Liam Yates wasn’t born in Ireland like his two older sisters. Yet he grew up immersed in Irish culture.

For years, his mother, Kathy, has helped organize and run Irish dance competitions, known as feiseanna, at the Irish Centre of Pittsburgh in Squirrel Hill. His musician father, David, plays the music.

The Brookline native is particularly intrigued by one of Ireland’s most beloved culinary imports to America — the golden-brown round of quick bread known as Irish soda bread.

His mother had fallen in love with the criss-crossed loaves during the 10 years she lived in Maynooth in County Kildare, Ireland, after graduating from St. Francis Academy in Castle Shannon. When she returned to Pittsburgh in 1994, she often made the traditional quick bread to serve alongside soup or stew or with a cuppa.

Advertise with us

Mr. Yates has seen countless loaves at the Irish Centre, because the club for years has held a soda bread baking competition at its feis competitions to promote and celebrate Irish culture. By age 10, paired with an older mentor, he started learning how to judge those contests in the three categories — white bread (made with all-purpose flour), brown bread (made with whole wheat flour) and raisin bread/scones (aka “fancy” bread.)

Turns out he had a knack for it.

The 20-year-old University of Pittsburgh sophomore has become something of an expert at determining whose soda bread has the best shape, color, sound, texture and taste. He also can tell in an instant who has erred, ever so slightly, by kneading the dough for a minute too long or failing to fully mix the salt and soda powder into the flour.

“It’s more an art than a science,” he says of the baking process.

You don’t have to be judge, or even a baker, to know there’s something magical about the way four simple ingredients can be turned into something so delicious. You certainly don’t have to be Irish, and it sure as heck doesn’t have to be March 17, Ireland’s national holiday, to make a loaf. You just need a big bowl, a cast-iron skillet, a hot oven or stovetop and a gentle hand.

Advertise with us

Given how strongly soda bread is identified with Irish cuisine, you might think it’s as old as the ages. Yet soda bread is a relatively modern invention, showing up on Irish tables only a few years before the start of the Great Famine in 1845.

While soft wheat was easy to procure for bread during the 1800s, yeast to make it rise was expensive. The ready availability of bicarbonate of soda as a cheap leavening agent in the 1830s changed all that. Suddenly, quick breads could be made at home both speedily and easily every day, even in the poorest cottages.

For that you can thank chemistry. When acidic buttermilk mixes with the baking soda, it creates small bubbles of carbon dioxide in the dough that make it rise.

According to the Society for the Preservation of Irish Soda Bread, the oldest reference to a written soda bread recipe dates to 1836. It was made in a flat-bottomed, cast-iron baking pot known as a bastible. It was cooked over an open fire with live coals on the lid, “taking off the cover occasionally to see that it does not burn.”

Today, most Irish soda bread is baked on a cookie sheet or cast-iron pan in an oven. You can also divide the dough into “farls,” or quarters, and cook it in a heavy skillet or griddle on the stovetop with moderate heat.

Advertise with us

The traditional recipe calls for just flour, salt, soda powder and buttermilk. Yet as the Irish had more money and more ingredients became available, some started throwing other things in, as well, says Marie Young, a Dubliner and Irish instructor at the University of Pittsburgh since 2006.

Barmbrack, also known as speckled bread, is a plain, yet richly fruited and spiced bread traditionally served around Halloween in Ireland.  Many Irish made a richer fruitcake at Christmas, she says, and any leftover raisins, sultanas, currants or other dried fruit would sometimes find their way into soda bread.

Her grandmother, June Mullen, who lived in Galway and wrote her recipes on the backs of cereal boxes, would add raisins and dried cherries to her “spotted” loaves and scones.

“I never saw white bread growing up, at least in her house,” she says.

Which helps explain why many of the Irish soda breads enjoyed today — including my family’s much-loved recipe handed down by my husband’s Irish grandmother, Nellie Foy — include dried fruit, along with butter and sugar.

Advertise with us

While soda bread is still a standard in Ireland, Anne Burnham, who was a founding director of the Ireland Institute of Pittsburgh and a one-time food writer for the Post-Gazette, says there’s so much more to Irish cuisine today. You’re much more likely to see home cooks whipping up a plate of tacos, bowl of Thai noodles or wood-fired pizza instead of soda bread.

True, many cling to tradition, which is wonderful, she says. But the Irish food scene has been revolutionized and internationalized in the last 20 years.

She adds you’re probably going to get brown bread at local pubs and restaurants instead of white. Whichever you choose, “you always want to lavish on Irish butter,” she adds.

So what qualities makes a loaf of Irish soda bread shine?

When he’s judging, Mr. Yates first surveys the overall shape of the bread. Rounder is better, and the cross cut on top — added for both symbolic and practical reasons — should be deep and present. He then looks to the overall color of the loaf, with the most points going to ones that are evenly golden brown.

Advertise with us

Mr. Yates knocks on the bottom of the loaf with his fingers to see if it is fully baked. (It should sound hollow when thumped.) He’ll also judge how well the bread slices. If it’s too hard or too soft on the outside, or too cake-like in the middle, points are deducted.

Finally, he tastes it. If he detects anything other than the four ingredients, or it’s sweet, additional points are deducted.

The most common mistakes bakers make, he says, are kneading the dough too heavily, which makes the bread dense. Conversely, if he finds big holes or lumps inside, the leavening was not properly combined with the dry ingredients. A soapy, salty or bitter taste means too much baking soda or not enough buttermilk was used.

Famed Irish chef Darina Allen, who founded Ballymaloe Cookery School, suggests mixing the batter in a large bowl with your fist formed into a “claw” until it is well and evenly mixed. She then tidies up and flattens the dough and tucks it under with floured hands instead of kneading it. (You can watch a video here.) You can use either all-purpose flour for a white loaf, or half whole wheat and half white for a brown loaf.

In addition to marking her bread with a cross for the traditional Catholic blessing, she also playfully pricks the four corners to “let the fairies out of the bread” so they don’t jinx it.

Advertise with us

While no two soda breads will look exactly the same, Mr. Yates says, judges should be able to recognize it as a loaf of bread and not a cake.

Plain soda bread is great for sopping up soup or gravy from stew, or as a side to a traditional St. Patrick’s Day dish like corned beef and cabbage or shepherd’s pie. Sweet soda breads laden with raisins, currants, caraway seed or other mix-ins are best served at breakfast or for afternoon tea, with a steaming up of tea.

It should always — always — be served warm from the oven, preferably with a good slather of creamy butter and a teaspoon or two of jam.

Making Irish soda bread, says Kathy Yates, doesn’t just taste good. It also brings comfort and shares the values and traditions of times past.

“You feel like you belong in these times when we’re separated” by the pandemic, she says.

Advertise with us

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter/IG @gtmckay.

Irish Soda Bread

PG tested

The goal to making a great soda bread is not to overwork the dough. Some like to use a wooden spoon to stir the ingredients together, but you can also use your hands. The traditional “cross” cut into the top of the loaf has a dual purpose. Along with warding off evil spirits, the cut helps the bread cook in the center, and stretch as it rises.

Soda bread is best served warm from the oven, or at least on the day it’s baked. Traditional add-ins to make it a “fancy bread” include raisins, currants, other dried fruits and caraway seeds. Sanding sugar can be sprinkled on top for a sweet finish.

Advertise with us

4 cups all-purpose flour

1½ teaspoons baking soda

1 teaspoon salt

2 cups cold buttermilk (not low fat)

Preheat oven to 425 degrees.

Advertise with us

Grease an 8-inch cake pan or baking sheet well (or use parchment paper)

Whisk together the dry ingredients, making sure salt and baking soda are well distributed. Stir in the buttermilk until it becomes too stiff to stir.

With floured hands, knead the dough on a work surface about 10 times until all the flour is moistened. Form the dough into a round about 1½ inches thick.

Place round on the prepared pan or baking sheet, and cut a ¼-inch-deep cross in the center of the dough reaching out all the way to the sides with a very sharp knife

Bake for 30 minutes, or until bread is golden brown and it sounds hollow when tapped on the bottom. Serve warm.

Advertise with us

Makes 1 loaf.

— Kathy Yates, Brookline

Soda Bread Farls

PG tested

Derived from the Gaelic word “fardel” meaning four parts, farls are round flatbreads that are cut into quarters. They are slow cooked on a dry griddle or in a cast-iron pan and are typically served hot, with butter and jam. In Northern Ireland, farls are fried in bacon fat until golden crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, as part of an “Ulster breakfast.”

Advertise with us

3½ cups all-purpose flour

1½ teaspoons baking soda

½ teaspoon fine sea salt

1¼ cups buttermilk

Sift the flour, baking soda and salt into a large bowl. Pour in the milk and mix with a spatula or your hands until you have a soft, dry dough.

Advertise with us

For the dough, roll into a ball and then roll it out into a circle just under ½-inch thick, then divide into quarters.

Place a heavy-bottomed skillet over medium heat and sprinkle lightly with flour. When the flour starts to brown the skillet is ready.

Place the farls in the pan and cook until lightly browned, about 5 to 6 minutes on each side. (They will rise into triangular pillows.) Test for doneness by pressing the middle — if it holds the indent of your finger, you must flip the farl again and cook until firm.

Cool the cooked farls on racks, covered with a damp tea towel to keep them soft or uncovered if you prefer a drier crust. Slather with fresh butter and honey or jam.

Makes 4 farls.

— Adapted from “Clodagh’s Irish Kitchen” by Clodagh McKenna (Kyle Books; March 2015)