If the Downtown skyline seems to be getting brighter these days, your eyes aren't deceiving you.
Thanks in part to the views of the city from PNC Park and Heinz Field, Downtown corporations, businesses and hotels are more interested than ever in adding their names in neon to the Pittsburgh skyline.
Since 2001, nine businesses or institutions have received approval from city officials to erect "high wall" signs -- those at least 40 feet above ground -- to buildings Downtown, in the Strip District, or on the South Side.
They've included Citizens Bank, Sky Bank, the Art Institute of Pittsburgh and the Westin Convention Center hotel, all Downtown, and Seagate Technology in the Strip District, said city Zoning Administrator Bob Reppe.
More neon is on the way. Highmark has received approval from city officials to put its name and corporate logo on all four sides of Fifth Avenue Place. And Duquesne Light last week got planning commission assent to put its name in lights on the Chamber of Commerce Building.
"I think it's part of our commitment to the vitality of Downtown Pittsburgh as a commercial center. It also affirms our commitment to this region," Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said of the sign. "We look at it as really a commitment to being Downtown at a time it's important for leaders to stand up for the value of Downtown Pittsburgh."
Read More
Not everybody thinks a brighter skyline is a better skyline.
Chief among them is planning commission Chairman Tom Armstrong, who plans to call for a six-month moratorium on additional approvals during a forum on high walls signs being held today by the Riverlife Task Force.
"Some [signs] look better than others, but I think in the aggregate they cheapen the appearance of the skyline," he said.
Armstrong would like to see a halt to additional approvals while planners, members of the Riverlife Task Force and the public at large discuss the proliferation of such signs and their impact on the city's picturesque skyline.
"I think we ought to be very cautious in our future activities with high wall signs because I do think they make a significant change in the appearance of our skyline," he said.
The latest spurt in the demand for signs coincided with the opening of PNC Park, with the skyline as its backdrop, and, oddly enough, the adoption of an ordinance that banned rooftop signs and placed restrictions on "high wall" signs.
Under the ordinance, signs cannot cover more than two percent of a building, there can be no more than four of them on a building, and they must undergo a design review by the planning commission.
But Riverlife Task Force Executive Director Lisa Schroeder does not believe PNC Park was the only factor, noting that some of the more prominent signs -- Federated, Mellon Bank and Free Markets -- were in place before the stadiums opened.
Schroeder said she hopes today's forum will begin a public conversation on "high wall" signs and the impact they are having and will have on the Downtown skyline and its integrity.
"Our strongest concern from the time we first started looking at it was where is the point that the skyline becomes so cluttered that we lose singular beautiful element that is really an icon of Pittsburgh," she said.
Jeffrey Letwin, another planning commission member, opposes a moratorium. He believes the signs add to the city's vitality.
"I think the signs, with the standards we've imposed, are impressive. I think they make the skyline look pretty nice," he said. "Can you point to me one sign that has come on line the last two years that you can say detracted from the skyline or is an ugly sign? I can't think of any."
Letwin said he would not be opposed to seeing a sign on every tall building Downtown, noting that the number of skyscrapers are limited compared to a city like New York.
"There's something about a sign that gives a Downtown area a quality of excitement at night that there's something going on rather than lights out at dark," he said. "Here we are trying to generate interest in Downtown. I think it just enhances things."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.