BUFFALO, N.Y. -- Twenty-eight stories above Buffalo, overlooking city hall, an unruffled Dorothy Johnson surveyed the fading metropolis that's hers to rescue.
Two weeks ago, Johnson was hired to head the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority, a nine-member state board with budget control powers. Created in July with New York Gov. George Pataki's signature, the board will oversee the development of a four-year fiscal plan for the city.
The board's mission, in shorthand: Save Buffalo.
"There's no silver bullet here," Johnson said, shrugging.
Johnson, a 14-year veteran of New York's state Budget Division, has fled the frying pan for the fire in her move to Buffalo. The city's mayor is being roundly criticized, police and fire cuts are being pondered, other layoffs are imminent, new tax revenues are being debated, a massive budget shortfall looms and there's no help coming from the state.
"Obviously, it won't be easy," Johnson said. "But it can be done. It has to be done."
Buffalo and Pittsburgh, in so many ways, are a couple of antique steam engines running on parallel tracks to financial insolvency. Which town gets there first, or manages to chart a new course, may depend on how well Johnson and her board do their job.
They must induce the city to cut its projected shortfall by a specified percentage each year for the next four. By the final year of the fiscal plan, according to the state legislation that designed the board, the shortfall should be nearly eliminated.
Compared with Pittsburgh's estimated $60 million budget shortfall, Buffalo's anticipated 2003-04 deficit of $24 million or so seems like the portrait of fiscal health. That gap, historically, has been patched with millions in state aid and by spending the city's reserves.
But this fiscal year, those city reserves are now empty, and the state, which last year sent $68 million Buffalo's way, is virtually tapped out.
"They don't have any more money to throw around," said Andrew Rudnick, one-time chief of the Buffalo Financial Planning Commission and head of the Buffalo Niagara Partnership, the city's de facto chamber of commerce.
"Prior to Sept. 11, Buffalo was receiving extraordinary state aid, an annual bailout. Now, New York can't continue its normal level of state aid, let alone an extraordinary level."
The board must mull these numbers: Buffalo is facing an estimated 2004-05 budget shortfall of $30 million to $48 million, discounting the sister shortfall belonging to the city's school district, which is paid for by the city but operated by an independent board.
If revenues decline and costs rise at current rates, city administrators are estimating a $127 million shortfall by 2006-07. Buffalo's budget this year is about $293 million.
Buffalo's plight, like Pittsburgh's, raised fundamental questions about what role American cities will assume in the 21st century, and how they are to be financed. In decades past, cities provided, and paid for, everything -- garbage service, parks, zoos, theaters -- because they could afford it, and because people who worked in the city generally lived there.
Mayor Anthony Masiello: "Instead of giving us change, they gave us cash . . . . Which I gladly took. It camouflaged all of our ills." (V.W.H. Campbell, Post-Gazette)
More on Pittsburgh's budget crisis:
47-year veteran of city workforce gets pink slip
City tries to collect millions in unpaid fines, tickets to ease budget woes
Municipal finances: Pittsburgh and Buffalo
See an index to the Metrovisions series
But in recent years, Buffalo and Pittsburgh increasingly were unable to pay for everything, because of a degenerating population and tax base, a growing percentage of tax-exempt properties, suburban business migration, and a general decline in the manufacturing and commerce industries that buoyed both cities for much of the 20th century.
Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy has likened the process to putting fingers in dikes, addressing the city's budget problems superficially, rather than on a structural, or legislative, level. His counterpart in Buffalo, Mayor Anthony Masiello, said structural change, initiated by the state Legislature, was necessary.
"Instead of giving us change, they gave us cash," Masiello said. "Which I gladly took. It camouflaged all of our ills."
Sagging value
Last year, Buffalo reached a dubious milepost; though it's by far the largest city population-wise in New York's Erie County, its property now has less tax value than the land and buildings in suburban Amherst, 12 miles away and not even half Buffalo's size.
Overall, Buffalo has seen its property value decrease by about $2 billion over the past three years. At least 40 percent of the city's property is tax exempt, an obstacle with which Pittsburgh is familiar.
And Buffalo is nearing the state limit for money it may collect by way of real estate taxes, meaning a property tax increase is out of the question.
"It's a signal that business as usual must change," Masiello said. "The traditional ways of running a city, we can't afford anymore. You can't just say, 'Here's your geographical area, and the city is supposed to live off of the property taxes.'
"We simply don't generate the kind of revenue that we need."
That means gutting the city's budget, and going toe-to-toe with the city's two largest labor groups, the police and fire unions.
This spring, Masiello and police negotiated a contract that will give police a hefty raise, as well as $8.1 million in retroactive pay. In exchange for the back pay, the city's 881-member police union, the Buffalo Police Benevolent Association, has agreed to thin its ranks by 200 officers over four years, through voluntary retirements.
Masiello said the contract would save the city up to $9 million a year by 2007, but his opponents say the possible savings will be more than negated by the checks being written for back pay.
Most notably, the pact and Masiello are being attacked by Erie County Executive Joel Giambra, who wants to merge the city police force with the county's sheriff's department.
In Pittsburgh, city officials are moving toward a merger of EMS and fire department workers, a consolidation that could save the city $7 million this year and $15 million in 2004.
Buffalo police, predictably, are against any merger talk, and won't be willing to bend much further on force reductions. But many officers are worried that the new budget oversight board will make union-busting its top priority.
"It's a millionaires' club," said police Lt. Sean O'Brien, during a union picnic at Buffalo's lakefront. "They want to put the burden of the city's fiscal woes on the working class -- garbage, parks department, police, fire."
The city is now negotiating a new contract with firefighters, who have always been paid equally to their police brethren. That won't happen this time around, according to the city.
"What they're saying is that they can no longer afford parity," said Joe Foley, president of the Buffalo Professional Firefighters union, whose 819 members have been working without an updated contract since July 2002.
"They wanted us to agree to a smaller raise than the [police union] got, then they wanted us to agree to mandatory layoffs, starting immediately," Foley said.
"I wasn't going to sell out 136 members for a $1,300 pay raise."
Other cuts could be around the corner. Masiello's 2003-04 budget calls for the elimination of 120 city jobs by the end of this fiscal year, which could save the city $4.5 million by next June. Some of those layoffs have been carried out, mostly in the building inspection offices, and others are pending approval of the oversight board.
Buffalo has exhausted most of its one-time expense dumps, handing many of its recreational expenses over to the county. Pittsburgh has taken a similar approach, selling off old liens, refinancing old loans.
Buffalo's downtown baseball park, home of the Buffalo Bisons, is now being operated by the county, as are the Buffalo Zoo and the historic Shea's Buffalo Theater.
The city is also discussing a raft of possible budget-related reforms: Having a part-time city council, forcing new employees to live in the city, asking the county to share its 1 percent sales tax revenue with the city, expanding the water and sewage service into the suburbs, privatizing skating rinks and city golf courses. None have been enacted.
And none of those revenues or cuts will have the long-term effect of closing the budget shortfall, unless the city's main costs -- fire, police and fringe benefits -- are lessened drastically. Those three expenses account for 72 percent of the city's budget.
Everything else, said Eva Hassett, commissioner of the city's administration and finance division, is ancillary.
"Whatever you cut, it will grow back," she said.
As in Pittsburgh, Masiello's administration views the current budget crisis as an opportunity to solve the city's budget problems, once and for all.
"This is our chance," Hassett said. "We are nearing the end of the system for cities as they are currently constructed."
Board the answer?
If there are to be wholesale reforms to the methods by which Buffalo collects and spends money, they will probably be put into effect by the oversight board, which has sweeping budget powers and is the strongest of the oversight boards operating in New York.
"Nobody really thinks the mayor can do what he says he's going to," said Rudnick, the Buffalo Niagara Partnership chief.
"That's why we've been pushing for this board from the beginning."
The oversight board must approve all new contracts and expenditures, and can also suspend certain provisions of existing pacts. It can't totally abrogate the contracts, though.
The board offers Pittsburgh a glimpse into its possible future. Mayor Murphy has said he would allow a fiscal review board to examine Pittsburgh's annual budget as part of a legislation package that would permit the city to raise its occupation and payroll taxes.
For now, the Buffalo board is studying the city's finances and hiring full-time staff members, such as Johnson. But that changes in September.
Buffalo is operating under the mayor's 2003-04 budget, adopted in May, but by Sept. 1, the city must submit to the oversight board a revised budget that will shave up to $8.4 million from this year's deficit. The city must also submit the rest of its four-year plan at that time.
After a two-week review, if the oversight board doesn't approve of the changes, this year's budget and the four-year plan are sent back to the city for additional revisions.
If the oversight board disapproves of the second round of changes, due at the end of September, the board may craft its own budget, for this year and the next three.
Thomas Baker, chairman of the oversight board and executive director of the philanthropic John R. Oishei Foundation, said the timetable was an ambitious one, but he acknowledged that permanent solutions to decades-old budget inequities were years, not months, away.
"Expectations of this getting better in a short period of time are ill-founded expectations," Baker said. "You can't turn the Queen Mary on a dime."
He pointed to Louisville, Ky., which has successfully regionalized all city services and earlier this year merged the city and county governments, creating one unified government. Overnight, the city's population jumped from 256,000 to nearly 700,000.
But that was a three-decade process, and voters shot down merger referendums in the early '80s.
In Buffalo, parochial attitudes have prevented any serious discussions of consolidation on such a comprehensive scale.
"I refer to it as the M-word," Baker said. "That's a systemic problem that both Pittsburgh and Buffalo deal with."
If archaic Buffalo is to save itself, salvation will be the end product of a test of political wills -- the will of the Masiello administration, which would prefer to solve the city's budget problems from the inside out, and the will of the control board, which has the final say on all budget matters and will entertain any and all cost-sharing proposals.
Hassett, who keeps a magic 8 ball on a windowsill in her office, said she had no idea how the crisis will be resolved, but knows that something must give by year's end.
"We can't possibly provide services this way anymore," she said.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.