The same type of shell casings found at the scene of a party bus shooting in March 2013 were discovered at the site of Tiona Jackson’s slaying a month earlier, a firearms expert testified Tuesday.

The shells could link James Lawrence, who was convicted in March of third-degree murder in the shooting death of Steven Lee Jr. outside of a party bus in Sheraden, to Ms. Jackson’s death, which occurred outside of Red’s Bar in Beltzhoover on Feb. 28, 2013.

On the second day of the Beltzhoover bar trial, Raymond Everett, who works for the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office, testified that a computer program matched the .40-caliber cartridge cases found at the party bus scene with those in Beltzhoover, indicating that the same firearm was used in both incidents.

But Kayleigh Shebs, co-counsel for Mr. Lawrence from the Office of Conflict Counsel, said the link in shell casings doesn’t reveal anything about who fired the gun.

Advertise with us

“You can’t say who was holding that firearm that day, correct?” Ms. Shebs asked in cross-examination.

“No, ma’am,” responded Mr. Everett.

Mr. Everett was one of the last witnesses to testify before the prosecution rested its case.

One of the prosecution’s witnesses was Mr. Lawrence’s ex-girlfriend, Summer Kerley. On the stand, Ms. Kerley was shown a surveillance video of the outside of Red’s Bar. It showed a man and a woman exiting the bar and turning to the right toward Vincent Street, where the shooting occurred minutes later.

Shortly after the man and woman exited, four men left the bar and turned to the left. Within minutes, a tan Pontiac can be seen passing the bar along East Warrington Avenue toward Vincent.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kerley identified the car as her’s, saying she let Mr. Lawrence use it on occasion. She also identified the four men as Mr. Lawrence, Dorian Peebles, Devontay McFadden and Jerrick Lane-Bryant, and the woman who exited the bar first as Ms. Jackson.

Brent McCune, co-counsel for Mr. Lawrence, questioned Ms. Kerley’s credibility in the midst of a plea offer from the district attorney’s office. The deal would lessen charges she is facing in the party bus case in exchange for her testimony in Mr. Lawrence’s trial and in the upcoming trial of Mr. Peebles, a co-defendant with Mr. Lawrence.

Ms. Kerley said she had not yet accepted the deal.

The defense called its first witnesses to the stand as the day wound down.

D.L. Fullum, a former jitney driver, testified that he drove Mr. Lawrence to his home in Homewood before the shooting occurred. He said there was nothing unusual about Mr. Lawrence’s demeanor.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lawrence faces charges of homicide, conspiracy, carrying a firearm without a license, aggravated assault and reckless endangerment in relation to Ms. Jackson’s death and the shooting of Nigel Pryer.

The defense is expected to rest its case today.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette,com or 412-263-1488.