Bob Donaldson, Post-Gazette

John Torkos is a frequent visitor to Panther Hollow Lake with his fly rod, even on a rainy day in January. The small lake is tucked in a valley in Pittsburgh's Schenley Park next to the CSX Railroad tracks.

Click photo for larger image.

John Torkos casts a nymph across the placid surface of his favorite lake. As it sinks, there's a telltale tug and he triumphantly lands an eight-inch crappie.

Advertise with us

"People are amazed that there are fish in here," said Torkos, the lone fisherman among Sunday morning strollers and dog walkers. "If they haven't been down here before, they're amazed there's a lake."

Barely visible from the Panther Hollow Bridge but accessible by several trails, Torkos is fishing Panther Hollow Lake, a one-acre impoundment created in 1909 when Phipps Run in Schenley Park was dammed for fishing, boating and ice-skating. A boathouse was built for renting canoes, handing out cane poles and serving hot chocolate by a fireplace on frosty afternoons.

Torkos remembers the boathouse, which is gone, from when he was 10 and his father took him fishing for stocked catfish and bass. Drawn by those memories, the 48-year-old parking lot attendant ventured back to the lake with his own children from their Greenfield home four years ago. Though it has silted in to half its original depth and hasn't been stocked since 1996, the lake still yields crappie, largemouth bass, bluegill and carp.

"Where there's life there's hope," said Torkos, who has seen big turtles come to the surface. "If they could make this lake the way it was, they'd draw a lot more people down here."

His vision is shared by the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy, the eight-year-old, non-profit organization partnering with the city to restore Pittsburgh's four largest parks -- Frick, Riverview, Highland and Schenley. Founded by former "Pittsburgh Magazine" publisher Meg Cheever, who had read about what the Central Park Conservancy has done for New York, the PPC three years ago published a 20-year, $100 million regional parks plan. Because of their size, those four parks receive most of their annual funding -- about $4.5 million for operating, and $700,000 for capital expenses -- from the Allegheny Regional Asset District, which allocates state sales tax revenues for cultural and recreation resources. RAD funding also has allowed the parks to sidestep the city budget crisis.

Advertise with us

Besides maps, snack stations and rest rooms, amenities park users asked for in a PPC survey, the plan addresses structural changes needed to make the parks viable again. In Schenley Park's case, drainage is a problem with 100-year old clay pipes broken and protruding, and unable to carry runoff to the lake. Hillsides are eroding, exposing the roots of large trees. "If we are to completely restore the Panther Hollow valley we've got to rethink how the water system functions, and that's no small task," Cheever said.

The 80-acre green heart of the park can be glimpsed from the deck of the Schenley Park visitor's center across from Phipps Conservatory at the entrance to the Panther Hollow Bridge. A trail from the visitors' center leads to the lake. So do steps in the Anderson playground, although they are badly in need of repair.

City crews will begin next month to reestablish Phipps Run, which feeds the lake, and they are in the process of reconfiguring trails that begin at Bartlett Street near the run's headwaters. These are first steps toward improving flow and reestablishing the wetlands that once filtered water to the lake, said assistant public works director Mike Gable. His crews are working in 3/10ths-of-a-mile increments, which should put them at the lake within two years.

Before dredging can be done, though, the antiquated storm water system has to be addressed and eroded areas replanted, some of which is going on now, said Gable.

Gable estimates it will take about $250,000 to dredge the lake and about $1 million for a new boathouse, projects that would require special funds through RAD or from the private sector.

Advertise with us

The lake is two-thirds its original 5-foot depth and so infertile that both Gable and Torkos marvel that it sustains any life. Yet, bass and crappie feed on young carp, and there is a steady source of damsel flies, dragon flies and other bugs. "Half the lake was greened over last year," said Torkos, who has explored it in a belly boat with portable depth finder. "Mud! I churned up mud the entire length from the stream end to the track end."

The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission supports the dredging because it sees urban fisheries as a way to attract new anglers in the wake of declining license sales. "We've tried to get the word out that we'll assist with the management of these lakes," said Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson, who had ordered the stockings up until eight years ago. "Silting is a common problem in these types of lakes, but once you dredge you can put small ponds up above to catch the muck. We can assist with management, water testing, providing fish, making sure it's all done right." Lorson has added dozens of urban lakes to the state's stocking schedule in recent years.

Pittsburgh's other impoundment, Lake Carnegie in Highland Park, also was stocked by the state until a few years ago and now depends on natural reproduction, although anglers add fish from the river. Unlike Panther Hollow Lake, which is fed by streams and runoff, Lake Carnegie gets water from two sources ... a city line and a babbling brook that dissipates chlorinated discharge from a micro-filtration plant. It doesn't have the same drainage problems, though catch basins that use to collect run-off have deteriorated. The lake has a concrete bottom and was deeper than Panther Hollow Lake when it was built at about the same time.

"We're lucky to get four feet at the center now, where it used to be 10," said Gable. Weed growth is a problem that the city controls with herbicides. It also needs to be dredged. And Gable would like to remove concrete pads and walkways added over the years that have shrunk the surface to about two-thirds of an acre.

"The idea is to make the water inviting even if people just come to dangle their toes," Gable said. "It's about removing barriers so people can touch the water."

Advertise with us

In a PPC survey, even folks who don't use the parks voiced support for their renovation, said Cheever. "The parks have been here for over 100 years and have been important to generations of Pittsburghers."

Torkos is a prime example. He introduced his daughters, now 11 and 8, to fishing at Panther Hollow, making them third generation park users. But he wonders if they'll be the last generation to toss bobbers into the lake.

"We need to get a Save the Lake thing going," he said. "It's not something I could do alone, but I'd sure help."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.