ST. CLAIRSVILLE, Ohio -- Sandra Melchiorre's question pretty well encapsulates the electoral mystery that has turned Ohio and Texas into the twin Alamos of the Hillary Rodham Clinton presidential campaign.
"It has me befuddled. How did this guy come up the way he did?" asked Mrs. Melchiorre as she hunched over a steaming cup at Sipper's Cafe.
The guy, better known as Barack Obama, has pressed in on Mrs. Clinton's once formidable leads in both states, swamped her in the last 11 primaries and caucuses and ripped the cloak of inevitability from the Clinton presidential campaign.
In Ohio, where she once held a lead in the double digits, late polls have given her a five-point margin, suggesting a win, but hardly the rout that was once her seeming entitlement. In Texas, Mr. Obama has drawn all but even in a place with 228 delegates there for the taking.
"My husband's voting for him. I just did not think he would do that," said Mrs. Melchiorre.
She would, of course, like to see Mrs. Clinton in the White House. Mrs. Melchiorre fits the demographic: an educated woman of 72 from a post-industrial state that seems to have been designed precisely for the people who loved Bill Clinton and were destined to embrace his wife. That's why thousands of them -- mostly women -- were shivering in a line outside the high school one block away, waiting for their heroine's arrival.
But Mrs. Melchiorre's husband was voting for "this guy" Obama. And the woman seated to her right, her own daughter, Debbie Gordon, 42, was wavering.
"I'm kind of in-between," said Mrs. Gordon. That she is "in between" says much about Mrs. Clinton's dilemma as she enters Tuesday's primaries in two states that most observers thought, a scant six months ago, would have been an exercise in delegates being piled atop an already established nomination.
Mrs. Gordon has a home health-care business. She's an ardent believer in national health insurance, Hillary Clinton's signature topic.
"Last night a couple of comments she made about health insurance didn't add up to me," said Mrs. Gordon. "And her tax return. She hasn't released it to the public. She's hiding something."
Clintons go all out
One thing she is not hiding is herself. Mrs. Clinton, and her husband, the former president, spent the week in a grinding series of visits that reached into Ohio's border counties -- out-of-the-way places like this one rich in blue-collar Democrats. On Wednesday night, she visited here and then Belpre, a town so small her forces booked hotel rooms across the river in long-ago-voted West Virginia.
In all, four states go to the polls Tuesday: Rhode Island, Vermont, Ohio and Texas. But the first two account for a handful of delegates and have been all but ignored both by the candidates and the media. The action -- frenetic, constant and at points raucous -- has been in Ohio and Texas, both states that could, in theory, abruptly end the contest for the Democratic nomination.
In a sign that he initially did not expect to overtake Mrs. Clinton in Ohio, Mr. Obama scheduled no further visits after last week's post-debate rally in Columbus. But on the heels of polls that now suggest he could draw even, Mr. Obama put together an evening rally in the Cleveland suburb of Parma last night and another one in Columbus at midday today.
In Texas, a Clinton loss -- at least a narrow one -- has been viewed as a wound, but a nonfatal one.
Not so Ohio.
Among the more than 1,000 people who lined up in the cold outside St. Clairsville High School -- a huge number of them women -- the frustration was evident.
"I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around what it is he does that was so great," said Melanie Valentine, who drove over from Cambridge, Ohio, to hear her preferred candidate, a woman she expected to have the nomination in hand by now.
"I'm a Hillary fan," she added. "I'll vote for Obama if I have to I guess. I'm having a harder time getting excited about him."
But with the Illinois senator's candidacy taking on the atmospherics of a movement, as opposed to Mrs. Clinton's more prosaic, if solid, point-by-point platform, Ohio is shaping up as the do-or-die state.
"If Hillary loses in Ohio, it's over," said Bert Rockman, a political scientist who has researched presidential politics at the University of Pittsburgh, Ohio State and, now, Purdue.
Trending toward Obama
While recent polls have given Mrs. Clinton a relatively comfortable six- to five-point margin in the final weeks, a poll released late last week by John Zogby, an independent pollster, puts her at 44 percent to Mr. Obama's 42 percent and a surprising 9 percent of the electorate undecided.
"It's trending Obama, as Texas is," said Mr. Zogby.
In fact, Mr. Zogby's poll shows Mr. Obama with a slight edge in Texas, something considered unimaginable a month ago, when the Clinton campaign strategy called for closing the nomination with a Super Tuesday coup de grace.
"The Clinton campaign could have done better by being a little more skeptical of its own inevitability," said Cal Jillson, a professor of political science at Southern Methodist University in Dallas.
The Texas phenomenon involves not a seismic event, but small Obama gains into the Clinton constituency. Hispanics, a pivotal element in the Democratic party there -- in fact, the group that has made the difference in keeping the Catholic vote Democratic -- are not abandoning Mrs. Clinton. Nor are they coming in the avalanche she needs, said Mr. Jillson.
"She needed two-thirds of that vote. If she gets 58 or 60 percent, that's not enough," Mr. Jillson said. Mr. Obama doesn't have to win the Hispanic vote, Mr. Jillson said. "All he has to do is eat into it."
This momentum shift, which has so perplexed Mrs. Melchiorre and her peers, could be more a function of the similarities between the candidates rather than any meaningful differences, says Paul Allen Beck, head of the political science department at Ohio State University.
"I think you come down, for many voters, to a choice that's based on what candidate has the best chance of winning," said Mr. Beck. "If you watch this guy Obama come from nowhere and build a lot of strength, win a lot of caucuses and primaries in a row, you change your estimate of who's going to have the best chance in the election."
The Obama campaign Friday made that sense of inevitability its working mantra.
David Plouffe, the Obama campaign manager, bluntly said Mrs. Clinton "will fail" on Tuesday, and recited Clinton campaign predictions that they would be tied or ahead in the delegate count by Tuesday's primaries.
Various counts have put Mr. Obama ahead by 100 to 150 delegates, with the outcome depending in large part on the sizable number of uncommitted "superdelegates" as well as delegate slates from Michigan and Florida, two states stripped of their convention seats for moving their primaries ahead. Mrs. Clinton remained on the ballot in both Florida and Michigan and has now advocated reinstating the slates from those states, which she won by default.
"The Clinton campaign has to begin winning big states by big margins to have any hope of erasing this delegate deficit," Mr. Plouffe of the Obama campaign said in a conference call to reporters.
He said Tuesday's outcomes were unlikely to result in a large delegate shift toward either campaign, an outcome that would set the stage for a showdown in Pennsylvania April 22.
Whether there will be a Pennsylvania showdown, say political experts, could very much rely on whether Mrs. Clinton can eke out a respectable showing in Texas and win Ohio by a wide enough margin to compensate for any Texas setback.
At the St. Clairsville rally, Mrs. Clinton showed up more than 40 minutes late, nursing a cough picked up in Ohio's fickle winter, and with a slightly revised message.
"How do you hire a president?" she asked the crowd. Think about the presidency as "more like a hiring choice than a voting choice," an implicit message that her political and real-world experience surpasses that of Mr. Obama, whose strong suit has been the less exact realm of oratory.
Doug Hattaway, a senior spokesman, hovered in the back of the gymnasium and acknowledged the subtle shift in the Clinton sales pitch.
"She feels like it's the toughest, most serious job in the world. We need a president who's ready to handle those challenges on day one," he said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.