An architectural firm claims that the state and the University of Pittsburgh caused delays and cost overruns on the $119 million Petersen Events Center.

Apostolou Associates/Rosser International says Pitt and the state Department of General Services rejected its suggestions to trim costs and instead added features that pushed up the cost.

General Services "wanted the costs of the project to be reduced without eliminating items from the design," a goal, the firm says, that was "unattainable."

The architects claim they were directed to do extra design work without compensation and to speed up their work.

Advertise with us

Apostolou/Rosser made the allegations in response to a lawsuit that Pitt and General Services filed in December in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. The architects claim that Pitt filed its lawsuit "as a means of redirecting criticism on this project" that was raised by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in a series of stories published in April.

The newspaper's findings were consistent with many of the allegations now being made by the architects as well as by the state and the university.

The Post-Gazette reported that the project grew from $35 million when the basketball arena was proposed in 1992 to $119 million when it opened in October 2002.

Costs escalated initially because Pitt and General Services nearly doubled the size of the building and changed locations at the last minute.

After construction began, the state incurred $28.5 million in cost overruns over the original base cost, which experts said was about two to four times more than normal.

Advertise with us

Pitt and General Services claim in their lawsuit that the architects' drawings were deficient and resulted in costly fixes. They also claim that the architects worked too slowly.

Pitt and General Services did not specify the amount of damages but their lawsuit refers to cost overruns that the Post-Gazette has reported, including $10.8 million for architectural "errors and omissions" and $5.6 million in claims settlements with 14 contractors.

General Services built the arena for Pitt, and the state and the university split the costs. They paid Apostolou/Rosser $5.1 million.

The firm is a joint venture of Mount Washington-based Apostolou Associates and Atlanta-based Rosser International.

The architects have filed a counterclaim that puts the blame on Pitt and General Services.

Advertise with us

The architects say they were supposed to design the arena and prepare specifications for contractors to bid on. The winning contractors would then use completed designs to do their work.

But General Services changed the Petersen to a fast-track project in which bids are solicited from contractors before the designs are finished. The fast-track method is meant to speed up work, but it is risky because contractors must rely on incomplete drawings.

The architects claim that General Services and Pitt compounded the risk by continually changing the scope of the project, changing the location of the arena and mandating a faster schedule.

"The cumulative effect of these changes caused the cost of the project to balloon," Apostolou/Rosser claims.

General Services also demanded that the architects redesign the arena to fit within the state's budget. But each time they proposed ways to save money, according to the architects, General Services and Pitt rejected their ideas.

Advertise with us

By June 1999, the architects estimated that the arena would cost $68.5 million to build, but General Services directed them to design it for $55 million without reducing the scope of the work.

Then General Services awarded construction contracts that cost even more than the architects' estimates.

The architects also claim that state demands required them to work more than 15,000 extra hours without compensation. At one point, they say, they had to do six months of work in three months.

Apostolou/Rosser also has filed a claim for extra fees with General Services. They got no answer, so in August 2002 they sued General Services at the state Board of Claims, for $2.1 million. That case is pending.

The state has turned the claim over to Pitt because the university is required to pay all claims settlements.

Advertise with us

The architects say they have continued to supply Pitt with documentation to prove their claim. And throughout that claim's process, they say, Pitt never asked for the damages that it now demands in its lawsuit.

It wasn't until Pitt learned that the Post-Gazette intended to publish stories about the Petersen project that the university decided to file its own lawsuit, according to the architects, to deflect criticism from itself.

Pitt director of news Linda Schmitmeyer and General Services spokesman Frank Kane declined to comment on the architects' claims.

General Services and Pitt also filed a lawsuit claiming that mistakes by other contractors have caused the Petersen's dome to leak from more than 200 holes. Those contractors have not responded yet to the allegations.

The Petersen project included an upper campus chiller plant and a steamline system that were designed by another architectural firm. The two lawsuits and the Board of Claims case do not question that work.