HARRISBURG -- Former Lt. Gov. Bill Scranton is calling on House Republicans to flatly reject the $27.3 billion state budget that Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell has proposed for the fiscal year starting July 1.

Mr. Scranton, a Republican businessman who briefly ran for governor in early 2006, blasted the Rendell budget yesterday as "a document of incredible audacity and ambition. With seven tax increases, it would have a devastating effect on the state. His tax-and-spend plans will have a direct effect on families. Even Democrats are having difficulty swallowing this budget."

The attack by Mr. Scranton, who was lieutenant governor from 1979 to 1986 and retains considerable clout in the party, was just the latest sign that a serious budget standoff is shaping up at the Capitol.

Some leaders are privately predicting that a long, hot summer lies ahead as the budget fight becomes more contentious. Some are even recalling the standoff of 2003, Mr. Rendell's first year in office, when the new budget wasn't adopted until late December.

Advertise with us

Mr. Scranton said Mr. Rendell wants to borrow an additional $850 million for some programs -- increasing state debt for the next 30 years -- and slap a 6.17 percent tax on oil company profits, which Mr. Scranton said would just raise gasoline prices. He complained the governor wants to impose payroll taxes on businesses that don't offer health insurance and raise the state sales tax from 6 percent to 7 percent.

"That's a 16 percent increase in the sales tax -- 1 percentage point but 16 percent," he told the House Republican Policy Committee, a group headed by Rep. Mike Turzai, R-Bradford Woods, which airs policy issues. "There is no evidence available to show that a state can tax itself into economic viability."

Mr. Turzai and other House Republicans warmly praised Mr. Scranton for his comments and vowed to give them strong consideration during the coming budget debate.

Rendell spokesman Chuck Ardo fired back, saying: "We understand this will be a difficult budget, but we believe the governor's proposals are important if Pennsylvania is to move forward."

Mr. Ardo said the Rendell budget "is reasonable and responsible and addresses many of the challenges Pennsylvania faces," such as solving "the transportation funding crisis" by generating money to repair ailing roads and bridges and to aid struggling mass transit agencies.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ardo said the Rendell plan to promote alternative forms of energy is "good for the environment, the economy and the long-term national security by making us less dependent on foreign oil."

The 2007-08 budget is supposed to be adopted by June 30, but so far House Democrats, who control the chamber by a slim 102-101 margin, haven't even submitted the annual "fake budget" to the full House for debate and a vote. It's an annual exercise here, one that was led by Republicans since 1995 because they controlled the House -- until this year. Each legislator gets to include his or her own pet project in this House version of a budget, but everyone involved in the process knows that it won't be the final version enacted. It's done primarily so that House members can put out news releases for the home folks saying they'd voted for funding of local projects, knowing full well that the money wouldn't be in the final version signed by the governor.

After House passage, the "wish list" budget proposal heads to the Senate, where most of the pet projects from the House are stripped off to reduce overall state spending to a certain degree.

But even that early, fake budget -- a term that both Democratic and Republican legislators hate -- is late in coming this year. It's usually acted on in April.

"Only 54 days until July 1, and still no budget has been introduced [by Democratic leaders], let alone debated and voted on," House GOP spokesman Steve Miskin said yesterday. "What are they waiting for?"

Advertise with us

A 2007-08 budget proposed, as required by law, by Gov. Rendell in February, will be used at the framework, as is typically the case. Democratic officials said yesterday that Rendell budget will be introduced tomorrow and the House will vote on it May 21, 22 or 23. After tomorrow, those will be the only days in May that the House is in session. Both the House and Senate will return to work June 4.

"This is not an easy budget. We still face difficult decisions," Rep. Dwight Evans, D-Philadelphia, who chairs the House Appropriations Committee, said yesterday.

Democrats have been saying they need more details on 2006-07 revenue collections before they introduced a new budget.

As of April 30, the Revenue Department now says, the state had collected $22.8 billion in sales, income, corporate and other taxes. That amount is $208 million above what officials earlier had estimated would be in hand by April 30.

But the current surplus is far less than the $850 million surplus that was on hand as of June 30, 2006. That means legislators will have less surplus funds to use in 2007-08, another factor complicating budget negotiations.

Advertise with us

Reform of legislative procedures is another time-consuming issue that will slow things down in coming weeks. The first step comes today, as the Senate's State Government Committee discusses several key changes in General Assembly procedures.

These include bills to reduce the size of the current 203-member House and 50-member Senate; limit the number of terms a lawmaker can serve; eliminate lame-duck sessions, the three-week sessions held after the November election in even-numbered years; change the way Senate and House district lines are redrawn after each census; and give Pennsylvanians the power of "initiative and referendum," so residents can have measures enacted, as is now done in California.

And there's more potential sand in the wheels:

The narrow margin by which Democrats run the House is problematic. If all 101 Republicans vote "no" on Mr. Rendell's budget, all 102 Democrats would have to vote "yes," leaving them vulnerable to "tax and spend" charges.

Many legislators are afraid to enact the governor's tax hikes, especially the higher sales tax, which would cost taxpayers an extra $1.4 billion. A vote for higher taxes gives an opponent a big weapon to use against an incumbent when he or she runs for re-election next year. Incumbents know voters are already angry over the 2005 pay raises, which caused 55 legislators either to lose re-election in 2006 or retire so they didn't have to face voters.

Advertise with us

Huge differences of opinion exist over how to generate an additional $965 million per year to fix roads and bridges and $760 million per year for mass transit.

There are widely divergent views on how to deliver broad-based property tax relief to middle-income homeowners.

Many are concerned the Rendell plan to extend health care insurance to 800,000 uninsured adults could mean higher business taxes.