homicide and aggravated assault and single counts of a weapons violation and conspiracy.
A third person, Brittany Jones, 19, also of Penn Hills and a student at Duquesne, is charged with reckless endangerment, carrying a firearm without a license and conspiracy. Police say Ms. Jones helped Mr. Holmes and Mr. Baynes smuggle guns into a back-to-school dance at the Duquesne Union ballroom hours before the shooting. She is free on $2,000 bond.
Cmdr. Thomas Stangrecki of city police Major Crimes announced the arrest at a news briefing but declined to take questions, saying the investigation was continuing into the attack.
Mr. Holmes was denied bail last night at his arraignment hearing. His lawyers said they would argue for a bail hearing because Mr. Holmes voluntarily turned himself in and because Mr. Baynes was granted $250,000 bond.
James Sheets, counsel for Mr. Holmes, said he turned himself in because he was frightened after hearing news accounts and seeing his picture in newspapers.
He said police characterized Mr. Holmes as armed and dangerous, "neither of which are true."
Mr. Holmes called the lawyers early yesterday morning to arrange when and how he would surrender. His lawyers then called the homicide unit to arrange the pickup at their Downtown office, at 304 Ross St.
Mr. Holmes took a letter from his lawyers to police headquarters stating that he was invoking his Fifth Amendment rights and would not answer any questions.
Mr. Sheets said he plans on entering a not-guilty plea on behalf of Mr. Holmes.
He said Mr. Holmes is not disputing claims that he was at the scene of the shooting, but said Mr. Holmes did not commit the crimes police have charged him with.
Mr. Holmes' preliminary hearing is scheduled for Tuesday at 8 a.m.
Duquesne President Charles J. Dougherty, who appeared at the police news briefing, commended Pittsburgh police and other law enforcement agencies for their swift work in the case.
"Now with the arrest of the second shooter, we believe Duquesne University can begin the road back to normalcy and to the safety and security that has been known for years on campus," he said.
"This has been a tragedy in the life of a great university but the response of this community, caring for each other through this suffering, will make Duquesne a greater university."
Two of the five students who were wounded in the shooting early Sunday remained hospitalized at Mercy Hospital. They are Sam Ashaolu, 23, who was in critical condition, and teammate Stuard Baldonado, 21, who was in fair condition. Three other basketball players, Kojo Mensah, 21, Aaron Jackson, 20, and Shawn James, 23, have been released from the hospital.
Yesterday, members of Mr. Ashaolu's family said they were encouraged by subtle signs of improvement in his condition since Tuesday night.
"It is only little things," said Mr. Ashaolu's brother, John. "He's moving his legs a little and responding a little by squeezing people's hands. From what the doctors have said, those things are small, but definitely are encouraging signs. We know it is going to be a long road and need to look at these little improvements as a positive in what we realize is going to be a long process."
Earlier, Dr. Dougherty announced the immediate suspension of Ms. Jones, a sophomore, following her arrest overnight Monday.
University officials said Ms. Jones was suspended for committing multiple violations of the university Code of Student Conduct, but did not elaborate.
"The university community is stunned and deeply disappointed to learn that a student may be involved in this incident that has brought such injury and heartache to our campus," Mr. Dougherty stated in a news release.
Ms. Jones was removed from classes even before completion of a hearing process at which she can still challenge the campus charges over the next several weeks. The school said it has the authority to act before completion of the process and chose to do so given the nature of the allegations.
Her attorney, James M. Ecker, said the move amounted to overkill and that his client had already tried to contact a campus counselor about withdrawing.
"She's extremely upset," Mr. Ecker said. "For all the things [the media has] said about her on her Web site. It's making her look like a bad person. She's never been in trouble."
Ms. Jones, who on her MySpace.com profile described herself as the "definition of half lady, half thug," accompanied the suspects and at least four other people to the dance, according to an arrest affidavit. Police said she approached a student working as a doorman at the event and asked "if he was patting people down" and was told "No."
The school, in a policy now under review, does not have metal detectors at dances, including the Saturday night event attended by about 200 people -- students from Duquesne and other area colleges and non-student guests.
Also under university scrutiny is the encounter between the student doorman and Ms. Jones. Asked if the doorman should have alerted campus officers immediately if he was asked about checking for guns, Duquesne spokeswoman Bridget Fare said: "I think that would be a reasonable expectation for an institution. However, we want to make clear we don't know what was said.
"This is what one student is saying. And I've heard four or five versions of what that is."
Two armed Duquesne University police provided security in the ballroom, and neither of those officers nor people at the dance reported any altercations inside. Four other armed police officers and two unarmed security guards patrolled elsewhere on campus.
After the dance ended about 2 a.m., a confrontation occurred on Academic Walk near Vickroy Hall and Duquesne Towers when a woman police have not identified, but believed to be part of Ms. Jones' group, began talking with the basketball players.
Police said Mr. Baynes and Mr. Holmes became upset because of that and began taunting the basketball players. The basketball players turned and walked away to avoid a confrontation. The other group turned and walked in the opposite direction, but Mr. Baynes and Mr. Holmes whipped around and began firing at the athletes.
According to a police affidavit, an unidentified witness who saw the shooting later pointed out Mr. Holmes from a photographic lineup and picked Mr. Baynes' photograph out of a similar photographic lineup.
The school confirmed yesterday that it is weighing interim steps for beefing up security at gatherings "that could be up to and including wands and [metal] detectors," Ms. Fare said. "Everything is on the table."
She could not say if the university-owned A.J. Palumbo Center is included in the discussions. There are police present at every event there and metal detectors are sometimes used for concerts at the request of the act.
Duquesne postponed its Bluffstock Music Fest that had been scheduled for campus Saturday. The school said it did so out of respect for the injured players and would likely reschedule it in the spring.
A postgame alumni picnic also was canceled, but the 1 p.m. football home game Saturday against Sacred Heart will go on, albeit with extra security in place that Duquesne did not elaborate on yesterday.
"The athletes wanted to play and felt that would be the best way to honor their fellow athletes," Ms. Fare said. "The basketball team also wanted them to play."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.