HARRISBURG -- Tax rates under Lynn Swann's proposed property tax overhaul may have to be higher than the 2 percent maximum he has cited, a top aide to the Republican gubernatorial candidate said yesterday.

Ray Zaborney, Mr. Swann's campaign director, acknowledged that possibility in response to state data provided by The Associated Press suggesting that a 2 percent maximum would not allow school districts, municipalities and counties to collect as much revenue as they do now.

Mr. Zaborney said, however, that Mr. Swann is committed to ensuring that his plan would not force local spending cuts or tax increases on individuals. The reorganized tax rates are supposed to be "revenue-neutral," meaning that local governments would get the same amount of revenue as they would without the consolidation.

"It's hard to say what revenue-neutral is four years from now," Mr. Zaborney said.

Advertise with us

According to state data from 2003, property tax collections equaled 2.5 percent of the market value of taxable real estate in Pennsylvania that year -- or $2.3 billion more than would be collected at a tax rate of 2 percent.

During the 2003 calendar year and the 2003-2004 school year, the latest periods for which information is available, combined local property tax collections were $11.85 billion, according to the Department of Education and the Department of Community and Economic Development. The market value of taxable real estate in Pennsylvania in 2003 was $478.4 billion, according to the State Tax Equalization Board.

Mr. Swann, the former Steelers star and sideline reporter for ABC Sports, is challenging Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell, who is seeking a second term in the November general election.

Mr. Swann's wide-ranging plan to reshape the way property is taxed would take several years to implement because one key aspect -- changing the basis of a property owner's tax bill to the property's market value rather than assessed value -- requires a constitutional amendment. Such a change requires approval by two consecutive legislatures and ratification by the voters.

His plan, aimed at making property tax bills more stable and predictable, would immediately limit increases to 3 percent a year. Once the constitution is changed, assessments would be frozen and valuations would change only when a property is sold or substantially renovated.

Advertise with us

A Rendell campaign spokesman said Mr. Swann's proposal may sound good politically, but lacks sound policy.

"This is just more evidence that Swann doesn't know or care anything about how government actually works," the spokesman, Dan Fee, said.

In an interview last week, Mr. Swann dismissed suggestions that his plan may not work as advertised. He maintained that his new taxing system could tap surplus state dollars, savings from consolidating school district health care insurance and anticipated revenue from slot-machine gambling to ensure that the changeover does not force local governments to cut spending.