Living in Erie isn’t for everyone — especially not in winter — but Billy Hines always knew that’s where he wanted to be, specifically because of the cold.

He grew up ice fishing with his dad and uncle on waters like Presque Isle Bay, where getting to bluegills, crappies and the like often meant boring holes through several feet of frozen water. He loved every minute of it.

So though he later went to school at Slippery Rock University, then lived in nearby Indiana, Pa., there was no question he would eventually return home.

“Honestly, growing up, I remember thinking I never want to move away from here because I love ice fishing,” said Hines, who works as a tackle buyer with FishUSA, a tackle shop in Fairview. “I couldn’t wait for winter because of it. Then I actually moved away for about eight years and came back, and I don’t think we’ve had ice since.”

Advertise with us

Certainly not enough for a hardwater angler, anyway.

Hines and friend Gus Glasgow of Harrisville in Butler County run the Western PA Hardwater Tournament Series. Launched in 2016, it was, at its peak, the largest competitive ice fishing circuit in the country, drawing anglers from Vermont to Minnesota and points in between to as many as five events across the region each winter.

Then, the ice disappeared.

If Hines and company are able hold a tournament in 2025 — and they’re planning just one, the Flagship Ice Open at Presque Isle on Feb. 1 — it will be their first since 2022. All those scheduled the last two winters were canceled because there wasn’t safe ice. That’s 4 inches, at a minimum.

That’s been the lot of ice anglers all across Pennsylvania lately. Theirs has been a sport without a playing field.

Advertise with us

Blame it on unusually warm conditions. Colton Milcarek, a meteorologist with the National Weather Service in Pittsburgh, said the winter of 2022-23 was the warmest since 1950, when the agency started measuring temperatures at the Pittsburgh airport. Then, the winter of 2023-24 was warmer yet.

That was bad news for ice anglers. What’s worse is that it’s indicative of a longer-term, still-continuing trend. Milcarek said Pennsylvania winters have been slowly but steadily getting milder for decades now.

The pace at which they’re warming has really picked up steam in the last 25 years or so, added Kyle Elliott, director of the Weather Information Center at Millersville University in Lancaster.

Those changes can be hard to detect from one winter to the next, being a percentage of a degree difference here and there, Milcarek said. But over time, they add up.

“A couple degrees doesn’t sound like a lot,” Milcarek said. “But if that’s the difference between 31 degrees and 33 degrees, it’s also the difference between ice and no ice. So when we ride that line, even small changes can mean a lot.”

Advertise with us

According to the National Snow and Ice Data Center, it can take days to weeks for a lake to freeze over, depending on air temperature, wind, snow cover and water depth. The more “freezing degree-days” — a measure of how cold it’s been and for how long — in a row, the better and faster ice forms.

“But the cold snaps that we get tend to be less frequent and less cold than what we’ve seen in the past,” Milcarek said.

That’s not just a Western Pennsylvania phenomenon, he added. The same thing is occurring all across the mid-Atlantic and beyond.

But it’s certainly had consequences here, where the ice fishing season at best runs from December through February or so.

Allegheny Angler in Tarentum, which opened in 1988, once sold ice fishing gear along with bait and other supplies. It doesn’t anymore and has no plans to do so again.

Advertise with us

“There’s just no point,” said co-owner Ed DeMichele. “We used to carry the tips-ups, the augers, all that stuff. But then it would all just go upstairs and collect dust and then come down the next winter, then go back up. We don’t even order it anymore.

“I think last year we had ice for three days and that was it.”

Scott Gates, owner of S&S Bait and Tackle of Chalkhill, Fayette County, just stocked his store with ice fishing equipment. But, he noted, it’s inventory he bought three years ago and hasn’t moved, as fishermen are slow to buy gear they fear they won’t be able to use.

The desire to ice fish still exists, he said. In the winter of 2021, what he called the last good ice season, anglers flocked to High Point Lake — located near Mt. Davis, Pennsylvania’s highest point, in Somerset County — when the lake froze.

“The first weekend of safe ice my buddy was up there and he counted 80 shanties before he lost count,” Gates said. “We went through every piece of bait we had here. Everything that we had was gone.

Advertise with us

“When the ice is good, the weekends are good. It’s just as busy as it is in the spring for trout season. We just need it to get cold and stay cold.”

Or anglers need to be willing to travel. Jordy Allison, a biologist with the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission who’s also an instructor for the agency’s learn- to ice-fish programs, typically ice fishes in Pennsylvania from mid-December through the first week of March.

The warmth of the last two winters, though, shortened his season by a month or more. It wasn’t worse only because he’ll drive a couple hours from his Centre County home to find ice if that’s what it takes.

“Over the last two years, it’s been relatively difficult to find safe ice with any consistency. However, I have never had a season in 17 years where I have not been able to ice fish at least a little bit of time,” Allison said.

In the future, though, he may have to travel even farther. Milcarek said long-term projections suggest Western Pennsylvania’s winters might, in 50 to 100 years, look more like those of Kentucky and Tennessee today.

Advertise with us

That’s not to say this region won’t ever see cold again. There will always be variations, with some years more frozen than others, he said. But the average winter is warmer now than before, and even warmer ones are probably on the way.

“There will always be cold weather,” Milcarek said. “But there’s looking to be a lot less of it in the future. Which might not be good news for ice fishermen.”

It’s certainly not for Allison. Ice fishing gives him an excuse to get outdoors in winter, and provides meals. Panfish caught through the ice — bluegills, crappies, pumpkinseed and yellow perch — are the only fish he harvests in a year’s time.

But he says there’s more to this pursuit than exercise and table fare.

“There’s also something very magical about drilling a hole in a frozen lake and actually being able to catch fish out of it,” Allison said.

Advertise with us

“With open water, you can go out in your kayak or your boat or you can wade and you can cover a lot of water. But with ice fishing, to think that you can figure out where fish are in a lake and drill a hole on top of them and catch them in a 5-foot radius, there’s something pretty special about it for me.”

Hines loves the sport, too, and was thrilled to get out once or twice last year to introduce his young son to it. He hopes for more such days in the future, and for more Hardwater Series events.

If only the weather cooperates.

“Growing up here on Presque Isle Bay, I remember drilling through 24 inches of ice. And now, I don’t know if we’ll ever see that again,” Hines said. “It definitely doesn’t feel like that’s something that’s even possible at this point.

“But hopefully we have a good year where we can all get out and fish multiple days instead of just one.”

Advertise with us

For more

The Western PA Hardwater Tournament Series’ Flagship Ice Open is scheduled for Feb. 1 on Presque Isle Bay in Erie County. Entry costs $100 per two-person team. There will be cash payouts to the top finishers, plus thousands of dollars in giveaways from sponsors. Each registrant also gets a Flagship Flex ice rod.

For registration information and to stay up to date on ice conditions, visit facebook.com/WesternPAFishing.

The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission periodically holds virtual “introduction to ice fishing” programs. Participants can then attend an in-person event later in winter.

Those classes are finished for the season (find them in the future at register-ed.com/programs/pennsylvania). But the agency has lots of introductory ice fishing videos on its YouTube channel to help would-be anglers get started. Go to youtube.com/@PAfishandboat and search “ice fishing.”

Bob Frye (bfryeoutdoors@comcast.net) is a journalist who has covered the outdoors for 30 years. He works for the Pennsylvania Game Commission as associate editor of its Game News magazine.