The fictional tale of four friends changing professional course and pooling their resources to open a restaurant could lend itself to drama, comedy or even romance. In real life, where running a restaurant bears little resemblance to throwing a dinner party, such choices usually end in tragedy.
Yet every so often, passion, hard work and good taste can trump inexperience. At Bar Marco in the Strip District, Justin Steel, Kevin Cox, Michael Kreha and Robert Fry have created a bar and restaurant with unexpected appeal.
Bar Marco
Food:
2 stars = Recommended
Ratings explainedService:
2 stars = Recommended
Ratings explainedAtmosphere:
3 stars = Excellent
Ratings explainedOverall:
2 1/2 stars = Recommended+
2216 Penn Ave.
Strip District
412-471-1900
- Hours: Dinner and drinks, Wednesday-Saturday, 5 p.m.-2 a.m.; brunch, Saturday-Sunday, 10 a.m.-3 p.m.
- Basics: A gorgeous space for drinking and grazing, with an emphasis on eclectic wines and cocktails and Italian small plates.
- Recommended dishes: Patatas bravas, frico, bacon-wrapped dates, green beans and potatoes with nettle pesto, Bar Marco burger, tequila marinated flank steak.
- Prices: Snacks, $3-$10; entrees, $9-$25.
- Drink: A small, frequently rotating wine list focuses on out-of-the-ordinary varieties and regions, most offered by the glass and bottle. Drink options also include a variety of traditional aperitif and after-dinner wines and liquors. House cocktail list offers a wide range of interesting, flavorful options which were carefully made and typically well balanced. A small beer list offers a range of styles, including several large-format beers.
- Summary: : Wheelchair accessible on first floor; credit cards accepted; reservations accepted; no BYOB.
- Noise level: Low to medium loud.
Bar Marco inhabits the space previously occupied by the Firehouse Lounge, upstairs, and the craft cocktail bar Embury, downstairs. They've started small, limiting food and drink service to the downstairs space, which seats 32. Upstairs, they offer a rotating exhibit of local art, as well as space for private events. Where Embury was dark, cozy and a little old-fashioned, Bar Marco is spacious and bright. Removing the dropped ceiling and an interior wall has opened up the space, emphasizing the plentiful natural light. Colorful abstract paintings and a striking chandelier draw the eye upward, but the prettiest decorations were bowls of citrus fruits and jars of fresh herbs, a glorious wash of color against the pale marble of the bar.
While Bar Marco is technically a restaurant, drinks are at the heart of the operation. The cocktail list is eclectic, encouraging drinkers to try something new, and even classic cocktails were given a personal twist. A slice of red bell pepper added a distinctly savory note to a tequila gimlet ($8). The sazerac was made with cognac rather than rye, which gave the drink a noticeable softness ($10), while aperol added a pleasing hint of bitterness to a Manhattan, which was lightened by a cava float ($12).
Mr. Kreha worked in retail wine and spirits sales for three years and he's curated an interesting, engaging list of wines that's meant to complement the food and introduce diners to new varieties and regions. Additional selection of spirits, aperitifs and digestifs, including a number of amari, offer the drinker a wonderful range of options depending on one's taste and mood.
The menu is delightfully heavy on elegant snacks such as roasted potatoes topped with a paprika aioli ($6), crisp fried cauliflower served with a lemon wedge ($7), and a bowl of bacon-wrapped dates stuffed with gooey manchego ($10). Frico, usually a wafer or envelope made from baking hard cheeses, was served almost like a quiche, the thick wedge of well-browned cheese sandwiched around thin slices of potato ($9). Grated sunchoke fritters were served with a flavorful tarragon aioli, the tastiest use of this root that I've tried.
Not every snack lived up to these high standards. A salad of roasted beets, arugula and goat cheese was seriously under-dressed, but would have been dull even with the liveliest vinaigrette. Greens and beans were similarly undistinguished, but on a later visit these had been replaced with a dish of crisp-tender green beans and crispy roasted potatoes, served cold and doused in a bright green, garlicky nettle pesto ($7).
Food came out of the kitchen at a steady yet slow pace. Had the dining room been entirely full, I expect service might have been slower, especially since bartenders were doing double duty as servers.
For a picnic-like dinner, there's also a selection of cheeses and cured meats, typically sourced from Crested Duck Charcuterie, their neighbor in the Pittsburgh Public Market ($3 each).
Entrees varied in quality more than small plates, particularly when price was taken into consideration. On an earlier visit, entrees were sized and priced for two, but in reality, they could easily be shared by a larger group, especially if accompanied by a few of the small plates. Fluke en saor, a sweet and sour combination of pine nuts, raisins, onions and vinegar, was fine but dull. The fish was cooked well, but there was simply too much of it and not nearly enough sauce ($25).
Spaghetti Amatriciana was also disappointing ($17). Fresh pasta was too soft for this preparation, and making a vegetarian amatriciana (usually it's made with guanciale, dried pig's jowl) makes about as much sense as a vegetarian bolognese ($17).
On our next visit, entrees were more varied and less Italian. They were also sized for one and priced more appropriately. The Bar Marco burger was worth ordering even in this over-saturated burger market, an espresso-rubbed local beef patty topped with thick slices of grilled red onions, smoked bacon and more of that fantastic tarragon aioli ($9). Tequila-marinated flank steak was tender and flavorful, despite being sliced a little thick, and served with a generous blanket of salsa verde ($18). The make-your-own-tacos plate was completed with several warm corn tortillas and a tangy red onion and cucumber relish.
Another plate took a turn toward the South, a grilled pork chop served with grits and greens braised with bacon. The greens were delicious, but the pork chop was overcooked and the grits were a little too loose ($21).
While Mr. Fry said they hope to expand dessert options in the future, my choice consisted of a simple chocolate tasting from neighbor Mon Aimee (a chocolate covered candied orange peel, two pastilles and a white chocolate lemon cordial truffle), paired with an amari flight (Averna, Fernet Branca and Strega). The pairing was great, but it won't work for those who don't like amaro, don't want anything else to drink, or don't want to spend $20.
Bar Marco was still a work in progress, but from visit to visit, its quartet of owners had already made smart changes and refined dishes. A more experienced team might have gotten off to a smoother start, but Bar Marco already has a sense of style and of place, something that many restaurants fail to find, no matter how experienced or talented their owners.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.