A proposed five-year, cost-cutting contract between Pittsburgh and its firefighters union actually is expected to lead to the hiring of dozens of firefighters.
That's because changes in health insurance for retirees beginning in 2006 are expected to drive many veteran firefighters into retirement, and the city probably will begin training a new class of firefighters to replace most of those who retire.
The deal, announced Wednesday by Mayor Tom Murphy and the firefighters union, appears to have the support of a majority on City Council, which is expected to discuss it Wednesday.
Candidates campaigning to replace Murphy when he retires at the end of the year disagree on whether the contract, which the new mayor would have to live with, would be a good deal for the city.
The contract would require those who retire after Jan. 1 to pay for any future increases in their health benefits, but those who retire before then would not have to pay.
The Fire Bureau is expected to face the same kind of exodus the police force had last year, when nearly double the usual number of 55 officers retired rather than wait for possible contract concessions that could have been imposed under a new contract awarded by an arbitrator in January.
Bob Kennedy, an aide to Murphy who oversees public safety, said there's no way to predict how many of the 868 firefighters will retire. The city is prepared to begin training new firefighters once it gets an idea of how many it will need.
"What we're going to have to do is wait and see once council and the union approve this and step back and see what happens," Kennedy said. "Then we'll know how many we'll need in the class."
The city expects to realize a savings of $10.7 million to $11.5 million annually through several changes: hiring new firefighters at the first-year rate of $29,000 a year, substantially lower than the pay of veteran firefighters; eliminating 108 vacant positions that will no longer have to be filled by others on overtime; eliminating six of the 44 fire units; cutting fire divisions from five to four, reducing the number of managers needed to supervise firefighters; reducing overtime pay from $330 per shift to $284 per shift; increasing insurance co-pays; and reducing paid holidays from 14 to 10.
City Solicitor Jacqueline Morrow said the city hasn't determined which six units to eliminate, or whether they will involve closing some of the 35 stations. Some stations have more than one unit.
The city can close the first six units without approval of firefighters, but the union could challenge any additional closures through arbitration if firefighters believe the changes would put them in danger. The city has long complained that the arbitration process ties its hands in dealing with police and firefighters, but Morrow said the clause limiting the arbitrator to consider only safety issues should be a benefit to the city.
Although the contract contains a lot of changes the city wanted, the union leadership agreed because the changes are less onerous than proposals from the city's Act 47 financial recovery team and a study done by a Texas consultant, said union attorney Joshua Bloom.
The study by ERASE Enterprises for the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority, another oversight group helping to straighten out the city's finances, recommended eliminating 13 fire stations and building three new ones, along with substantial staff and benefit reductions.
"The problem is, with the Act 47 board and the [ICA], it was so unlikely that we would convince an arbitrator or anyone else that we shouldn't make some changes," Bloom said. "This is basically the best we could do."
Although the city said it was happy with the safety standard for closing additional stations, Bloom said he didn't expect any more closures after the first six.
The union had claimed closing stations would put the city out of compliance with National Fire Protection Association guidelines for response time of four to eight minutes, but it agreed to drop a referendum to make those times a requirement.
"I think it would be very, very difficult for the city to prove it could close any additional stations and be able to meet response times or any other reasonable safety standards," Bloom said.
Most of the council members reached yesterday said they were in favor of the proposed pact, particularly because the contract was supported by Murphy and the city's Act 47 recovery team.
"If the savings are real, it's a good contract for city taxpayers," said council President Gene Ricciardi. "I like the cost controls. I like a five-year contract. A five-year contract allows [firefighters] to plan their lives."
Councilman Jim Motznik agreed.
"If there was a problem with it and either the Murphy administration or the union or the Act 47 coordinators had a problem with it, we would have heard about it by now," Motznik said.
Councilman Alan Hertzberg said he plans to bring the proposed contract to council on Wednesday for a preliminary vote in his capacity as chairman of the Finance and Budget Committee.
"There are going to have to be sacrifices made and we have to do it," he said. "We can't let the city die."
The council members all expressed concern about the exodus of veteran firefighters.
"The veterans who are there to mentor the younger people coming in would be leaving, so it's going to have a dramatic impact on the public safety of the city of Pittsburgh," Motznik said.
Councilman William Peduto, who's running for the Democratic nomination for mayor, said he agreed with most of the provisions of the contract, but was unhappy that it does not contain a reopener in 2007 in the event the city's revenue projections fall short. Without such a provision, Peduto said he plans to vote against the pact.
"I can't in good faith vote for it," he said.
Of particular concern is more than $20 million in revenue projections from slot machines in the next two years, which Peduto notes is not a proven source of income and could fall short, leaving the city in another financial rut.
"We're not taking into account the city's health when we have brand-new revenue streams that we never had before and we don't know how much it's going to bring in," he said. "We're still in extremely rough water."
Another mayoral candidate, former council President Bob O'Connor, said he supports the deal.
"The contract is an improvement over the last one," he said through a spokesman. "It saves $10 million a year and is a step in the right direction in protecting public safety."
The third Democratic candidate for mayor, county Prothonotary Michael Lamb, said Wednesday he hadn't reviewed the proposed contract and couldn't be reached for comment yesterday.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.