HARRISBURG -- Ask state Sen. Gerald LaValle if his support for the legislative pay raises in 2005 is the reason he's retiring from the Legislature this year and you'll get a blunt answer.

"That wasn't the issue," the 75-year-old Beaver County Democrat said curtly. "That's all I'm going to say."

Another retiring lawmaker, Sen. Gibson Armstrong, wasn't as terse as Mr. LaValle, but he also said that his vote for the pay raises isn't the reason he doesn't want to go before voters again this year.

"I've accomplished what I wanted to accomplish," said the 64-year-old Lancaster Republican. He said he helped to get state funds for a new $170 million convention center and a minor league baseball stadium in Lancaster.

Advertise with us

He said it took him eight years to get the $50 million for the convention center, which "will revitalize downtown Lancaster. I wanted to stick around until I secured the funding."

Three other longtime state senators are retiring after the current two-year General Assembly term, which ends Nov. 30: Sens. Roger Madigan, 77, R-Bradford County; Constance Williams, 63, D-Delaware County; and Terry Punt, 58, R-Franklin.

All five had voted for the controversial July 2005 legislative pay raise measure, which was repealed four months later in the wake of voter anger. But because of their four-year terms, this would have been the first time they faced the voters since the furor over the raises.

Eric Epstein, a Harrisburg political activist who started a group called Rock the Capital to protest the pay raises, sees a connection between the retirements and the pay raise votes.

"The pay raise was a self-administered dose of political arsenic with a shelf life of three years," he said. "Some will evade political death, but none will escape the shadow of the vote."

Advertise with us

Mr. Epstein is keeping track of whether legislators voluntarily paid back their raises to the state treasury. He said the Senate clerk indicated that Mr. Armstrong, Mr. Madigan and Mr. Punt paid back the full amount, $7,708, while Mr. LaValle still has $4,539 to repay. An aide said that while Ms. Williams voted for the raises, she never took the money and so had nothing to return.

But G. Terry Madonna, a Franklin & Marshall College political science professor and political pollster, downplays the lingering effect of the pay raises.

"I don't think it's a critical issue any more," he said. "I've talked to enough legislators who are leaving to know there is a general frustration level with what's going on in Harrisburg.

"The environment is pretty hostile. They hear constant harangues and criticism about the General Assembly. They're like anyone else -- they want to be loved, and all that criticism can be grating. Sometimes the legislative process just grinds you down."

The five senators will be joining 16 House members who also have decided not to seek re-election.

Advertise with us

House members who are departing on Nov. 30 include southwestern Pennsylvania Reps. Tom Petrone, D-West End; Tom Tangretti, D-Hempfield; Ed Wojnaroski, D-Cambria; Tom Yewcic, D-Cambria; Jess Stairs, R-Westmoreland; and Lisa Bennington, D-Morningside.

All but Ms. Bennington are retiring after many years at the Capitol. She was elected in 2006 but wants to return to her divorce law practice.

Fewer legislators -- 21 total -- are leaving this year than the 31 who chose not to run again in early 2006, when voter anger still raged over the pay raises. Altogether, 55 left the Legislature in December 2006, either through voluntary retirement or by being defeated in the May primary or November general elections of 2006.

Mr. LaValle, a former mayor of Rochester in Beaver County and a former Beaver County commissioner, was first elected to the Senate in 1990. In his retirement announcement, he didn't give any reasons for leaving but said he took "great pride in having had the opportunity to represent the good people of the 47th District."

In his retirement news release, Mr. Madigan called his Senate tenure, which began in 1984, "a labor of love." As Senate Transportation Committee chairman, he is "proud of what we have done in recent years to improve our transportation system," including passage of Act 44 in July.

Advertise with us

Act 44 will raise Pennsylvania Turnpike tolls by 25 percent next year, and seeks federal approval to put first-time tolls on Interstate 80 as a way of raising nearly $1 billion a year for roads, bridges and mass transit. He voted for Act 44, but many people in north-central Pennsylvania have strongly criticized the attempt to put tolls on I-80.

Mr. Punt has been in the Senate for 20 years and was in the House for 10 years before that. He has had health problems recently and said he wanted to have more time with his children. He said he has brought $17 million in state funds for farming, highways and bridges into his district.

Ms. Williams has been in the Legislature since 1997 and a senator since 2001.

"The time has come for someone else to have the incredible opportunity that I have had," she said in a statement. "I intend to stay involved [in politics] and to fight for what I believe in. It just won't be as an elected official."