When University of Pittsburgh senior Xingyu Song and Zechen Zhang, a 2022 Carnegie Mellon University graduate, think of Dave & Andy’s Homemade Ice Cream, they recall long nights cramming for finals.

They would head to the small shop on Oakland’s Atwood Street, right off Pitt’s campus, for an sweet pick-me-up — chocolate for her, salted caramel for him.

“Lots of good memories, it was kind off emotional support,” Mr. Song said, digging into a quart-size treat Saturday.

This time feels bittersweet, though, as Dave & Andy’s will be shutting its doors soon. After 40 years of serving up homemade ice cream and hand-rolled waffle cones, owner Andy Hardie is retiring the beloved business. Its final day of serving is Sunday.

Advertise with us

“We would like to thank our friends, families, past and present employees and most of all our loyal, loving customers. You are what made 40 years possible. We will cherish all the wonderful memories and friendships that have been made over the years,” said a post on Facebook announcing the closure.

The announcement received hundreds of comments. One woman wrote it was the first thing she ate after giving birth. Another said she visited Dave & Andy's on the first Father's Day after her dad passed away, to honor his memory.

The business’ footprint on the community also was evident from the line wrapped around the block Saturday, with some people waiting for hours before the store opened. It’s been that way daily ever since the shop broke the news.

Dave & Andy’s Homemade Ice Cream owner Andy Hardie fills a pint of ice cream for a customer at his shop on Atwood St. in Oakland Saturday, April 27, 2024. First opened in 1983, the Oakland shop will close it’s doors Sunday, April 27. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The second group of customers to get in the door Saturday, Ms. Song and Mr. Zhang were in line by 10 a.m., two hours before the doors opened.

“I've been staring at this place for a week, and I didn't have a chance to get in until today,” Ms. Song said. “It’s so sad.”

Advertise with us

It was an emotional day, too, for Mr. Hardie, who has run the business solo since his partner, Dave Tuttle, left in the early 1990s. The shop opened in 1983. Almost everything the pair knew about running an ice cream shop came from a Ben & Jerry’s short course offered at Penn State University.

They knew the location in Oakland would be perfect since it was close to the city’s college campuses, and they were right, remaining a Pittsburgh staple for decades.

“It was a tough decision, but it was time,” Mr. Hardie said on Saturday. “It was a good, long trip. I’m thankful.”

Mr. Hardie’s son Gregg flew in from Denver to help close up shop, and it’s been overwhelming for him to see the response.

“We'd have lines around the block occasionally, but not like this,” he said. “It's crazy to see people waiting three hours. I mean, it’s just been so positive.”

Advertise with us

Nicole Caparanis and Lou Klein of Shadyside tried to get in a few times this week, but the line was already long by the time they got there. “It was nuts,” Mr. Klein said.

On Saturday, they succeeded after waiting an hour with their two children, Addison, 9, and Austin, 6. They remember coming here when they were first dating.

What has kept the place successful over the years is simple, according to Ms. Caparinis.

“Good flavors and fresh ingredients,” she said. “The ice cream is amazing.”

For South Side native Kathi Radock, who was enjoying a fan-favorite flavor, white chocolate cinnamon habanero, with her wife, Amy Camp, it’s the little quirks, too. She thinks of the M&Ms they place at the bottom of every cone.

Advertise with us
Dave & Andy’s Homemade Ice Cream shop owner Andy Hardie greets customers lined up outside of his shop on Atwood St. in Oakland Saturday, April 27, 2024. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“The first time, you don't know to expect it, and you're like, ‘Oh, that's cool,’ and that’s part of the memory,” she said.

There’s also a kind of old school charm. Julie Coder said the shop looks just about the same as it did when she was a freshman at Pitt almost 25 years ago – the green tile floors, the chalkboard noting the flavors of the day, “Best Ice Cream” awards dating back decades on the walls.

She had the opportunity to thank Mr. Hardie in person for all the memories, telling him this was a place to celebrate or to cry. Either way, it felt better with a handmade waffle cone in hand.

“When you see a place closing on social media and you start crying, you know it had a big impact,” Mrs. Coder said. “I just wanted to thank him.”

While sad that this would be her family’s last visit, she’s glad that she could enjoy the treat one last time with her 10-year-old, Will, and husband, Jim.

Advertise with us

“The smell is the one thing I wish I could bottle it up and take it with me,” Ms. Coder said. “It's really all part of the core memories.”

Correction: posted May 1, 2024, Andy Hardie and Dave Tuttle took a short course through Penn State University to help them learn how to operate their business. An earlier version of this story said they took the course at a different university.