Presque Isle State Park, a 7-mile-long spit of sand that juts out into Lake Erie, is a magnet for rare birds.
But few have drawn the kind of crowds that Alaska’s state bird – the willow ptarmigan — did when it took a monthlong vacation on the beach, marking its first ever Pennsylvania sighting.
The plump game bird, about as tall as a crow, might be a little chunkier after eating a bounty of food, including native willow leaves, on Presque Isle.
The female willow ptarmigan (pronounced TAR-mi-gan) sported her summer plumage — a white underbelly topped by mottled brown plumage — when she was reported on Presque Isle on June 21. But it seems she had already been in town for a few days.
After a social media frenzy, someone contacted the Erie Bird Observatory with photos of the same bird on the peninsula on June 16. A non-birder wanted someone to identify the weird-looking bird, said Katie Andersen, a naturalist for the Erie Bird Observatory, headquartered at the Tom Ridge Environmental Center in the the state park.
Before one of the ptarmigan’s last sighting on July 18, hundreds of birders from nearby states and far afield descended on Presque Isle. National birding superstar Bruce Barrett, of San Jose, Calif., visited Erie to view the bird on the last day it was seen, according to eBird. The bird reappeared on Gull Point on Aug. 1.
The ptarm, as some birders call it, did not disappoint.
Rarities usually stay for a day or two at Presque Isle’s Gull Point. This wayward Arctic visitor apparently preferred a much longer visit in Erie.
“This is a bird that I didn’t expect to see unless I hit the lottery to travel to Alaska to see it. This made my year,” Andersen said.
Birders rushed to Presque Isle after learning about the sighting from rare bird alerts as well as eBird reports, an internet platform with crowd-sourced bird sightings.
“It’s the kind of bird that if you are within driving distance, you are going for it,” Andersen said.
The day after the first sighting, she struck out shortly after dawn in the rain.
“I was there for five hours watching her and people started to arrive from the other end of the state by then,” Anderson said.
She ran into about 30 people in the morning and another 30 people in the evening.
But there was a catch: You needed to walk nearly a mile along the beach to reach the desolate tip of the peninsula known as Gull Point.
Excited birders didn’t care. They waited patiently for the avian celebrity to appear from a stand of phragmites, an invasive grass.
“The perfect plump ptarmigan eventually emerged from the phrag for some killer looks, before tucking herself under some driftwood, and into our hearts,” said one Pennsylvania visitor on eBird.
Another exclaimed, “AHHHHHHH BABYYYY!!! Continuing little chubby guy wandering around the same area as yesterday, often disappearing for short periods of time in the phrags.”
Other visitors noted how chill the bird was as they baked in the heat.
“Continuing mega rarity, refound by others just as we were leaving Presque Isle,” wrote another birder on eBird.
“After walking up and down the point in the hot sun all afternoon, we find her here, sitting calmly on a pile of vegetation at the edge of the pond behind a bike rental.”
When the thermometer reached 90 degrees and above, the ptarmigan hunkered down in the shade under shrubs and panted the way birds sometimes do in the heat, Andersen said.
The ptarmigan seemed to handle July’s heat dome and powerful storms better than some of her fans. Park staff responded to a handful of medical calls for possible heat stroke and dehydration from birders who ventured to Gull Point unprepared.
“People were very excited to see the rare bird but forgot to take care of themselves,” said Holly Best, a park manager.
Some visitors were new to the state park and didn’t take water with them for what is a deceivingly arduous trek.
“There is very little shade there and you have to walk in loose sand,” Best said. “Although the terrain is flat, it’s still demanding to walk to Gull Point.”
Park administration noted an uptick in birders visits while the rare bird was on site. Presque Isle typically attracts about 4 million visitors a year – the most of any state park in the commonwealth – with the bulk frequenting its sandy beaches in the summertime.
To beat the heat while walking to Gull Point, Anderson periodically stepped into the lake to cool her feet. She sympathized with the visitors who overheated.
“When you are a birder, sometimes the bird takes over all rational senses. You get so focused on the bird,” she said. “I’ve made choices that I probably wouldn’t have made in another situation.”
Andersen saw the ptarmigan eating a lot, especially feeding on the interior sandbar willows. On hot days, the bird resumed feeding in the evening and was seen drinking from Lake Erie.
“Every time I saw her walking along in the sand, I thought, ‘This is wrong and this is weird,’” said Andersen.
She did a little online sleuthing and discovered what appears to be the same ptarmigan, identified by photos, in Ontario, Canada, in late May on the northeast end of Lake Erie.
“She could have been working her way along the southern shore of Lake Erie," Andersen said.
When resting, the bird hid under a shrub or other cover and was well camouflaged. Anderson said she might turn up in another cool place.
“I suspect that since she is a bird from a cooler environment, the ptarmigan might take advantage of the cooler days to go farther afield.”
Though this rare bird is gone, Andersen and other birders will continue to make the trek to Gull Point to catch a glimpse of the federally endangered piping plover. Three pairs of plovers are nesting there this year and produced a dozen chicks.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.