HARRISBURG -- The Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board yesterday released its reasons for making the choices it did last month when it awarded licenses for two casinos that will be built on Philadelphia's riverfront, and one each in Bethlehem in the Lehigh Valley and in the Poconos.
The gaming board's release of the hundreds of pages starts the clock running on a 30-day period during which losing applicants may appeal.
Philadelphia
The Sugar House casino, to be built by HSP Gaming, will occupy a 22-acre plot on the Delaware River a couple of miles north of Center City.
The board said it likes the "synergy" the casino will create with Center City's many attractions, including restaurants, taverns, theaters and tourist destinations, such as Independence Hall, the Pennsylvania Convention Center and Reading Terminal Market.
The other casino will be built on the riverfront in South Philly, four miles from the Sugar House casino and a couple of miles south of Center City. Its developer is Philadelphia Entertainment and Development Partners, which is working with officials of Foxwoods, a huge 10-year-old casino in Connecticut owned and operated by a Pequot Indian tribe.
Members said Sugar House casino developer Neil Bluhm of Chicago has plenty of financial backing and builder Dan Keating has a good track record in successfully completing projects.
They said there was little neighborhood opposition to Sugar House, unlike there was with Donald Trump's TrumpStreet casino, proposed for Fishtown, a lower-income neighborhood several miles inland. The Trump casino was the only one of the five Philly proposals that wasn't on the Delaware River.
Foxwoods casino in Connecticut will provide great management skills and experience for its Philadelphia casino, gaming board members said, and its backers have agreed to give 42 percent of their profits for local charities, another factor the board liked. Foxwoods officials include Ed Snider, chairman of Comcast-Spectacor, which owns the Philadelphia 76ers basketball team and Flyers hockey team.
The board liked the fact that the Sugar House and Philadelphia Entertainment casinos are on the waterfront, which offers impressive views for visitors, and are insulated from neighborhoods by Interstate 95, which will provide ready access to both.
Gaming board Chairman Tad Decker, a Philadelphia lawyer, said one of the losing applicants, Pinnacle Entertainment, didn't seem interested in easing casino-related traffic congestion. Also, its site was near the Sugar House casino, and the board didn't want to approve two casinos so close to each other.
Neither of the two approved Philadelphia casinos has any connection to any Atlantic City casino, which means they will compete vigorously for business from gamblers, the board said.
One of Sugar House's investors is prominent Philadelphia lawyer Richard Sprague, who represents state Sen. Vincent Fumo, among many others. Mr. Fumo was a major backer of the slot machine legislation passed in 2004. Board members said political influence played no role in their decision. They noted that they didn't grant a license to either of the two bidders favored by Philadelphia Mayor John Street.
Lehigh Valley, Poconos
The board awarded the two casino licenses outside Pittsburgh and Philadelphia to Sands Bethworks in Bethlehem and Mount Airy in the Pocono Mountains for vastly different reasons.
There were five applicants for the two licenses, one near Gettysburg and two each in the Poconos and in the Bethlehem-Allentown area of the Lehigh Valley.
Near Gettysburg, Crossroads Gaming Resort & Spa proposed building a casino with 3,000 slot machines, restaurants, bars, a 225-room hotel, spa and self-parking garage on a 58-acre site in Straban Township, 2.5 miles from the historic battlefields.
The board turned down its application because of concerns about revenue projections, community objections to construction so close to the Civil War battlefields and the fact that it wouldn't open until 2009.
Projected annual tax revenue from Crossroads would have been the highest, at $277.5 million, but the developer indicated more than 60 percent of its revenue would come from out-of-state gamblers and it could lose 15 percent to 20 percent of its business if neighboring Maryland follows through on a proposal to legalize gambling.
Board member Jeff Coy said, "History was a factor" in his decision not to vote for the Gettysburg casino. Others were concerned about reducing tourists at the battlefield.
Once the board rejected the Gettysburg proposal, it was left to choose between the proposals for the Lehigh Valley and the Poconos. The law requires casinos to be at least 20 miles apart, except in Philadelphia.
The board said developers proposed quality projects in Bethlehem and Allentown. It chose Bethlehem because Sands Bethworks will redevelop the massive site of the former Bethlehem Steel Works and doesn't have a casino in Atlantic City.
The Sands Bethworks casino will be a two-phase project, with the first phase costing about $600 million and featuring a casino with 3,000 slot machines, a 300-room hotel, a 10-screen movie theater, restaurants and 120,000 square feet of retail space. The second phase would add 2,000 more slots, more retail space and property donated for a museum, public television station and an arts facility.
Major advantages are the site's location where it can draw from New York and New Jersey and its reuse of many buildings from the former steel plant.
Board member Sanford Rivers said that casino should do for Bethlehem what The Waterfront retail project has done for Homestead and the Pittsburgh area, bringing new life to what had been a brownfield industrial area.
Tropicana Pennsylvania, which proposed a casino complex with two hotels and other amenities on 24 acres, fell short because of concerns about traffic improvements needed near its site. The board also was concerned that Tropicana has a casino in Atlantic City and could use the Pennsylvania site to push customers to Atlantic City, where the tax rate is lower and potential profits higher.
In the Poconos, the board decided the former Mount Airy Lodge in the resort area in northeastern Pennsylvania was superior because it will be open sooner and include the longtime commitment to the area by developer Louis DeNaples.
The project will revitalize the long-closed resort, with the $375 million first phase including a casino with 3,000 slot machines, a 200-room hotel, a spa, restaurants and a 27-acre lake.
Pocono Manor was rejected because the board was concerned that its 23-story casino wasn't appropriate for the rural setting.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.