Pittsburghers love their comfort foods as much as anyone. Mike Gahr just wishes we craved the ham loaf his family has been making in Venango County since the mid-1970s.

It’s not for lack of trying. Last year, the Franklin resident and his wife, Betsy, set up shop at the The Block Northway Farmers Market in Ross. They’ll be there again this year each Friday afternoon with a cooler full of the frozen oblong loaves, and a slow cooker filled with bite-sized chunks of cooked meat for sampling via toothpick.

The couple have gotten lots of nibbles, and more than a few shoppers have gone home with one of the one-pound loaves, which sell for $6.50. But the meatloaf-like concoction known as Gahr’s Hamloaf still has so many more diehard fans up north, in places like Erie, Grove City and Mr. Gahr’s parents’ hometown of Oil City, as well as over the border in Ohio.

“It’s a hard market to get into,” says his wife, who’s from Pittsburgh. And it’s not just because local tastes tend to vary. It appears ham loaf suffers from age discrimination, too.

Advertise with us

While those 50 and up often recognize the dish as something from church picnics or Sunday dinners with grandma, younger people, at least in Steelers Country, are totally clueless.

“They’re like, ‘What the heck is it?’” she says.

The answer is: a filling dish with a velvety texture that most likely has its roots in Germany. Think meatloaf, only made with ham, and ground pork instead of the classic mix of ground beef, pork and veal.

Ham loaf is thought to have originated with the Pennsylvania Dutch, the German-speaking immigrants who settled in and around Lancaster County in the 18th and 19th centuries. While home cooks turned to it for economic measures — it’s a great way to use up leftover ham — it was available commercially by the 1930s at Kraft Brothers Markets in Oil City and nearby Titusville.

When Mr. Gahr’s father, Leo, purchased the Oil City meat market in 1976, he renamed it Gahr’s Southside Market. The recipe for ham loaf — from a 1930s Domino Sugar cookbook found in the rafters — came with it.

Advertise with us

Today, Gahr’s Hamloaf is frozen until it’s sold. But back in the early days, the ham loaf came fresh, wrapped in butcher’s paper at the store.

The family added its own touches to the recipe over the years, and during the 1980s, ham loaf became the market’s most sought-after item — more popular even than its smoked meats and deer processing business. Then the older Gahrs decided to retire and sold the shop in 1988, to the despair of fans.

Betsy was one of them. Her mother, who worked as a school nurse in Franklin, would regularly bring the ham loaf home as a treat. When she met Mr. Gahr for the first time, her immediate response was not “Oh, he’s cute,” but, “Oh, Gahr’s Hamloaf!”

Mr. Gahr thinks some of the reason ham loaf gets a bad rap is because there are a lot of bad versions in grocery store delicatessens. His loaves are quick frozen for better consistency, whereas deli ham loaf can get mushy and turn gray. “And it’s hard to get excited about gray meat.”

He churns out about 1,000 pounds of ham loaf a week and makes all the local deliveries in person. Shipped orders are especially popular in Florida, where he jokes half of the population used to live in Venango County. His ham loaf is available at Giant Eagle locations in Venango, Erie and Crawford counties.

Advertise with us

The loaf can be made at home with ground ham, eggs, dry or prepared mustard (and sometimes both), crushed saltines or breadcrumbs as filler, and milk. Some add a little ground pork for flavor, or with spices like curry powder, ginger and/​or cloves,

Served as an entree with mashed potatoes or mac ‘n’ cheese, ham loaf is often baked with some sort of sweet and tangy glaze on top — typically a mixture of brown sugar and vinegar with a dash of ground mustard. Gahrs’ Hamloaf is sweet enough on its own since it includes brown sugar.

The loaf can be grilled or baked to give it a slight char. Sliced cold and slathered with mayo, it could be a perfect addition for a Fourth of July picnic.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.