Elements Contemporary Cuisine opened Downtown in September 2010. Owner David Greenberg had put together a talented and experienced team, even giving executive chef Justin Severino and managing partner Michelle LaVelle-Denk small ownership stakes in the restaurant. While Mr. Greenberg was heavily involved from the beginning, Mr. Severino quickly became the public face of the business, and his food, particularly his charcuterie program, was central to the restaurant's identity.
So when he left last July to open his own restaurant -- Cure, in Lawrenceville -- it meant that Elements would be going through some changes.
Elements Contemporary Cuisine
Food:
1 star = Satisfactory
Ratings explainedService:
2 1/2 stars = Recommended+
Ratings explainedAtmosphere:
2 1/2 stars = Recommended+
Ratings explainedOverall:
2 stars = Recommended
444 Liberty Ave.
Gateway Center (enter on Stanwix Street) Downtown
412-251-0168
- Hours: Monday-Thursday, 11 a.m.-9 p.m.; Friday, 11 a.m.-10 p.m.; Saturday, 5-10 p.m.
- Summary: The eclectic American menu incorporates influences from Asia, Europe and the Mediterranean, but its best offerings include traditional restaurant favorites such as calamari, roast chicken and creme brulee.
- Recommended dishes: Crispy calamari, tuna tartar, spicy tomato soup with shrimp, Gerber's Amish Farm Chicken, creme brulee trio.
- Prices: Appetizers, $4-$16; $18-$35; desserts, $8 and up.
- Drink: Full bar including house cocktail list; wine list organized by variety and style; by the glass options include 3 sparkling, 12 white and 12 red, starting at $8; half-bottles include 1 sparkling, 18 white and 22 red, starting at $25; bottles include a wide range of new and Old World offerings, 6 sparkling, 32 white and 45 red. On Wednesdays, corkage is waived and bottles of wine are half-price.
- Useful information: Wheelchair accessible; credit cards accepted; parking validated for Gateway Center Garage, 2 hours from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. and five hours after 5 p.m.; reservations encouraged for peak times; corkage, $15; Wednesdays free corkage.
- Noise level: Low
The transition, carefully overseen by Mr. Greenberg and Ms. LaVelle-Denk, was slow and steady, but the adjustments were substantial. Where once Elements aimed to be a destination, it has now shifted its attention to winning over the Downtown audience. New executive chef Robert Courser has developed a menu that leans more toward American and Asian flavors. The charcuterie and cheese program is still on the menu, but it's smaller and less deftly executed. Cured meats such as duck speck and nocciola were cut too thick and tasted dried out. Charred radicchio had none of the complexity and crunch of the earlier version. Tea-smoked prunes were sweet and jam-like, but they lacked the smoky edge once imparted by pu-ehr tea.
It's a challenge for any chef to take on a previous chef's specialties, and, in general, Mr. Courser has modified the menu to reflect his own tastes. The best new dishes included a straightforward calamari that was both crispy and tender ($9) and a robust tuna tartar, large chunks of raw tuna mixed with buttery avocado and interspersed with thick slices of cucumber ($12). It wasn't the prettiest plate, but the combination of crisp fried wanton triangles with avocado and raw tuna had all the quality of a perfect snack: creamy avocado, silky raw tuna and crunchy chips.
My favorite dish was a special -- a spicy fresh tomato soup flecked with mint, poured tableside over a generous spoonful of creme fraiche and two pesto-coated shrimp ($9).
A roasted Amish farm chicken breast with lovely golden skin was simple and tasty, served on a bed of polenta with some pretty roasted carrots and a tart cranberry compote ($21). Tricolore orechiette pasta was a little soft, but it came dressed in a pleasantly bright San Marzano tomato sauce with fresh mozzarella, lots of lightly cooked basil and delicate spring greens ($18).
Some tweaking would improve a number of plates. A straightforward salad of frilly lettuce, thick slices of balsamic-glazed beets and creamy bits of goat cheese was fresh and satisfying, but the beets were refrigerator cold, dampening their flavor ($11). A bowl of French onion soup had good broth, but the layer of Swiss and provolone cheese didn't have the rich flavor or soft, stretchy texture of classic Gruyere ($9).
Asian steak bites started with small cubes of steak, which were juicy and flavorful. Unfortunately, they were tossed in a sweet, one-dimensional hoisin glaze and served with a bowl of truffled popcorn ($14). The popcorn itself had a well-balanced drizzle of truffle oil, but the combination of flavors had no connection to Asia and weren't particularly appetizing.
Other dishes suffered from more fundamental problems. A seared tuna steak was too salty at the edges, which only emphasized the lack of seasoning on other parts of the dish ($28). A pile of fried spinach was completely flavorless, while a "rice cake" made from dry white rice was flavored only by the too-sweet sauce, which tasted nothing like the caramel or miso mentioned on the menu. Scallops were cooked well, but their delicate flavor was overwhelmed by a savory, slightly spicy black bean cake (the best thing on the plate), as well as a broken beurre blanc and an oddly fishy-tasting fresh tomato salsa ($25). A pork chop was served with a wedge of undercooked, underseasoned potato gratin, and a heap of fiddlehead ferns that tasted oddly bitter.
Dessert options, now from pastry chef Joe Post, also have evolved. The menu is elaborate, ranging from plated desserts to chocolate truffles to a half-dozen dessert cocktails. These were better executed than the savory menu, but they weren't the most elegant creations in town. Fans of creme brulee will enjoy the citrus creme brulee trio, three miniature dishes of key lime, tangerine and passionfruit-pineapple flavored custards ($8). The peanut butter s'more was whimsical and indulgent, a tall stack of toasted marshmallow, chocolate brownie, graham cracker and peanut brittle ($8).
Elements always has offered a fairly traditional, upscale restaurant experience. Large, comfortable, cloth-covered tables; bread service; and attentive servers still create an environment of comfort and calm. Elements is quiet, a rare commodity in restaurants these days. Free parking (even in Downtown's most confusing parking garage) and a convenient location are strong selling points. And it's worth noting that Mr. Greenberg seems to be constantly present, an attentiveness that has helped maintain the quality of service, if not the quality of the menu.
Not every restaurant can set a new standard for creativity. A good restaurant can be good enough. But Elements has a lot of work to do before the food reaches that standard.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.