HARRISBURG — After asserting that “a white nationalist ... is quite a bit different than a white supremacist,” state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry, repeated Friday a charge that identifying a white nationalist as white is racist.
The strange war of words over the terminology of hate groups continued the day after Mr. Metcalfe created a stir Thursday, when he asserted his distinction about white nationalists versus white supremacists on the House floor and appeared to defend having invited a man with alleged white nationalist ties to testify before his state government committee this week.
Mr. Metcalfe was responding to comments by Rep. Leslie Acosta, D-Philadelphia, who said she felt silenced unfairly in Mr. Metcalfe’s state government committee Monday during a hearing on a bill to make English Pennsylvania's “official” language.
“I'm a duly elected member of this body,” she said. “My statements were ignored, silenced and disrespected.”
Mr. Metcalfe responded that Ms. Acosta incorrectly identified one of those who testified, saying that she said the person was “known to be a white supremacist associated with hate groups.” An email from the Southern Poverty Law Center identified one of the people testifying before Mr. Metcalfe’s committee as having white nationalist ties.
“There was an email that was put out alleging that somebody was a white nationalist, which is quite a bit different than a white supremacist, and to say that somebody is a nationalist and that they are for the independence of their country and a patriot to defending their country is a lot different than somebody saying somebody is a racist,” he said, according to an unofficial transcript of his remarks from the House floor.
“And for whoever said the man was white to be begin with, that person was actually the racist tying his skin color to his patriotism and what he stands up for for the country,” Mr. Metcalfe said.
Mr. Metcalfe stuck to his remarks Friday, saying, “Whoever made the assertion he was white was actually the racist,” and he said he believed the controversy was distracting from the merits of the legislation to make English Pennsylvania’s official language.
The Southern Poverty Law Center monitors domestic hate groups and extremists. An email from the group said Robert “Bob” Vandervoort, who testified at the Monday hearing, is the head of ProEnglish, which it identified as a “nativist extremist group.” On Monday, when asked about the characterization, Mr. Vandervoort said he does not consider himself a white nationalist.
White nationalist groups “espouse white supremacist or white separatist ideologies, often focusing on the alleged inferiority of nonwhites,” according to a definition on the Southern Poverty Law Center’s website.
Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, who has tangled with Mr. Metcalfe on a number of issues, said: “What is the difference between a white nationalist and a white supremacist? I think that’s parsing words. At the end of the day, they come close to meaning similar things.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.