Rockaway Pizzeria, one of the region’s most celebrated pizza joints, is moving from White Oak to Regent Square later this year.

“It was really now or never. This was an opportunity I was looking for that was impossible to pass up,” says owner and pizzaiolo Josh Sickels.

Sickels plans to relocate from his current White Oak location to the former Square Cafe space on South Braddock Avenue in Edgewood by late autumn or early winter (Rockaway will continue as-is until the transition). He believes this move will bolster his already excellent business.

“I have a lot of customers that have traveled all over to get here. A lot of them are from the city, and this’ll make it easier for them to get my food,” he says.

Advertise with us

Sickels opened Rockaway as a hole-in-the-wall pizza shop in 2017, quickly earning acclaim for his New York-style pies. In 2020, he moved to a larger location next door to the original, where Rockaway truly became a destination for pizza lovers.

The fastidious pizzaiolo has continued to refine his New York pies, experimenting with ingredients, fermentation times and overall process. The effort shows; his offerings in that style are among those setting a new national standard for what’s increasingly called “third wave” pizza.

Sickels has also expanded his exploration of regional styles since launching Rockaway 2.0. His square, grandma-style and specialty pies, such as the New Haven-influenced white clam pizza, are standouts in their own right.

“I’m driven by the creative process. It’s a huge thing for me,” he says.

As Sickels prepares to enter its next chapter with Rockaway, he says he’s feeling a rekindled focus on his craft. Rockaway 3.0 will offer him the opportunity to continue his slow, steady pace of improvement.

Advertise with us

Although the overall square footage of the new space will be similar to the White Oak location, he’ll have a bigger slice case, which will allow him some freedom to play with new topping builds.

The new location — Regent Square includes sections of Pittsburgh, Edgewood, Swissvale and Wilkinsburg — should also bring a larger lunch crowd, so he’s going to extend his hours, too. If all goes as expected, he hopes the increased volume in the new location will allow him to expand the quality and quantity of specialty ingredients, too.

“Regent Square is a huge walking neighborhood. There are thousands of houses within a 10-minute walk,” he says.

Sickels says that he’s planning on refining his menu in the new location. He’ll scale back on some of the salad and sandwich offerings from his menu in White Oak to focus more directly on his pizza. Look for changes like creamed spinach replacing a basic spinach and feta pizza, and an even deeper exploration of regional East Coast styles.

“Philly’s pizza is amazing. Jersey’s pizza is amazing. Crispy, thin pizza is amazing,” Sickels says.

Advertise with us

He’s optimistic about Regent Square as a neighborhood, noting how businesses such as longtime favorite D’s Six Pax and Dogz and the new independent bookstore Stay Gold Books add vibrancy to the area.

The move will also place him across the street from his other business, the bar and restaurant Hemlock House, which celebrated its one-year anniversary earlier this month.

“Having the two restaurants across the street from each other is an ideal setup. Right now I’m spending so many extra hours a week in the car,” he says. “It’ll make my life easier, which in turn will make the pizza better.”

Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, X @halbklein and IG @halbklein.