After Carolyn Dumaresq stepped down from office in January as acting state Education Secretary, left behind was a compact disc that the agency says may contain documents from her 16-month tenure in office.

But the disc and its contents are shrouded in mystery because the Department of Education says the device is password-protected and it cannot access the documents it contains.

The agency said Monday it discovered the disc and the password feature while responding to an August Right-to-Know Law request from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, part of a yearlong effort by the newspaper to compel the agency to turn over emails from the former secretary.

The department “attempted to access any information on the disc by consulting the former secretary, along with utilizing available technology at its disposal,” states a footnote in a response sent to the newspaper Monday by Angela Riegel, the department’s Open Records Officer. “Those efforts were unsuccessful.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Riegel could not say why the agency was unable to obtain the password. Reached by phone Monday night, the former acting secretary said the reason is simple: It was the department’s information technology staff, not her, that created the disc, following what Ms. Dumaresq said is standard practice of taking material remaining on computer hard drives for safe keeping when employees leave.

She said she gave the agency her computer password when officials contacted her a week or two ago. She has not heard from the department since.

Ms. Riegel said it’s not unusual for documents to be turned over when employees leave. But she could not say if it is common for materials to be password-protected and how that fits into the agency’s practices for records retention. The agency is seeking help accessing the documents from the Commonwealth Office of Administration.

On Aug. 5, 2014, the Post-Gazette filed a Right-to-Know request seeking all of Ms. Dumaresq’s emails “as they pertain to the performance of her duties” since becoming acting secretary on Aug. 25, 2013.

The newspaper did so after she cited what she said was a departmental practice of purging emails each evening. She was trying to explain why the department released only five emails authored by Ron Tomalis, then Gov. Tom Corbett’s special adviser on higher education, during his first year in the job.

Advertise with us

Mr. Tomalis resigned in August 2014, weeks after a July 27 Post-Gazette article revealed he had a largely empty calendar, phone logs averaging just over a call per day, no written job description and a total of five emails written during his first year as special adviser, a position he was appointed to in June 2013.

In an Aug. 25, 2014 interview, Ms. Dumaresq told the newspaper that 700 of her emails had been gathered and were being reviewed in response to the Right-to-Know request. However, about two weeks later the department denied the request saying it was “insufficiently specific.”

The state Office of Open Records said the request was specific enough and ordered the agency on Oct. 27 to turn over the emails. But that determination was overturned in July by Commonwealth Court.