Stepping through the doors of Downtown's Omni William Penn Hotel feels like a trip back in time -- in the best possible way. The glittering chandeliers, gilded archways and elaborate velvet drapes evoke a kind of Henry James fantasy of European travel, new world wealth in an old world setting. The hotel's main restaurant, the Terrace Room, is equally splendid, with its elaborate carved ceiling and colorful mural, "The Taking of Fort Pitt."

White tablecloths, heavy draperies and crystal chandeliers are undoubtedly out of touch with today's dining trends, but the Terrace Room's unique loveliness could be a powerful draw. So why were so few diners there on a recent Wednesday night and even fewer on a Saturday?

The Terrace Room

Food:

Advertise with us

1 1/2 stars = Good+

Ratings explained

Service:

1 star = Good

Ratings explained

Advertise with us

Atmosphere:

2 1/2 stars = Very good+

Ratings explained

Overall:

1 1/2 stars = Good+

Advertise with us

Ratings explained

Omni William Penn Hotel

530 William Penn Place

Downtown

412-281-7100

Advertise with us
  • Hours: Breakfast: Monday-Friday, 6:30-11 a.m., Saturday-Sunday, 7-11 a.m.; Sunday brunch: 11 a.m.-2 p.m.; lunch: Monday-Saturday, 11 a.m.-2 p.m.; dinner: Monday-Sunday, 5-10 p.m.
  • Overview: A grand setting for straightforward American and continental fare.
  • Recommended dishes: : Frisee salad, beet carpaccio, lamb shank, wild boar, caramelized Brussels sprouts.
  • Prices: Starters, $8-$12; soups and salads, $7-$9; dinner entrees, $20-$37; desserts, $7-$8.
  • Drinks: Full bar; the short wine list focuses on wines from California and a handful of other countries. The list is organized by variety and it's on the expensive side, but all bottles of wine (except sparkling) are 50 percent off Monday through Thursday. Two sparkling wines and five white wines are available by the glass, starting at $9; six red wines are available by the glass, starting at $10.50.
  • Summary: Wheelchair accessible; credit cards accepted; reservations accepted; no BYOB.
  • Noise level: Low.

An explanation might begin with the cost: Restaurant prices have been trending downward, but at the Terrace Room, the least expensive entree is $20, and more than half of the options are more than $30. Those prices raise expectations for delicious food and quality service, but the restaurant is not meeting those expectations.

The fineness of the dining room was undermined by a half dozen small failures: Menu covers were old and faded. A jar of mustard was left on a window ledge. Meals were punctuated by the crash of cutlery and china dropped into bus tubs -- out of sight but not out of mind.

Servers rushed through their jobs. No one ever offered to take our coats, or brought small plates for shared dishes like the charcuterie platter. Tables were never completely cleared (not to mention crumbed) before dessert; instead, servers kept themselves busy by clearing tables for the evening and setting up serving pieces for the next morning's buffet station -- presumably, so they could leave more quickly at the end of the night. One server poured huge glasses of wine from the bottle we'd ordered, more intent on emptying it than on anything else, and not even apologizing for spilling some down the side of one guest's glass.

The food, no matter how fantastic, would have had a hard time making up for this dreary, disinterested service. And the food seemed to be aiming for agreeable, rather than impressive.

A frisee salad with bacon and a poached egg was a well-executed classic. The frisee had been neatly trimmed into bite-sized pieces, a detail almost too small to mention, except that it's so often neglected, and so essential to a well-made, delicious salad.

Advertise with us

The heirloom beet carpaccio was another good choice. The plate was lined with thinly sliced, very brightly colored purple beets, topped with a small pile of arugula and petite globes of goat cheese, which were coated in bread crumbs and pan-fried ($10). Tarragon vinaigrette was a good match for the beets, contributing a delicate anise note.

Skip the charcuterie platter, with its dry saucisson and rubbery pate ($11). With so many local options for superb charcuterie, this plate struck me as particularly sad.

A butternut squash bisque was too watery and weirdly spiced, veering toward pumpkin pie ($7), but a trio of seared sea scallops garnished with a sun-dried tomato relish were simple and pleasant ($12).

Entrees included several good options beyond the usual chicken, salmon and steak. A rack of wild boar was a fun change from lamb chops, supported by a delicious mess of braised cabbage and bacon. Green beans and a floury potato fritter distracted more than they enhanced this plate.

A "pear braised" Elysian Fields lamb shank had a discernible sweetness, although it also had the slightly tough texture of meat braised a little too long ($30). Toasted hazelnuts enhanced the nutty sweetness of barley, called a risotto, but with the distinct, grainy texture of a pilaf. A fish du jour, roasted basa (a meaty white fish similar to cod) was served with roasted fingerling potatoes, gingery sweet potatoes and fresh arugula ($28). The combination of starches was unexpectedly delicious, particularly in combination with the arugula.

Advertise with us

The menu places a surprising emphasis on steak, with three options leading the entree list. But at these prices ($35 to $37), one could do far better. The prime ribeye was threaded with gristle, and the mashed potato croquettes and sauteed peppers and sugar snap peas that accompanied the steak were the most boring side dishes on the menu.

Vegetarians had slightly better options. Polenta with local mushrooms, caramelized brussels sprouts, sauted spinach and golden tomato sauce were basically a combination of side dishes, but the vegetables were generally well cooked, and the tomato sauce was lighter and sweeter than the typical "red" sauce ($20). Gnocchi with roasted tomatoes, spinach, goat cheese and caramelized onions was a winning combination of flavors, although the gnocchi were so soft and delicate that they were almost indistinguishable from mashed potatoes ($24).

A few suggestions to lighten the bill: Dine on Sunday through Thursday and all bottles of wine (except sparkling wines) are 50 percent off. Also, feel free to skip dessert.

Henry Clay Frick was the developer behind the original William Penn hotel in 1916, and he was clearly passionate about creating a grand hotel for the Pittsburgh community. Over nearly 100 years, it has been sustained and improved by thoughtful investors, including the Omni hotel group. The Terrace Room deserves to be treated as more than just a hotel amenity. Without closer attention, it will continue as it is now: A grand, sumptuous and mostly wasted space.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.