HARRISBURG -- One is a former elementary schoolteacher, another a former stand-up comedian and a third a former nurse.
All of them want to be on the state Superior Court.
In all, six candidates are running for three open seats on the bench.
Four of the candidates -- Republicans Cheryl Allen and Jacqueline Shogan, and Democrats Ron Folino and Christine Donohue -- live or work in Allegheny County. The others, Bruce Bratton and John Younge, are from suburban Harrisburg and Philadelphia, respectively.
CHERYL ALLEN
Cheryl Allen
The career assessment test Cheryl Allen took as a freshman at Penn State University showed she was well-suited to become a counselor, minister or lawyer.
Now, she is on the bench of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, a speaker at women's prayer breakfasts and a founder of the Parent Mentoring Project, where volunteers counsel young mothers in Allegheny County.
First, though, she spent three years teaching second grade in Pittsburgh.
Around that time, she met some students and learned that the University of Pittsburgh School of Law was recruiting minority students, particularly African-Americans.
After graduating, she worked as a lawyer for Neighborhood Legal Services, the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission and the Allegheny County Law Department.
In 1990, she was appointed to Common Pleas Court -- filling Ralph Cappy's seat when he was elected to the Supreme Court -- and has served there ever since, mostly in juvenile court.
Among the things she is most proud of is her work to keep young offenders out of jail and out of Shuman Juvenile Detention Center, which had become overcrowded. To achieve that, she worked to bring in the Youth Enrichment Services Diversion Program, which assigns caseworkers to monitor young offenders at their homes and schools.
Judge Allen, 59, lives in Hampton. She is married to James Skipwith and has three sons and five grandchildren.
BRUCE BRATTON
Bruce Bratton
Bruce Bratton has long been fascinated by the way people interact with government.
He expected to study that relationship academically as a historian, but instead ended up with a much closer view of it as a Dauphin County Common Pleas judge.
Now, Judge Bratton, 58, wants his decisions to have a longer reach by rendering decisions that set statewide precedent.
And, he said, he's the perfect person to do it.
"I have had 25 years' experience as a lawyer and a little over six as a judge handling all kinds of cases from adoption to zoning," said Judge Bratton, a Republican. "I have the broadest and longest experience [among Superior Court candidates] handling all kinds of cases. Who better qualified to review transcripts and decide whether everyone got a fair shake, whether the judge made a mistake as to law?"
That doesn't mean it's easy.
There are times when he would like to be more lenient, to give down-on-their-luck defendants a chance to get their lives together at home instead of behind bars, but mandatory sentencing laws prevent it.
"I can only do what I am civically authorized to do, and that's how it should be. Governments should be limited," Judge Bratton said.
Judges should interpret and follow existing laws, not create new ones, he said.
Judge Bratton grew up in Mifflin County in Bratton, a township named for his ancestors who settled there. He now lives outside Harrisburg in Susquehanna Township.
He is married to Holly Bratton and has a 25-year-old son and a 23-year-old stepson.
Judge Bratton is a Vietnam veteran and a graduate of Penn State University and the University of Pennsylvania School of Law.
CHRISTINE DONOHUE
Christine Donohue
Christine Donohue knows that sitting on the state Superior Court is a huge responsibility. She also believes she is up to the challenge.
Currently a commercial litigator for Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney in Pittsburgh, Mrs. Donohue has 27 years' experience as a trial lawyer.
She wants to sit on the Superior Court because, she said, its judges have the greatest effect on Pennsylvanians, even more than the state Supreme Court. That's because all litigants in trial courts have the right to have appeals heard before the Superior Court.
She believes all of the court's opinions should be published and, therefore, become precedent. Currently, the court issues many of its opinions as memoranda, which means the decisions apply only to the facts of a particular case and do not become precedent.
Ms. Donohue, a Democrat, never has held elected office, but does have experience as a judge. She served a three-year appointment to the Pennsylvania Court of Judicial Discipline, where she made several difficult decisions.
"It's always a hard decision when you have lawyers and judges who are accused of wrongdoing," she said.
"There's nothing more important to the legal system than the integrity of its lawyers and judges. The minute people lose confidence in that, you have a big problem with the whole branch of government."
Ms. Donohue, 54, grew up in Carbon County, She received her bachelor's degree in political science from East Stroudsburg University and her law degree from Duquesne University.
She is a trustee of The National Aviary of Pittsburgh, past president of the Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association and a charter member of the Allegheny Bar Foundation.
RON FOLINO
Ron Folino
If everything had worked out according to Ron Folino's childhood dream, he would be a shortstop for the Pirates.
Instead, he is a Common Pleas judge in Allegheny County and now a Democratic candidate for Superior Court.
He also is a former stand-up comic, but gave it up because he wanted a career that would make more of a difference in people's lives.
Mr. Folino, 53, draws upon his experience at The Comic Strip in New York City, even in serious court cases.
"Humor really helps in the courtroom. People are so tense when they come to court and when they're nervous it's hard to get the truth to come out," he said. "Humor relaxes them."
Still, when it comes to rendering decisions, no one takes the responsibility more seriously.
"I understand the decisions I make impact people very strongly," he said. "I realize that when people come to court it's the most important thing in their lives."
Judge Folino is married to Lois Folino, who recently retired as director of volunteer services at West Penn Hospital. He considers his mother, Margaret, his hero and role model.
He was raised in Penn Hills and graduated from Penn State University and Dickinson School of Law.
He has been on the Common Pleas Court for 14 years.
In a survey of its 8,000 attorneys, the Allegheny County Bar Association recently gave him the highest overall ranking of all 70 state and federal judges in the county and ranked him No. 1 for impartiality and temperament, and ranked him in the top three for diligence and legal ability. The ratings came in surveys conducted in 2000 and 2004.
He also has received the highest rating by the Pennsylvania Judicial Review Board.
JACQUELINE SHOGAN
Name
Jacqueline Shogan, of Murrysville, is used to taking care of people.
That's what she has done as a nurse, as a mother and as a lawyer specializing in health law.
Now she wants to take care of litigants in court cases that run the gamut from child custody to wiretapping.
She says her background gives her a unique perspective that would make her an effective, thoughtful and impartial judge on the Superior Court.
She had been a nurse for 12 years when she decided to turn her attention to her long-standing interest in public policy and the legal system.
With a bachelor's degree in nursing from Temple University and a master's degree in nursing from the University of Virginia, Mrs. Shogan graduated in 1990 from the Duke University School of Law in North Carolina.
After graduating, she practiced for eight years in civil litigation, health law and administrative law, then spent four years as an attorney on the staff of Justice Maurice Cohill of the U.S. District Court for Western Pennsylvania.
Ms. Shogan, 54, is currently with Thorp Reed & Armstrong in Pittsburgh and has a special interest in children's and health care issues.
She also teaches appellate practice at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.
She is president-elect of Neighborhood Legal Services Association and a past member of the Board of Trustees of Edmund's Academy in Pittsburgh and the board of directors of Easter Seals in Western Pennsylvania.
Superior Court judge is a position she has been seeking for two years. She ran in the spring primary but came in third in a seven-way race.
Another ballot spot opened up later, when Superior Court Judge Michael Joyce, of Erie, was charged with insurance fraud and announced he would retire.
She married her high school sweetheart, Jeff Shogan, an oncologist at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. They have a 23-year-old daughter, and two sons, ages 16 and 14.
JOHN YOUNGE
John Younge
John Younge has been a judge for 12 years, but the toughest decision of his life had more to do with white wedding dresses and churches than black robes and courtrooms.
He says getting married was the hardest decision he's ever made, and it turned out to be the best one, too. Ever since Joy May Brown became Joy May Brown-Younge, his life has been getting better and better, he said.
"I never accomplished anything until I married my wife," he said. "Call it a coincidence, but I don't know."
He graduated from Boston University and the Howard University School of Law before becoming executive director and general counsel to the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority. He also worked as an attorney in private practice and, in 1995, was elected to the Common Pleas Court of Philadelphia.
The next accomplishment, he hopes, will be his election to the Pennsylvania Superior Court.
Judge Younge will tell you his qualifications if you ask, but he'd rather talk about his wife, his three children, his church or, most recently, his Democratic running mates: Ms. Donohue and Judge Folino.
"They're good people and they have a demonstrated commitment to giving back to the community," Judge Younge said.
So does he.
Judge Younge is chairman of the West Philadelphia Community Mental Health Consortium, president of the Cobbs Creek Environmental Education Center, past president of the Friends of the Free Library of Philadelphia and deacon of the 7,000-member Sharon Baptist Church in Philadelphia.
The Pennsylvania AFL-CIO, which was one of the first organizations to endorse Judge Younge, says he is the right choice for union workers.
Judge Younge lives in the Wynnefield section of Philadelphia with his wife and three children.
Correction/Clarification: (Published Oct. 30, 2007) This story as originally published Oct. 28, 2007 incorrectly reported Superior Court candidate Jackie Shogan's finish in the May primary and her dates of attendance at Duke University. She finished third in the primary and graduated from Duke University School of Law in 1990.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.