It's hard to determine who will hate Pittsburgh's huge parking tax increase the most -- parking operators, Downtown businesses or consumers.

City Council said yesterday that it will increase the parking tax, already the highest in the country, from 31 percent to 50 percent to balance the city's budget.

For a motorist who now pays $10 per day, if the entire increase is passed along by the parking operator, the fee would rise by nearly $1.50.

Business leaders and parking operators complained that the move will be counterproductive, chasing motorists from Downtown and failing to generate significant new revenue for the financially troubled city.

Advertise with us

Mariann Geyer, executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, said the planned increase "shows how out of touch the City Council and the mayor's office are with the challenges facing business, not just Downtown but in all of Pittsburgh."

Geyer said up to 49 percent of the 140,000 commuters to Downtown every weekday could be affected by the tax (the other 51 percent use public transit). If parking rates become too high, employees eventually could drive their companies out of business or out of town.

The tax increase "just goes on to promote the perception that it is expensive and exclusionary to be in Pittsburgh or to be in Downtown to carry on business," she said.

Merrill Stabile, president of Alco Parking Corp., had a similar reaction. Alco owns or manages about half of the 21,000 parking spaces in the Downtown area.

"I'm still a little shell-shocked. I can't overemphasize the negative impact this will have on the Downtown area. I think it's going to be counterproductive and it's going to happen right away."

Advertise with us

The city's parking tax has been at 31 percent since January 1998, when it was increased from 26 percent. That compares with a parking tax rate of 25 percent in San Francisco and 14 percent in Philadelphia.

The tax is levied on the parking operator's gross receipts. Currently, for every $1 collected, the lot operator gets about 76 cents and the city gets about 24 cents.

Parking operators currently pay the city $2.37 of every $10 they take at the parking booth, leaving them $7.63. To make the same amount under the new tax, they'd have to charge $11.45.

Whether lot operators will pass the entire cost of the tax increase to their patrons is uncertain. Stabile and other operators said prices will change by different amounts at different lots based on demand and current prices.

For example, Stabile said, he expects the lot his firm runs adjacent to Heinz Field to increase its daily parking rate from $3 to $4, slightly more than the amount needed to cover the tax increase. To balance that off, the company might increase rates by amounts slightly lower than the tax increase at other lots.

Advertise with us

Stabile contends the city did not receive the benefit it expected the last time it increased the parking tax. Although rates have increased at many lots and garages -- which would increase the amount of tax the city collects -- the city's parking tax revenue only increased from $28.4 million in 1998 to $30.9 million in 2001 and 2002, the last years for which information is available.

Rest assured the 50 percent tax will not be listed in promotional materials used to attract new business, conventioneers or other visitors.

"It's never good to be at the top of any list ranking the highest tax on this, that or another, when you want people to consider doing business with you," said Bill Flanagan of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development.

The conference, and a task force chaired by Republican doyen Elsie Hillman and former U.S. Steel Corp. Chairman David Roderick, last year proposed smaller increases to a variety of taxes on commuters, businesses and residents to keep any one group from paying too much.

Council currently plans to rush the tax increase through, introducing it today and approving it tomorrow. As of yesterday, only one of the nine council members, Sala Udin, was dead-set against it.

Advertise with us

Udin, who represents Downtown, said he instead will propose increasing city property taxes by 0.61 mills, the amount city schools decreased their taxes under a court order this year.

The Pittsburgh Parking Authority, a quasi-independent agency that operates on a not-for-profit basis, will have a board meeting Thursday to decide how to adjust its rates. The authority has 7,420 parking spaces, 6,525 of them in the Downtown area.