One reason the city wants a financial recovery plan approved by the end of June is so it can cut salaries for city firefighters by 17 percent and avoid having to negotiate a wage reopener with the union.

Related article

Workers in city to feel the pinch under any Act 47 plan

On the Internet

Advertise with us

Read the full text of the 233-page Act 47 plan

Firefighters can reopen their four-year contract to negotiate wage increases beginning July 1. But if the recovery plan is approved by City Council and signed by Mayor Tom Murphy before then, the city administration maintains, the union would be required to accept a the 17.1 percent wage cut and benefit reductions required under the recovery plan.

The firefighters union vowed to fight the changes. The recovery plan released Wednesday also would freeze wages for most city employees for two years, require them to pay for health care benefits, and change work rules -- including not paying police officers for participating in court cases and eliminating officers' right to choose assignments by seniority.

"My first thought when I looked at this [recovery plan] was that I thought Andrew Carnegie had died, but it looks like he's running the city," said Fraternal Order of Police attorney Bryan Campbell, referring to the steel magnate famous for opposing unions.

"I'd say what it does is take away about our last 20 years of negotiating working conditions for our members. We're going to look into any legal steps we can take to fight this."

Advertise with us

The changes are necessary, Act 47 coordinator James Roberts said Wednesday, because the city's existing contract provisions are "cascading and combining to yield ever-increasing labor costs."

The controls are designed to get "back into management's hands the management of the city's workforce," he said.

One of the major recommendations directly affects firefighters, who have been at odds with Murphy over recommendations to close some fire stations. If it is approved by June 30, the Act 47 plan would require the city to cut $10.7 million from the firefighters' payroll, which amounts to a 17.1 percent wage decrease across the board.

The plan also calls for all union employees to begin paying 15 percent toward health-care benefits.

"That's what they think," fire union attorney Joshua Bloom said when asked about the city trying to cut wages. "I really don't think they can take $40 million, $20 million or $2 million. They can think that if they want. I really don't."

Advertise with us

Bloom dismissed the Act 47 team's findings, saying they were patterned on Murphy's five-year spending plan, which called for cutting 158 firefighter jobs and a number of fire stations, saving $9.3 million.

"They've adopted the mayor's plan, without question, which didn't do anything to maintain reasonable levels of public safety in terms of fire protection. You'd have to be asleep the last several months to not know the mayor has personal animosity toward the union," Bloom said. "To accept one side's proposal without question and not even entertain the other's opinion I think is arbitrary."

When the city and the fire union agreed to their contract (on the eve of the Democratic mayoral primary in 2001), according to Bloom, they agreed to July's reopener so they could negotiate additional wage increases, not wage cuts.

"They were talking about possible wage increases. Then to say, 'Oh, I reserve the right to get reductions,' is just not what was intended," he said.

Debate over the future of the Fire Bureau already was certain to occupy much of council's time as it mulls over the Act 47 plan, especially since it calls for the city to ultimately cut 168 firefighter jobs and seven of the city's 35 stations, starting in 2006.

Advertise with us

Council is due to take a final vote on the Act 47 plan June 29. The Act 47 coordinators have set a separate July 30 deadline for the state to approve new payroll taxes and a $120 occupation tax, saying the city will otherwise be forced to petition Common Pleas Court for commuter taxes.

Campbell said the recommendations limit whether officers can be paid for job-related court appearances, require drug and alcohol tests for anyone injured at work and take away the benefit of seniority. He questioned how the city would save money through the testing and seniority provisions.

"What financial benefit is it to the city to take a police officer who was punched in the mouth when he answered a call and give him a drug and alcohol test?" he asked.

The police and fire unions aren't the only ones affected by the recovery plan's recommendations.

"I had a feeling [the recommendations] wouldn't be good, but I didn't think it would be as bad as it is," said Henry Hurt, president of Local 2719 of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, which represents about 425 white-collar workers, including employees in the cable television bureau. Hurt would lose his production job in the cable bureau, which would be eliminated.

Advertise with us

"If they take away wages and benefits, there's not a whole lot more we can bargain for," Hurt said.

Fred Bell, whose Laborers Union is part of the Pittsburgh Joint Collective Bargaining Council that represents just over 400 employees whose contract doesn't expire until the end of 2006, said his group isn't eager to discuss givebacks before the contract expires. Bell's union represents garage mechanics whose jobs could be eliminated if the city follows the recommendation to privatize fleet maintenance.

"Right now, I don't think anybody is real interested in talking about cuts," Bell said. "I think it would be unlikely for us to consider anything without a rollback in directors' salaries."

The recovery plan also would freeze management salaries for two years, require contributions to health care and cut the staff of the mayor, controller and City Council by 15 percent.

For school crossing guards, health care changes that would require payment for anything more than individual coverage will be controversial because about half of the 166 guards are single parents. They make about $12,900 a year.

Advertise with us

"How are single parents going to [pay for family coverage]?" asked Marlene Lamanna, president of Local 192B of the Service Employees International Union, which represents the guards.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.