As is his custom, Pittsburgh Fire Capt. Donald Dorsey smiled broadly as he stood in front of Engine Co. 39, even as sadness hung like black crepe over Troy Hill on an otherwise sunny afternoon last week.

Steve Mellon, Post-Gazette

Pittsburgh Fire Capt. Donald Dorsey, right, gets hugs of support from Troy Hill residents who'd turned out to protest the closing of the neighborhood's fire station.

Click photo for larger image. Online graphic

Advertise with us

See a map showing the location of the Troy Hill fire station.

City Council had just voted to approve a firefighters contract that at 8 a.m. tomorrow will close six fire stations, including Troy Hill's, the city's oldest at 104 years and Dorsey's beloved workplace for 25.

Dorsey, a gregarious man with infectious optimism, didn't react with bitterness to the bad news but with gratitude for the good fight of Troy Hill residents who struggled valiantly again to save their station house and their firefighters. Unlike previous efforts since the 1960s to save the fire station central to the community, both literally and figuratively, this battle had been lost, but not for lack of passion.

"Thank you, thank you, thank you," Dorsey said to each person, cupping their hands in his and helping them off a Molly's Trolley that had transported them from City Council chambers back to -- where else -- the fire station.

Some of the women had tears in their eyes; Dorsey fought back his own. All of them, men, women, children, looked as if they had been punched in the stomach. As if hoping an embrace could stop the inevitable, many hugged Dorsey, outfitted in his "turn out" firefighter gear after returning from a call.

Advertise with us

"I was thanking them for loving me, for being so good to me. They adopted me," Dorsey said. "What else can I say to them but, 'Thank you'? They did a great job. They couldn't have done more."

At City Council, Troy Hill residents, store owners, a priest and a doctoral candidate had spoken in eloquent, measured tones, not just about their concerns for public safety if the station were closed but about their certainty that it would further rend the fabric of a community that had already lost a recreation center, a senior center, a swimming pool and a parochial school.

This firehouse, their firehouse, isn't just a building in a good neighborhood, but a good neighbor itself, they said. It had been there so long and had meant so much that it had created a quality of life that couldn't be quantified.

The firefighters have sponsored Easter egg hunts, read stories to children, fixed bicycles, engaged youths in pickup basketball games and held events for every holiday, such as distributing 50 pounds of sausage sandwiches during Halloween trick-or-treat.

Firefighters, under Dorsey's direction, bolted a bell to the station facade in 1993 to express their gratitude to residents for saving it during one of many closure threats. A community contest was held to name the bell, inscribed with the words "Courage, Honor, Service, Sacrifice."

Advertise with us

Residents overwhelmingly voted to name it, in German, "Die Glocke Sarah," or "The Bell Sarah," to honor Dorsey's mother, who had passed away that year.

Steve Mellon, Post-Gazette

Troy Hill resident Joe Pusaturi, 80, waves to firefighters responding to a call at Engine Co. 39, on March 16. City Council voted that day to close six fire stations, including Troy Hill's, the city's oldest at 104 years.

Click photo for larger image.

The bell is rung in celebration of good times, such as the annual New Year's Eve party at the station, and in respect of sad times, such as when the funeral procession passes by.

Advertise with us

Firefighters have become so ingrained in the community that they've been godfathers for babies, role models for future firefighters, invitees to weddings and, at times, pallbearers at funerals.

The firehouse's storied existence includes rumors of its haunting, again unique among city fire stations, with reported sightings of ghost firefighters playing cards.

Firefighters maintain the community's World War I Memorial near their station and the Western Pennsylvania Fire Fighters Memorial in Voegtly Cemetery, overlooking the Allegheny River.

Perhaps most important, in an ever-more-transient world, the fire station has been there since 1901, providing shelter from the cold for young and old waiting for a bus, a safe haven for those in need, a place where a helping hand, a shoulder to lean on or a sympathetic ear can be found at any time.

"You have no idea how much this will affect us mentally and socially as far as how we think about our neighborhood," Mary Wohleber, 88, a fifth-generation Troy Hill resident, told council members. "Our firehouse is the heartbeat of a town within a town."

Advertise with us

To understand Troy Hill, it is necessary to understand it's topography. The community, which in the 2000 census had 2,540 residents, was settled by German immigrants in the mid-1800s on a plateau that today forms the easternmost neighborhood on the city's North Side.

Down one side of the plateau is Route 28 and the Allegheny River; down the other is a valley.

"It's a very narrow ridge, 600 yards. I know because I measured it," said Wohleber, the neighborhood historian. "We're only a little bit over a mile long. We're all dead-end streets. We just do not naturally flow into other neighborhoods like other neighborhoods do.

"You really have to have a reason to come here. It's not a neighborhood you just pass through. It's not that simple."

But while topography may have cut the community off from others, it just as likely has had a role in making it tight-knit. Generations of people have made their homes on the hill, where American flags fly from neat rowhouses and houses of brick and wood. There are shops, professionals' offices, restaurants, small parks, churches (one with the second-most religious relics in the world, St. Anthony's Chapel), North Catholic High School and historic landmarks.

Advertise with us

Troy Hill has been the home of community leader Pinky McGlothin, 66, and her great-grandparents, grandparents, parents, children and grandchildren.

It's the closeness of the people that makes Troy Hill special, McGlothin said.

"You have to understand that neighbors here are like families. We sit up on a plateau. Everyone knows everyone. A lot of people are related.

"In fact, the joke is, 'Don't talk about anyone on Troy Hill because they're all related to each other,' " she said, laughing.

And at the hub is Engine Co. 39, at the intersection of Lowrie, Ley and Froman streets. Outside the white-brick building with its two arch-shaped truck bays is a life-size wooden sculpture of a firefighter carrying a child to safety. All that's missing from the Norman Rockwell tableau is a dalmatian and two elderly gents sitting on a bench.

Advertise with us

Actually, last Wednesday, only the dalmatian was missing. Lifelong residents John Weidner, 79, and Joe Pusaturi, 80, sat in the sunshine and spoke of sunnier days, almost as if appearing in the WQED documentary "Things That Aren't There Anymore."

"There used to be an incline right there, down to Herrs Island," Pusaturi said, motioning across the street to the hillside overlooking Route 28.

"And there was a nickelodeon there," Weidner offered.

"And that," Pusaturi said, pointing to a triangular building in the midst of the triangular intersection, "used to be a soda shop."

All gone. And now the fire station will be among them. The men shook their heads. The fire station bay opened. Dorsey and other firefighters jumped into their fire-safety vehicle, turned on the siren and sped off to a fire at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. They waved to Weidner and Pusaturi as they rushed off.

Advertise with us

Inside the station kitchen and sitting room, sugar cookies and doughnuts remained from the morning get-together held there before residents headed to City Council. Still visible on the white wooden wall are the outlines of the stalls that once held fire horses. An oat chute that dropped feed from the second floor remains. A large bulletin board is crammed with pictures of smiling neighbors and retired firefighters.

A knock. A young woman from a Head Start program entered to deliver students' entries in this year's Easter coloring contest sponsored by the firefighters. Master Firefighter John Arnold, a veteran of Engine 39 for 24 years, happily accepted the packet.

"I'll make sure the captain gets them," he said.

The woman smiled as she turned to leave. Arnold nodded in her direction. "This is a very unique fire station, and I'm not saying that just because I work here."

Dorsey and the firefighters returned from the call just as the residents arrived from City Council.

Advertise with us

"It's like getting the smile kicked out of a happy face," Dorsey said of council's decision to close the station. "It's very sad, very sad."

While some of the other 15 firefighters at Engine Co. 39 began bidding the next day on jobs at other stations, Dorsey said he wouldn't do so. Instead, he'll allow himself to be reassigned by the Fire Bureau administration.

"I promised these people I would never leave them," is how he explained his symbolic act. "And I won't."

The fire station will shut down for good tomorrow, but its Easter coloring contest will go on, as usual, with the Girl Scout troop from Troy Hill judging it.

And there to present the prizes, as usual, will be Fire Capt. Donald Dorsey, late of the former Engine Co. 39.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.