The selection of education reformer Mark Roosevelt, a former Massachusetts legislator who has never led a school much less a school district, as Pittsburgh Public Schools superintendent represents an experiment.
Paul Hawthorne, Getty Images
New York City Schools Chancellor Joel Klein with Get Organized New York Co-chair Caroline Kennedy last year. "Wondering how a former prosecutor would have the background to oversee the education of our children."
Click photo for larger image.
And while that experiment worries some skeptics, the phenomenon of selecting a "nontraditional" superintendent has become increasingly common throughout the country, and particularly in the nation's large urban districts.
Many school systems that have appointed nontraditional superintendents have seen student test scores rise and public participation in school life increase. And those results have encouraged still more districts -- many of which are frustrated by stagnant test scores and high school graduation rates -- to bring in superintendents from military, business, government or policy careers, according to Henry Duvall, a spokesman for the Council of Great City Schools in Washington, D.C. After all, superintendents with polished education backgrounds haven't always succeeded.
"It's sort of well, we've had experienced educators in the past, so let's see what happens by bringing in someone who has the enthusiasm and leadership ability to run the district," said Duvall, whose group represents the nation's large urban districts. "In general, it has been a positive experience."
Roosevelt, 49, was formally approved as Pittsburgh's next schools superintendent on Wednesday, contingent on his reaching an agreement with the board on a contract. The three-year contract, which offered Roosevelt $160,000 a year plus incentive bonuses, is still being negotiated; the board meets Aug. 3 to vote on the agreement.
If he starts work on Aug. 15 as scheduled, Roosevelt would become one of about a dozen nontraditional superintendents at districts throughout the nation, including those in Philadelphia, New York City, San Diego, Denver, Jacksonville, Fla., Baltimore and Savannah, Ga.
In many of those districts, even skeptics have found themselves won over by the new breed of superintendent. Jeannie Tsavaris-Basini, a PTA president in Queens who has been involved as a parent and student activist for 17 years, had high praise for New York City Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, a former prosecutor appointed to the position in July 2002.
"There were many, many of us who were skeptical," she said. "We were basically wondering how a former prosecutor would have the background to oversee the education of our children.
"Many people harshly judged him. But I decided to be fair and give the man a chance because all the others prior to him had failed."
Klein's office recently announced that for the first time, 50 percent or more of all the city's students in grades 3 through 7 met or exceeded the reading and math standards for their grade. Klein announced that black and Hispanic students achieved their greatest one-year gains and best performance ever on both tests.
He attributed the improved results to a reform program he created called Children First, which had all city students studying the same curriculum and encouraged teachers to aggressively work with students who struggled.
California's Los Angeles Unified School District also hired a superintendent from outside the usual education pipeline.
Roy Romer, former governor of Colorado, was named superintendent of schools of the Los Angeles City Board of Education in 2000. For decades, it was an urban school system more notable for its failures than its successes.
Romer's supporters say his leadership, including a focused curriculum and tougher math and reading standards, has given that system -- where about 78 percent of its 720,000 students are considered poor -- a reason to celebrate and hope.
Since 2000, elementary school scores in the state's Academic Performance Index have improved significantly.
The trend of hiring school superintendents from outside the education field began in Seattle, with the appointment of retired U.S. Army major general John Stanford in July 1995. Stanford immediately raised eyebrows with his claim that he'd never failed at anything, according to news reports. On his first day, Stanford proposed that central office staff spend one day each week helping in schools, and he made poor customer service a fireable offense.
Within a few weeks, Stanford had proposed tougher academic standards, ended social promotion, proposed more places for parents to register their children for school and begun a "reading offensive" that prompted the donation of thousands of books to local schools, according to the Seattle Times.
Stanford also dismissed protests by those who said his major reforms couldn't happen.
"It's never been done and, therefore, we will do it," he said, according to the Times.
A few months later, local companies were chipping in millions to create education programs, and Stanford had earned the kind of public adulation usually reserved for rock stars and religious figures.
Test scores rose, year after year -- and continued to do so even after Stanford died in office of leukemia in November 1998.
"He was immortalized, he was a god," said Tim Quinn, director of the Broad Urban Superintendents Academy. "If you talk to people today, they just genuflect when they hear his name."
For a nontraditional superintendent to succeed, however, he or she needs to pick a strong chief academic officer with a track record of improving student achievement, and a strong finance director, according to education experts and some nontraditional superintendents themselves. Such superintendents also need to understand the differences between their jobs and those of the school board members, and allow them to set policy.
Failing to respect that boundary doomed nontraditional superintendent Alphonse Davis in New Orleans after 21/2 years -- but also cut short the tenure of his successor, who had a traditional background, in about the same amount of time.
And a nontraditional superintendent, retired U.S. Army General Julius Becton Jr. struggled with the deep problems and entrenched bureaucracy in Washington, D.C., schools and left after a few years, according to Duvall.
Many nontraditional superintendents succeed precisely because of their lack of experience in the education system, according to Quinn, whose 10-month urban superintendent training program recruits about 20 executives, military officers and other would-be nontraditional superintendents each year from a field of about 300 applicants. Roosevelt completed the program in 2003.
"From their perspective, there isn't anything that can't be done, and they see everything from a fresh set of eyes," Quinn said. "They often say, 'This doesn't make any sense -- why would we continue doing all these things that don't work? We need to change strategy.' "
In Chicago, and most recently, in Philadelphia, nontraditional superintendent Paul Vallas did just that. Vallas, Chicago's former budget director, was appointed by Mayor Richard M. Daley in 1995 to a school system of more than 400,000 students, of whom about 85 percent were considered poor.
As chief executive officer of Chicago Public Schools, Vallas quickly reached contracts with the district's unions and created a five-year balanced budget plan to bring the district's finances under control. He also abolished social promotion, raised academic standards, built dozens of new schools, and expanded after-school and summer school programs.
Math and reading scores rose, although they stagnated in the final years of Vallas's tenure, which ended in 1999.
The percentage of children in grades 3 through 8 who were reading at or above national norms increased from 32.9 percent in 1997 to 38.9 percent in 2000, the year after Vallas resigned from Chicago schools. The percentage of children in those grades doing math at or above national norms rose from 34.3 percent in 1997 to 43.4 percent in 2000.
Vallas, who is now chief executive officer of the School District of Philadelphia, said he succeeded in both cities largely because he immediately defined his vision for education, outlined a five-year plan for a balanced budget, and started talking with the district's unions -- particularly its teachers union.
"That will be enough momentum to get you off the launch pad without a lot of foam ripping away," he said.
That momentum, Vallas said, helped him make necessary changes such as tougher academic standards, more professional development for teachers and administrators, and more time for children to master key concepts. And those reforms helped move the number of Philadelphia schools meeting state math and reading standards from 22 schools in his first year to 160 last year, he said.
"You don't have three years of that level of growth without doing something right," Vallas said.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.