In its lawsuit against the city of Pittsburgh, the National Rifle Association may have to keep its powder dry. Late last week, a Commonwealth Court judge quashed the gun-rights group’s attempt to restart its case, which an Allegheny County judge put on ice last month.
The NRA sued over the gun laws of Pittsburgh, Lancaster and Philadelphia early this year. Those suits were filed under Act 192, a 2014 law allowing gun-rights groups to sue local municipalities over gun ordinances. But Act 192’s constitutionality has itself been challenged, in a separate case currently before Commonwealth Court. In March, Common Pleas Court Judge Judith L.A. Friedman issued a “stay” on the NRA lawsuit, putting it in limbo until the Act 192 challenge is resolved.
The NRA appealed that stay, but on Thursday, Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini quashed the appeal, writing that “an order granting a stay … is only appealable by permission” of the lower-court judge, who hadn’t been asked for it.
“The ruling can be appealed” to a panel of Commonwealth Court judges, said attorney Jonathan Goldstein, who represents the NRA. “We are exploring our options to assert the rights granted to us under Act 192.” The Philadelphia and Lancaster cases are proceeding, he noted.
Commonwealth Court heard arguments in the Act 192 case on April 15. There is no set deadline for it to issue a decision.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.