Cake and apple pie contests have been a highlight of county fairs for years, enabling amateur bakers to strut their stuff beyond their circle of friends and family. Many contestants spend days or even weeks perfecting their recipes in pursuit of that coveted blue ribbon — proof positive they can work magic with simple ingredients like butter, flour, eggs and cocoa.
Jennifer Lang, who has four sons between the ages of 3 and 13, wasn’t so fussy in her first attempt.
When she decided to enter the chocolate cake contest at the Dayton Fair in Armstrong County last month, she had just 4½ hours to come up with a scratch recipe, bake and frost it, then deliver the three-layer confection for judging. “And I had a doctor’s appointment that day, and the fair was an hour away,” she said with a laugh. She was “elated” when her entry came in third.
So was her mother, Mary Steere, who pushed her daughter to enter the same cake in Westmoreland Fair’s contest on Aug. 20. Recently diagnosed with cancer and suffering mobility issues, she couldn’t join her daughter at the fair.
She was, however, the first person Lang called when she found out she’d won the Saturday morning contest at the Greensburg fairgrounds, besting 13 other contestants for the $100 first prize.
“There was nothing but pure joy on her face,” Lang said of the video call. “She was with me in spirit!”
The triple-layer cake — from a recipe the teacher found on the Internet and tweaked to make her own — was everything a chocolate cake should be: moist, with a delicate crumb and rich chocolate flavor.
The judges, which included this reporter, were particularly impressed by its old-fashioned chocolate ermine frosting, made by cooking flour and sugar with milk into a sweet paste that is then whipped with butter and cocoa. It was as light and airy as whipped cream, with a just the right amount of sweet chocolate flavor.
“I wanted it to be creamy, and I don’t like super-sweet frosting, so my goal was to make one that tasted like chocolate milk,” she said. “I tried to go strictly traditional.”
It was also a redemption of sorts for Lang, who wondered if her cake didn’t do as well in Armstrong because it sat in a barn overnight. “I don’t even know what it looked like when they cut into it.”
For the Greensburg contest, she froze the layers so they were structurally sound and kept the frosted cake in the fridge overnight, “hoping and praying it would make it to Westmorland County in one piece.”
She had some fierce competition: Brielle Davanzo, who placed third in the apple pie contest, came in second, and Summer Pavik of Latrobe, who won last year’s contest with a dark chocolate cake, took third place for a triple-chocolate, three-layer cake decorated with squares of Ghiradelli and Hershey chocolate.
It’s a family recipe that Summer makes all the time, “so I thought it would be fun to see how well it would do,” she said. The 14-year-old, self-taught baker, a freshman at Latrobe High School, also took second place in the apple pie contest.
Lang, another self-taught baker, recently started as a substitute paraprofessional at Apollo Ridge Elementary. She only got serious about cakes a couple years ago, in part large part because of friends. Wowed by the birthday cakes and cupcakes she’d made over the years, “they would come to me with an idea, and say, ‘Can you make this happen?’ And I’d say, ‘We can try but I can’t promise anything.’”
While she entered — and won — a cookie contest at a Christmas festival two years ago, the North Apollo resident rarely competes. “But I thought what do I have to lose except the ingredient list?”
This was the fifth year for the Westmoreland Fair’s Cake & Pie Showdown, which was staged in the Family Living Hall amid jars of jams, jellies, cookies and other food products. Participants didn’t have to be a Westmoreland County resident, but they were not allowed to have won first place in a homemade chocolate cake contest at any other fair in 2022. Calls for entries went out on Facebook in June, with an Aug. 1 deadline.
The fair began hosting a special event in 2018 to showcase everyone’s favorite baked goods, said organizer Jackie Elliot. While the number of entries has fluctuated each year — there were more cakes than pies last year — both contests typically get repeat entries.
Entries were scored on a 100-point system in five categories: flavor, texture, frosting and inside and outside characteristics. Cakes had to be layered and be made completely from scratch, with chocolate or cocoa as the main ingredient.
As the blue-ribbon winner, Lang gets to take her cake to the 2023 Pennsylvania Farm Show in Harrisburg in January, where she’ll compete against other county winners for the state title. It runs Jan. 7-14 at the Farm Show Complex & Expo Center. It will be the 107th running of the show, which is the nation’s largest indoor agricultural event.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.
MAMA J’S CHOCOLATE BLISS CAKE
PG tested
This triple-layer chocolate cake features light and fluffy chocolate ermine frosting and a super-moist cake with a secret ingredient — coffee. Lang used local ingredients, including Marburger Farm Dairy buttermilk, Galliker’s Dairy whole milk and Hillendale Farm eggs.
I chose to make the recipe as a sheet cake, which required a longer baking time (60 minutes). My co-workers polished it off in no time.
For cake
2 cups all-purpose flour
2 cups granulated white sugar
¾ cup unsweetened Hershey’s cocoa powder
2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
1 cup whole milk buttermilk
1 cup canola oil
2 teaspoon vanilla
2 large eggs
1 cup hot black coffee
For frosting
5 tablespoons all-purpose flour
½-¾ cup granulated white sugar
1 cup whole milk
1 cup salted butter, room temperature
2 teaspoons vanilla
3 tablespoons unsweetened Hershey’s cocoa powder
Preheat oven to 300 degrees and grease three 8-inch pans.
Combine flour, sugar, cocoa powder, baking soda and salt in a bowl. In a separate bowl, combine buttermilk, canola oil, vanilla and eggs.
Slowly mix wet ingredients into dry ingredients with a wire whisk until incorporated. Very slowly whisk in hot coffee (batter will be thin).
Divide batter evenly between the 3 pans and bake for 30-33 minutes, or until toothpick comes out clean. Let cakes rest 10 minutes, then transfer to freezer for 30 minutes.
While cake layers are freezing, prepare frosting.
Heat 1 cup of whole milk in the microwave for 1½ minutes.
In a small saucepan, add flour and sugar and whisk over medium heat 30 seconds. Slowly add ⅓ of hot milk to saucepan and whisk till all the lumps are gone.
Add the rest of the milk and whisk continually until the mixture is a custard consistency, 2-3 minutes.
Remove from heat, scrape the mixture into a bowl and press on a piece of plastic wrap. Cool on counter until cool to touch. To speed the process, first cool on the counter for 20 minutes and then in the fridge for 30 minutes.
Add butter to a stand mixer with a whisk attachment and whip butter several minutes until almost white (stop occasionally and scrape down sides). Slowly add cooled flour mixture 1 tablespoon at a time and whip until fully incorporated (otherwise it will be lumpy). Finally, add vanilla and cocoa powder and mix till combined. Remove whisk and with a large spatula, fold frosting by hand to remove any air pockets.
After all cake layers are partially frozen, begin to assemble by placing the first layer on a cake board. Put a layer of frosting on top and smooth out. Continue alternating cake and frosting. Apply a crumb coat, and then place in freezer for 20 minutes. Finish with a final coat of frosting on top and sides, add a bottom border and decorate the top.
Makes 1 cake.
— Jennifer Lang, North Apollo







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.