Frank Tokach followed a pretty traditional career path after he graduated from the now-defunct Pennsylvania Culinary Institute in 1999.

After completing an externship at Caesar’s Place in Lake Tahoe, Nev., the Donora native returned to Pittsburgh to hone his culinary chops working at various local kitchens and private clubs.

A short stint as a Sheraton Station Square line cook quickly turned into an executive chef position at the steakhouse Pittsburgh Rare in the hotel’s lobby.  He also worked as executive chef and beverage director at the Pittsburgh Athletic Association for more than seven years, and held chef jobs at Nordstrom and St. Clair Country Club.

He also owned Redwood Cafe, a gourmet sandwich shop in Mt. Lebanon, for two years before becoming an executive chef at PNC Park.

Advertise with us

He was inspired to become a culinarian at an early age by his Italian grandmother, Wanda, who cooked the family three meals a day, five days a week.

Wanda — who everyone called Nunny — “made [cooking] look easy,” Tokach said. “It talked to me. It just made sense.”

So when he made the jump to private chef just before the pandemic, it was hardly a surprise he took to in-home cooking like the proverbial fish to water.

He was getting bored cooking at a retirement community after leaving PNC Park in 2019, and the excitement and creativity that came with customizing meals for dinner parties and other events in people’s homes was not unlike what he had experienced with his grandmother growing up.

“The tradition [of cooking for a crowd] was passed down to us,” he said.

Advertise with us

A handful of gigs set up by connections in the restaurant business led to several a month, “and it just kept snowballing and snowballing,” said Tokach, who in May 2025 became Pittsburgh’s first chef to be certified by the United States Personal Chef Association.

Created in 1996, the designation assures a chef has run a profitable “cook-for-hire” business for at least five years, with written testimony from clients. The job starts with menu planning and sourcing and ends with cleaning up after cooking, plating and serving.

These days, Tokach averages about four dinners a week — everything from anniversary, retirement and birthday parties to couples dinners and celebrity get-togethers. He also regularly cooks for charity events like the upcoming A Gathering of Chefs on Sept. 28 to benefit The Bradley Center, a residence and school serving children recovering from abuse, neglect and other trauma.

The 10th annual farm-to-fork fundraiser in being held at Kinsey Events Warehouse, a historic industrial building dating to the 1930s in Oakdale. It feature small bites and desserts along with specialty cocktails, beer and wine and a silent auction. It runs from 5-8 p.m. and tickets cost $150 at bradleycenter.org.

Spearheaded in 2016 by Martin Thomas, who at the time was the executive chef at Sewickley Heights Golf Club, the farm-to-fork event brings together chefs from some of Pittsburgh's most well-known eateries for a common goal: to make life a little easier for those served by the child welfare organization by raising money for the extras that make a kid’s life fun.

Advertise with us

In addition to Tokach, this year’s featured chefs and restaurants include Emily Durham, Alekka Sweeney, Vincent Mangan, Sweetwater Center for Arts, Farmers Table and The Cellar at 1781 Club, Lula's of Sewickley, Trish's Truffles and Metz Catering.

Last year’s gathering brought 229 attendees and raised  $157,000 over expenses for activities like a trip to the zoo and birthday gifts for the 180 kids who live or go to school at Bradley Center.

Tokach jumped at the chance to be involved for the first time last year after a client  — who also happened to be on the Bradley Center’s board —  told him about the annual fundraiser. Being from a large extended Italian family, “I love helping kids,” he said.

Last year, Tokach prepared one of his most requested dishes for the harvest feast — crab cakes with lemon aioli served with a wild mushroom risotto with crispy garlic and shaved truffle. This year, ticket holders can expect a pop of flavor from another favorite that’s a little “sexier” — herb-crusted rack of lamb with a drizzle of sweet-hot peppered honey.

“You eat with your eyes first,” he said with a laugh, “so if it looks good, you think, ‘I have to try this.’ People love it.”

Advertise with us

Whether it’s cooking an intimate dinner for two or roasting, slicing and garnishing 35 racks of lamb for 250 guests at a  community event like A Gathering of Chefs, working as a personal chef is all about connection.

“You’re inviting me into your home,” he said. “It’s a different experience than coming into a restaurant. I’m creating a memorable experience where everything is customized. There is no set menu. You tell me what you want, and I make it for you.”

Along with the recipe for the dish, Tokach offers a few tips for recreating it at home: Make sure the oven stays at a constant temperature and use an instant-read thermometer so you pull the lamb out of the oven at the exact moment it hits 138 degrees.

“You can’t overcook it that way,” he said.

Leave it in too long and the crust is probably going to burn.

Advertise with us

In addition, make sure the finished dish rests for at least 5 minutes before you slice it, to allow the meat to reabsorb the juices.

“And go light on the sauce,” he added. While the sweetness of the honey helps cut through and balance the richness of the lamb, “a little bit goes a long way.”

A Gathering of Chefs runs from 5-8 p.m. Sept. 28 at Kinsey Events Warehouse, 7237 Noblestown Road, Oakdale. Tickets are $150 each at thebradleycenter.org. More info: 412-788-8219.

Herb-Crusted Rack of Lamb

As elegant as it is easy to prepare, this lamb recipe yields tender, rosy meat and a lovely browned crust that sings with fresh herbs and garlic. The peppered honey adds a spicy-sweet kick.

Advertise with us

For lamb

1 trimmed, or “frenched,” rack of lamb

Salt and pepper

2 ounces melted butter

1 cup panko bread crumbs

Advertise with us

1 bunch parsley

1 teaspoon thyme

2 ounces Dijon mustard

For peppered honey 

½ cup honey

Advertise with us

½ teaspoon salt

2 teaspoons fresh-cracked black pepper

2 ounces water

Preheat oven to 425 degrees.

Prepare lamb: Season with salt and pepper on both sides. Place on a hot grill and grill for 1 minute on each side.

Advertise with us

In food processor fitted with blade, pulse together panko, parsley and thyme. Stir in melted butter, ½ tablespoon salt and ½ tablespoon pepper. Mix well to combine.

Spread Dijon mustard on the top and sides of the lamb, but not on the bones. (Stop where the meat begins to be frenched.)

Using your hands, pack the herb mixture onto the mustard.

Place the lamb (fat side pointing up) on a sheet pan and roast for 25 minutes, or until the meat registers 138 degrees on an instant-read thermometer.

Remove from oven and allow to rest at least 5 minutes before slicing.

Advertise with us

While lamb is roasting, make honey sauce.

Combine honey, salt and pepper and water in a small saucepan and stir well to combine. Bring to a simmer over medium-low heat and cook for 5 minutes.

Slice lamb and drizzle with peppered honey.

Serves 3.

— Chef Frank Tokach