It’s true there are few better places to fish for walleyes right now than Lake Erie. But it’s also true it takes some special gear — from bigger boats to sonar to downriggers and more — to fish effectively.

Fortunately, there are plenty of other, easier-fished places that offer the chance to get walleyes, too.

Just look at the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission’s map designating the state’s “best fishing waters.” It singles out the rivers and lakes where anglers can expect to find the most fish, by species, based on surveys done by biologists.

And those selections offer just the “best” waters. It doesn’t account for lots of other places with plenty of potential. The Youghiogheny River, for example, produced the state record walleye in 2021. Richard Nicholson of Connellsville was fishing with a live creek chub as bait within Connellsville city limits when he landed an 18-pound, 1-ounce fish.

Advertise with us

The Yough’s not on the Fish and Boat map.

Pittsburgh lunkers

Neither is Pittsburgh.

Yet the “Pittsburgh pool” — from Emsworth on the Ohio River to Braddock on the Monongahela River and Lock and Dam No. 2 on the Allegheny River — is a legitimate walleye hot spot, said Mike Depew, a fisheries biologist in Fish & Boat’s Area 8 office in Somerset.

It’s full of prey species: shad, small shiners and red-horse suckers. They feed lots of walleyes, many of them big.

“The walleyes grow fast in that area and they grow to large sizes,” Depew said.

Advertise with us

But walleyes are thriving far beyond that part of the three rivers.

Anglers do very well on the Monongahela River around Charleroi, said David Plants, co-owner of Shadlure Tackle, a bait and tackle shop in West Elizabeth, reeling in good numbers of fish and some very large ones.

“I wouldn’t be surprised if the new state record came from the Mon,” Plants said.

That’s possible, Depew agreed. One Fish and Boat survey done just below the dam in Charleroi revealed a 34-inch, 14-pound walleye, he said.

Even, bigger was a 40-inch walleye state Department of Environmental Protection crews handled in the Allegheny near Freeport. They didn’t get to weigh it, Depew said, but the commission’s “weight-length estimator” — a chart that assigns a likely weight to a fish relative to its length, based on thousands of Pennsylvania fish handled over the years —  suggests it would have been really, really heavy.

Advertise with us

The chart offers likely weights for walleyes from 15 inches, the legal minimum for harvest, to 33 inches. That latter length typically equates to a fish weighing 14.8 pounds.

“So I can only imagine what that (40-incher) would have weighed if they’d had the opportunity to find out,” Depew said.

Pennsylvania’s statewide walleye season opened on May 3 and continues through mid-March of 2026. Anglers can keep six per day, with a minimum size of 15 inches.

Where to find walleye

Walleyes in general prefer water with a rocky or gravel bottom, according to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission. They’ll go for a variety of live baits, such as minnows, leeches and night crawlers fished on a jig head or a slip ring on or near the bottom, as well as on artificial lures. Those can include jigs, crankbaits, twisters and spinners. Look for lures in bright green, yellow, gold, silver, black and purple.

In all cases, equip your reel with line in the 6- to 12-pound test range, the agency recommends, and fish early and late in the day in spring and fall and after dark in summer.

Advertise with us

Certain rivers support walleyes as the result of natural reproduction, meaning fish breeding successfully enough to replenish their numbers. Other good walleye waters, mostly lakes, are the result of a large stocking program run by the Fish & Boat Commission. This year alone, the agency will plant nearly 12.9 million walleye “fry” (fish less than 1 inch long) and over 1.7 million walleye fingerlings (1-2 inches long) in waters around the state.

That program underwent an important change more than a decade ago.

“The purpose for almost all the walleye stocking in Pennsylvania ... is to establish put- grow and-take fisheries,” reads the agency’s walleye management plan. “As such, it is important that the [commission] maximize the use of a limited supply of walleye fingerlings and fry to ensure that stocking creates high-quality fisheries.”

Once upon a time, Fish and Boat put a relative few walleyes in a whole slew of water — the thought being that would give more anglers in more places at least a chance of hooking one. But such almost “incidental” catches led to little angler satisfaction. So these days, the commission stocks fewer waters, but puts more fish in each.

The results have been impressive in some cases. Pymatuning Lake in Crawford County, for example, gets walleye fry and fingerlings — sometimes both in the same year — to the tune of millions annually. Plenty of those fish survive and grow up.

Advertise with us

A 2024 survey of the lake resulted in catching 2,601 walleyes in trap nets. More notably, the catch of fish per trap net hour (a measure used to monitor abundance of fish relative to the time spent looking for them) was the third highest ever since 1989. It also represented a third straight year of increasing catch rates, following historic lows in 2021.

Tim Wilson, Linesville-based fisheries manager for Areas 1 and 2, said that was likely due to the high survival of walleyes stocked in 2019 and 2020, “with these year classes having reached large enough size to be captured in our nets.”

Pymatuning’s average walleye was 17.2 inches last spring, he said.

Giving up fewer fish overall, but more per hour, last spring was Lake Wilhelm, the centerpiece of Maurice K. Goddard State Park in Mercer County. The most common size was 22 and 23 inches, though some were as long as 29 inches.

“Based on our results, with multiple year classes represented and an overall catch exceeding the minimum required rate, it is evident that our stocking program is producing a viable walleye fishery for harvestable and trophy-sized fish,” reads a report of that work.

Advertise with us

Attack of the shad

Biologists didn’t see a lot of smaller walleyes in their survey, indicating poor survival of stocked fish in recent years. But the commission is experimenting with stocking more walleyes per acre in Wilhelm than is the norm going forward, which may help address that.

So, too, might fewer gizzard shad. Shad don’t eat young walleyes, but they can outcompete them for food. And Lake Wilhelm has had way too many for a long time, Wilson said.

“But in the winter of 2023-24, the folks at the state park reported a big die-off of gizzard shad,” he said. “I know our last survey prior to this last one, we got 8,000 in our nets. Then, in our most recent survey, we got a couple hundred.”

There are even some smaller lakes — ones easily fished even without a boat — that can produce walleyes in good numbers. Two on the state’s “best” list are Lake Gordon in Bedford County and Green Lick Run on the border of Fayette and Westmoreland counties.

Lake Gordon is a 120-acre impoundment owned by Evitts Creek Water Co. A survey done this spring caught more than 2½ times as many legal-sized walleyes per hour as needed to rate the waterway a “quality” walleye fishery, said Area 7 fisheries manager, Bryan Chikotas.

Advertise with us

Multiple surveys done at Green Lick, meanwhile, reveal an increasing number of both walleyes and legal-sized walleyes. Some of the best fishing is available from the shore, too, especially in those areas where the commission has installed habitat-improvement features.

So there are, in short, plenty of waters worth trying if you want to get into walleyes this spring. Erie, fantastic though it has been as of late, is not the only option.

Depew was fishing the Monongahela, for example, when a friend landed a 12-pounder. He’s yet to top that, but there’s always hope, he said.

“I’ve got five or six of them in day over 25 inches, though, so it’s possible.”