Pittsburgh's North Side has much to offer in entertainment. It's the home of two stadiums, a casino, museums and theaters, but it has long suffered for its lack of dining options.
It's not so much that restaurants don't open on the North Side, as that they don't seem to last very long. Take 422 Foreland St., an imposing, historical structure that housed James Street Tavern for almost 18 years until it closed in 2004. It was followed by Legends James Street Tavern in 2005, then Sassy Marie's in 2007, then Serendipity, which opened and closed in 2009.
Now, its James Street Gastropub & Speakeasy, a name which hearkens back to the James Street of old, while also offering a tip of the hat to current (well, sort of current) trends.
James Street Gastropub and Speakeasy
Food:
1 1/2 stars = Satisfactory+
Ratings explainedService:
1 1/2 stars = Satisfactory+
Ratings explainedAtmosphere:
2 stars = Recommended
Ratings explainedOverall:
1 1/2 stars = Satisfactory+
422 Foreland St.
North Side
412-904-3335
- Hours: Sunday-Thursday, 11 a.m.-11 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, 11 a.m. to 1 a.m. (limited menu 11 p.m. to 1 a.m.).
- Summary: This casual, comfortable neighborhood spot offers an eclectic mix of bar snacks, Southern-inspired dishes and comfort food.
- Recommended dishes: Oyster po boy, pulled pork, fish & chips, blueberry bread pudding with lemon curd.
- Drink: Full bar; house drink list includes classic cocktails and some more creative options, including a focus on locally distilled liquors. More than three dozen well-priced craft beer options, as well as a rotating selection on draft.
- Prices: Appetizers, $6-$15; soups and salads, $4-$13; sandwiches, $8-$15; entrees, $14-$30; sides, $3-$6; dessert, $6-$7.
- Useful information: Not wheelchair accessible; credit cards accepted; reservations for parties of 8 or more (arrive early for shows); kids menu available; corkage, $10.
- Noise level: (Upstairs) Low to very loud (during performances).
Owners Adam Johnston and Lisa Saftner took much of their inspiration from the North Side building's history as a center of the Pittsburgh jazz scene, a reputation that they hope to rebuild. Autographed musician photographs adorn one wall of the dining room, and menus are enclosed between record sleeves. There's live jazz Thursday through Sunday in the downstairs performance space, which is already booked through the end of the year. These shows are so popular that they recently set up an audio-visual system to simultaneously broadcast shows in the upstairs dining room and bar area.
Even when there's no show, the dining room attracts a respectable crowd. The menu is a hodgepodge of bar food, vaguely Southern dishes and classic comfort foods, such as meatloaf and fish and chips. Theoretically, there is something for everyone; an option at every price point. Realistically, some dishes were better than others, and it's hard to imagine that anyone is splurging on the yellowfin tuna or braised short ribs ($30). In fact, I twice tried to order the short ribs, only to be told they were unavailable that evening.
Burgers and sandwiches proved to be consistently tasty, not to mention inexpensive. While the selection included the Sweet Meat, a burger served on a doughnut-style bun with candied bacon and sweet onion mayonnaise ($10), I opted for the more traditionally indulgent Singing the Blues burger, enhanced with gorgonzola and smoked bacon ($10). It was a classically good burger, well-seasoned and juicy and served on a fluffy, yet substantial bun.
The same kind of bun stood up well to a generous portion of braised pork shoulder doused in a honey-chipotle barbecue sauce. The sauce was a little on the sweet side, but it was nicely balanced out by the tart, crunchy cole slaw that accompanied it ($8).
The best of the lot was the oyster po boy, a crusty roll layered with crispy fried oysters, sliced tomatoes and spicy horseradish mayonnaise ($12). All sandwiches came with house-made potato chips, which were often crisp and flavorful, but sometimes a little greasy and chewy.
Those chips also appear on the appetizer menu, served with a variety of dipping sauces ($7). Appetizers could better be described as snacks, as most are too substantial to allow for much eating afterward, even when shared. Deep fryers were put to frequent and varied use, turning out everything from potato chips and wings to oysters and "vegetable fries," strips of battered and fried bell pepper, zucchini, portobello mushrooms and eggplant served with a tart tomato-pickle relish and bacon ranch and cheddar-sour cream dressings ($7).
We had to try the peanut butter, beer and molasses wings ($6 for 6). They weren't bad, actually, but not necessarily worth the effort of getting peanut butter off your fingers (wet wipes were provided). Tequila lime wings were tasty, and there were about eight other varieties left to try.
If you're looking for a lighter option, try the spinach salad with red onion, roasted strawberry vinaigrette, peppered bacon and seared ahi tuna ($12). While the red onions were sliced a little too thickly, the spinach was crisp and plentiful, and the pink strawberry vinaigrette tasted impressively fresh.
With a little more attention to detail, more elaborate entrees could also prove to be good options. Pork in the Weeds, a pan-fried pork cutlet, was well-browned and crispy, but it was topped with a salad of mesclun greens and mealy tomato ($18). Swap out the wilted mesclun for arugula dressed in olive oil and lemon juice and it might have been a very successful dish.
A fried chicken breast was cooked well and came with authentically tender braised collard greens, flavored with bacon and a splash of vinegar ($17). Unfortunately, the collard greens were a little on the salty side and the plate also came with grits that had the texture of wet cement. A side order of mac and cheese was better, curly pasta gently coated in a mild cheese sauce and topped with crispy bread crumbs ($6).
Servers were pleasant, but a little absent-minded. A plate of fish and chips arrived without cole slaw and if we hadn't inquired it would never have left the kitchen. Another server dropped the check and then disappeared for 15 minutes, without bothering to ask if we wanted dessert. Errors, however, were admitted and quickly fixed.
Dessert options included raspberry chocolate beignets ($7), a brownie sundae ($6) and a blueberry bread pudding with lemon curd ($7). The last was particularly good, the tart lemon curd a nice foil for a sweet, rich square of custard-soaked bread.
James Street is also a bar, with a drink list that focuses on cocktails and beer. The list of bottled beer is lengthy and interesting, and they've recently introduced beer tastings every other Tuesday. The cocktail menu is more of a work in progress. Until recently, the list lacked any details about drinks, even though many were quite obscure, and the Gin Rickey I sampled, to put it politely, wasn't very good. Their new list, however, is both more varied and more detailed, with sections devoted to speakeasy cocktails, classics, martinis, frozen drinks and even one section focused on drinks made with locally produced Boyd & Blair vodka and Wigle whiskey.
Only time will tell whether James Street Gastropub and Speakeasy will enjoy the same longevity as its namesake, but the restaurant has already done an excellent job of connecting with the community.
The best compliment they've heard, said Mr. Johnston, is "James Street is back."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.