ERIE -- When the Obama-Clinton feud is finally over, Andre and Gary Horton will still love each other.

But for now, the two brothers -- both longtime political activists in Erie -- may be well advised to get separate rooms at this summer's convention.

That's because Andre Horton, 48, is on the ballot as a candidate for Sen. Barack Obama, and his older brother Gary, 56, is on it as a delegate for Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton.

This particular familial split pretty much mirrors the Democratic Party across the nation and in this industrial city's political establishment. "The calls I'm getting from people wanting to volunteer for either candidate are running about 50/50 either way," said Cathi Zelezny, who chairs the Erie County Democratic party and is remaining neutral.

Advertise with us

Supporting Mrs. Clinton might seem a tough call for Gary Horton, given that her opponent could be elected the first black president, but he doesn't see it that way.

"I also have seven sisters and a very active mother," he said. "The women in our household have never taken a back seat to men. We consider it a source of pride that both a black man and a woman may win the highest spot in government. I don't think we can lose either way."

But as the dueling campaign rhetoric between Mrs. Clinton and Mr. Obama becomes ever more toxic, both Andre and Gary Horton can only shake their heads.

"Do I like all the sniping, the gamesmanship, the tit for tat? No," said Gary Horton. "But a lot of it is media hype, and I'm able to keep it in perspective. Will I hate Obama if he wins? Will he," -- he said, nodding at his 48-year Andre -- "hate Hillary if she wins? No."

"Usually we're on the same page, but this isn't your usual election," said Andre Horton. While there was no tension between the brothers, or in the family -- "I'd like to think most of them are for Obama," he added with a sly look at his brother.

Advertise with us

Gary and Andre Horton grew up in a family of 13 children, raised by parents who were local labor leaders and civil rights activists -- "I remember they had me hanging campaign brochures on door knobs when I was 7 or 8," said Andre, a construction worker. Schooled in the political arts, the brothers learned early how to fight, how to win and, most importantly, how to move on.

Living in the comfortable but crowded house on West 11th Street, in the shadow of the gigantic GE plant, "we didn't know we were poor," said Gary Horton. "If our car needed a new paint job, our dad would be out there in the driveway working on it himself, and we never thought it was in any way unusual."

Howard and Mildred Horton were strict but loving disciplinarians who stressed the value of education and hard work, even as the Horton brothers watched their bustling neighborhood fade away as numerous small tool and die companies closed their doors. Their house -- and the whole neighborhood -- was eventually razed for an urban renewal project.

"All of what we knew growing up is gone," said Gary Horton.

As head of the Urban Erie Community Development Corporation, which provides adult education, GED, computer and work force training programs, Gary Horton has followed in his parents' footsteps and has been active in Erie politics for a long time. He has known Mrs. Clinton and her husband, the former president, since 1992, when he served as the mayor's special assistant and was a Clinton delegate to the 1996 convention.

Advertise with us

That personal connection, and his admiration for Mrs. Clinton's experience and her advocacy for education and health care, made him come out for her early in the campaign.

He remembers the first time he met Mrs. Clinton, he admired a gold "USA" pin she was wearing.

"She took it off and gave it to me," he said. "I still have it."

The person he calls his "baby brother" just smiled.

"I'm ready for a new approach to government," Andre Horton said. "I don't want someone tied to the same old Washington tactics or policies of the past. Sen. Clinton, I believe, is part of that status quo."

Advertise with us

But, he added, "We grew up in a loving household, and we know what it's like to disagree. I'm not going to say we didn't fight -- we had fisticuffs, but at the end of the day, no matter what the outcome, we were still family, and when the nominee is selected, then we'll move on."

The Democratic party may do well to follow the Horton brothers' example, although Gary Horton said one question still nags at him.

"Will you drive me to the polls if I run out of gas on Election Day? " he said, looking at Andre Horton.

"Yes, but if the outcome means four more years of Republican government, you won't be able to afford any more gas," his brother shot back.