Fifty years ago, Police Chief Martin Brody’s yell for beachgoers to “get out of the water” in “Jaws” changed how people thought about what shared the ocean with them.
Jim and Dan Hoffman have never heard that command at Pymatuning Lake or any of the other places they regularly fish. But the Beaver County residents know the look big, toothy fish can spark.
Jim, of Ohioville, and his father, Dan, of New Brighton, both specialize in fishing for muskies, the fiercest-looking freshwater fish to call Pennsylvania home. They’re good at it, too. Though muskies are sometimes called “the fish of a thousand casts” because it’s hard to catch one even under the best circumstances, the Hoffmans put 201 in their boat last year and lost another 59 right at its edge.
The biggest stretched longer than 50 inches — the benchmark for true monsters — and plenty of others measured in at 45-50 inches.
The way people react to those behemoths at Pymatuning State Park in Crawford County, with its popular swimming beaches, is often similar.
“One of the remarks we often hear from people is, ‘And I swim in that lake?’” Dan said.
“People are shocked when they find out where these fish come from,” Jim agreed. “The guys that know, they know, but the average person is probably not aware of these fish out there.”
The pair reeled in their first by accident. They were fishing the Ohio River one March close to a decade ago, trying for walleyes and hybrid striped bass. Something big hit Dan’s lure, attached to 8-pound test line.
“I just thought it was a big carp or something,” he said. “I didn’t get all worked up over it. Then I brought it in to the boat and it turned out to be a 46-inch muskie.
“We were both so shocked to see this giant fish. We decided right then and there: ‘Wow, this is fun. Let’s go for more of these.’”
Consistent success didn’t come right away, though. Early on, getting one fish a day or even 30 in a season (they fish year-round) was a big deal. They finally topped 100 in a season three years ago. Now, they’re doubling that.
Credit for that goes to hard work, Jim said. Once a hunter of deer, turkey and pheasant as well as a fisherman, he now spends 100 days a year pursuing muskies, typically on the water 12 or more hours each time out.
Pymatuning is his go-to (he has a camp in Linesville), but he, Dan and other friends also fish the Ohio and Beaver rivers, the Kinzua Dam and other waters in Pennsylvania and other states.
“That old cliché people like to say about ‘Time is money?’ Well, my dad likes to say ‘Time is musky,’” Jim said. “And that’s true. It’s all about time on the water. You’ve just got to pound it.”
There’s skill involved, too, of course.
How to catch ’em
Most of the state’s musky fishing is the result of stockings carried out by the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission.
The agency used to put a few muskies into a lot of waters to give people all over the chance to catch one. It later switched to stocking fewer waters, but giving each more fish to create targeted fisheries. More recently still, it’s been stocking muskies as yearlings — fish 12-14 inches long — rather than as fingerlings a third that size, to boost survival rates.
Even in the best musky waters, fish aren’t evenly distributed. Anglers have to move with the fish to catch them consistently.
In spring, for example, the Hoffmans often troll in water as shallow as 6 feet. Muskies, going through their spawning ritual, are often in skinny water around weeds then. Later, when water temperatures warm in summer, the fish move deeper, sometimes to depths of 15-20 feet.
“At Pymatuning, we start out fishing shallow. And if we’re not seeing anything on our electronics, we move deeper,” Jim said. “We keep sliding deeper until we find them.
“If we get our first fish, say, in 8 feet of water, we fish that depth until we need to try something else. And we use the same or similar lures on other rods, or cast the same style of bait.”
In lakes, fishing around structure — weeds, but also rocks or downed timber — is always a good place to start, as muskies are ambush predators. Sometimes, especially in shallow water, that kind of cover is obvious, like a blowdown along a shoreline. In deeper water, it can be more subtle.
“It doesn’t take much,” Dan said. “You’d be surprised. It might be a bump just a couple feet tall on the bottom or a boulder or something like that and they’ll stick around those areas.”
To get fish often means getting close to that cover. Jim fishes as near as he can without fouling his lures.
In rivers, it pays to check out creek mouths and creek channels. Dams, which offer not structure but oxygenated water, are likely spots, too, as they draw baitfish that serve as forage, Jim said.
There are other factors to consider, like speed. When the anglers troll in spring, and fish are either more lethargic or more content to stay in the shallows, dragging lures at about 3.5 mph is often effective, Dan said.
“They’re pretty sensitive to that speed. If you go too fast, they won’t go after it,” he noted. “But after they come out of the spawn, they’re hungry, and they tend to go after a little faster, bigger bait, so we usually troll around 4-5 miles an hour.”
Their crankbait-looking baits can run anywhere from about 3 inches long to more than a foot. Some are painted to mimic actual baitfish; others are unlike anything in nature. Those painted in a fire tiger pattern — bright yellow and orange below, neon green on top, with black tiger stripes — are some of their favorites.
Many of their baits are handmade, crafted by Wiley Lures and Leo-Lures, both in Ellwood City, and Zach Baker in Rochester, N.Y. But mass-produced baits available in big box outdoors stores catch fish, too, and generally cost less to start, Dan noted.
When casting, they often switch to big spinners with giant blades and sometimes tails, he added.
As you’d expect, landing fish as big and toothy as the ones the Hoffmans catch means using heavy tackle. When it comes to line, they use a 130-pound test fluorocarbon leader for trolling and often a wire leader when casting. Their main line is 100-pound test braid in all situations.
No matter the lure, line, location or technique, there are no guarantees, Jim said. What works in one water on one day may not work in another on that or another day. Sometimes, things can even vary from day to day at the same place.
“It’s very situational,” he said. “The tactics you use on Ohio River can be different than the ones you would use on Pymatuning on the same given day. These fish are unpredictable.
“So what I always say if you’re just starting out is you need to master one place,” Jim said. “Learn a lake or a river, whatever it might be. Just go there and catch as many fish as you can. You’re going to learn a lot about the fish in general. Then you can take that skill and you can kind of translate it to another lake or another river.
“You might have to tweak things a little bit. But you’re still using those principles you mastered from fishing one place over and over.”
Best musky waters
The Fish and Boat Commission maintains a list of “best fishing waters.” They’re lakes and river sections that biologist surveys have shown to hold good numbers of particular species. Its list of best musky waters (available at tinyurl.com/pafishingwaters) includes eight lakes and nine river sections.
About half of them are in the western end of the state. They include portions of the Allegheny, Monongahela and Youghiogheny rivers as well as Pymatuning, Keystone and Canadohta lakes.
All of those waters — and plenty of others that are also stocked — have potential to give up some truly large fish, Jim said. Already this year, he, his girlfriend Pamela Caplinger and Dan have caught several between 46 and 47 inches. All have fish longer than 50 inches to their credit, too.
“Just about any water that has muskies in it, there’s a big one in there,” Jim said. “There are some that have more than others. But if you go to any lake or river in Pennsylvania that gets stocked with muskies, you’re probably going to find one 45 inches and up.”
Whether you can land it is another question. Getting a fish that big up close is an adrenaline rush like few others, as Brody found out in “Jaws”.
“I keep telling Jim when we get some of these, we’re going to need a bigger boat,” Dan joked.
Handling muskies
The dog days of summer can be hard. Fish and Boat records of angler catches per hour of effort show that muskies are generally hard to come by in July.
But some of the best musky fishing of the year is coming. Those same records reveal August is historically one of the better months for landing the fish in lakes, while the action in rivers peaks in September.
As for where to catch them, the commission maintains an online map showing the locations of all waters in the state — not just the best of the best — that hold muskies. See it at tinyurl.com/paallmusky.
The commission has advice on what gear to use and how and when to use it, too, at tinyurl.com/pamuskygear/
Just remember, it takes muskies years to reach really big sizes. So if you catch one — and especially if you plan to release it — handle it as little as possible before getting it back into the water.
“Muskies are not robust and rugged like people think they would be given their size,” said Jim.
Handling them too much removes the protective slime that covers their bodies as a defense against disease. They can’t breathe out of the water either, of course. Leave them on the bottom of the boat, he said, and they sometimes thrash around to the point of sustaining fatal injuries.
So the Hoffmans practice CPR: catch, photo, release. If they catch a fish they want to photograph and measure, they lift it from the water, take a shot, note the length and girth, and return it — all within about 15 seconds.
“One thing a lot of musky anglers preach is, as a general rule, don’t hold fish out of water any longer than you can hold your breath,” Jim said.
With smaller muskies, ones they don’t take photos of, they unhook and release them without ever taking them out of the water.
“Because one day that thing’s going to be a 50-incher and you’ll be glad you let it go,” he added.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.