Motorists from Pittsburgh to Philadelphia and all points in between are prone to suspicions that their high-travel state is a web of bumpy, winding roads decorated with potholes, orange cones and bridge-out signs.
A new study says they’re right.
The “21st Annual Report on the Performance of State Highway Systems” put out this week by the Reason Foundation, a Los Angeles-based libertarian think tank, ranks Pennsylvania’s highway system as 41st among the 50 states based on 11 categories.
When the good news is that you’re not the worst, it’s not exactly a compliment.
It seems to be a race to the bottom. The ranking marks the third consecutive year Pennsylvania has slid down the list, having been No. 39 two years ago.
Wyoming garnered the highest marks, Hawaii the lowest.
Read More
“This isn’t an easy hand to play,” said David Hartgen, a retired transportation professor at the University of North Carolina and the report’s lead author.
“It’s a large system, and the budget is actually about average,” Mr. Hartgen said of the commonwealth’s 41,000-plus miles of state-controlled roads.
The state’s dilapidated bridges, narrow rural roads, comparatively high fatality rates and freeway congestion contributed to the low rating, even though it wasn’t terrible across the board.
Mr. Hartgen’s findings largely mirror those of the American Society of Civil Engineers. In its 2014 report card, it awarded the state a “D-” grade for roads and a “D+” for bridges.
“Although the recently signed Transportation Bill was an unprecedented, comprehensive package that will bring much-needed additional investment to the commonwealth’s transportation system, it is estimated that roadway needs will still not be met in 2019,” according to the civil engineers, referring to a road- and-bridge funding measure signed last year by Gov. Tom Corbett. “Simply keeping the road system from degrading, let alone improving it, requires more funding than is currently available in the budget.
That said, there is some good news for Pennsylvania.
“Not all the results are poor here. Actually the interstate system is in the middle of the pack and, in fact, the rural interstate system is rated 20th,” Mr. Hartgen said. “They’re doing pretty well maintaining pavement surfaces.”
The study relies heavily on 2012 data from the federal government that was supplied by individual states.
That means the information is nearly two years out of date and does not take into account the signing of Act 89, the transportation funding bill.
Mr. Hartgen and Rich Kirkpatrick, spokesman for the state Department of Transportation, said the spending package can only help Pennsylvania’s roads and bridges.
“This year alone, Act 89 is giving PennDOT the resources to invest roughly $600 million more in the highway and bridge network than otherwise would have been available, or about $2.1 billion in total this year. That’s at least 250 more projects this year, or more than 900 overall,” Mr. Kirkpatrick said.
What’s more, Mr. Kirkpatrick added, “Before Act 89, we were losing ground on pavement conditions, and progress we had made on bridges was threatened.”
PennDOT has shrunk the number of structurally dependent bridges to about 4,200 from a high of more than 6,000 in 2008, Mr. Kirkpatrick said.
Mr. Hartgen, a civil engineer by training, launched the study in the 1980s under the auspices of the University of North Carolina in Charlotte.
He said it is not meant to direct public policy in any particular way, and he noted that the report does not offer any conclusions or recommendations.
“Our goal here is just to get a handle on how the states are doing and whether they’re making progress or not and whether some issues remain,” Mr. Hartgen said.
“If you look at broader trends you can find some very useful findings. Contrary to public opinion and perhaps media opinion, the U.S. road system is getting better in almost all the dimensions we look at.”
While Mr. Kirkpatrick of PennDOT believes the prospects for improving road and bridge conditions in Pennsylvania are bright, he said the ranking system benefited states with “relatively small systems.”
Joining Wyoming at the top of the heap were Nebraska, South Dakota, South Carolina and Kansas.
“While we haven’t seen the full study, in the past, this ranking gave higher marks to states that spent less,” Mr. Kirkpatrick said.
“Pennsylvania has a big, old system. With Act 89, we expect to make progress in pavement and bridge conditions and expect that will be reflected in future reports.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.