Whoever said "the shortest distance between two points is under construction" no doubt spent time in Pittsburgh.
Newcomers to our city quickly realize with dismay that a grid has more to do with football than street patterns, and those funny little cobblestone alleys show up as real streets on maps.
So, good luck with that whole GPS thing.
A reader from the middle of the state wrote to say that she was once directed onto the Port Authority busway. A new resident said he was told his exit from the Fort Pitt Bridge would be on the left, and got lost when he realized -- too late in rush-hour traffic -- that wasn't the case.
In the name of casual science, we gathered up several GPS devices and instructed them to plot courses to two locations. The first involved highways and city streets, the second, a labyrinth of rural back roads.
Involved were two Garmin Nuvi units, two TomToms and an iPhone. For good measure, we gave MapQuest and Google maps a shot at it, too.
Route No. 1:
South Hills Village Mall in Bethel Park to the Fe Arts Gallery on Butler Street in Lawrenceville.
All of the GPS devices as well as the online mapping sites choose the following: Follow Route 19 North to Banksville Road and through the Fort Pitt Tunnel. Pick up Interstate 279 to Route 28 North, then turn right onto the 40th Street Bridge. Turn left onto Butler Street.
Obviously, this would not be the fastest route in afternoon rush-hour traffic. But the alternative -- drive into the Golden Triangle, take the 10th Street Bypass to Liberty Avenue, then Penn Avenue into Lawrenceville -- is the sort of route not recommended for out-of-towners.
Route No. 2:
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette building on the Boulevard of the Allies, Downtown, to Gambier, Ohio.
There is no simple way to reach Kenyon College. All of the maps and the GPS devices agree that for the first two-thirds of the trip, drivers should follow the Parkway West to Interstate 79 South, then Interstate 70 West. From there, one guess seems as good as another.
Once leaving the interstate, the roads are two lanes that wind through rolling terrain -- a great deal of farm land, not a great deal of landmarks. It is possible to get spectacularly lost in the middle of this, even with GPS.
The iPhone and three of the GPS devices opted to exit at 153B in Zanesville, which eventually leads up Ohio Road 146 West. From there, they direct drivers to Blackrun Road to South Market, then New Castle Road and Wiggins before arriving in the very tiny town.
One Garmin Nuvi and Google maps suggested a slightly different version of this route, but a personal favorite was reached after much trial and error, in addition to studying an old-fashioned paper map of Ohio: Exit 153 in Zanesville to State Street. Left onto 146, then a long stretch on 586, then 62 East (which sounds counterproductive, as you're actually heading west), then 229 into Gambier.
It helps to know at which big, unmarked field to turn right.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.