Doug Shriber of Squirrel Hill has caught a muskie or two, but he had never seen anything like the 26-incher he boated May 12.

Taken while trolling on the Allegheny River about 10 miles from Pittsburgh, the fish’s sides didn’t have the typical pale, striated pattern. It didn’t have the distinctive stripes of a tiger muskie, a sterile hatchery hybrid pairing a male Northern pike and a female muskellunge.

Shriber’s muskie had spots.

“It was about 10:45 a.m. I had four rods in and was trolling upriver by a big shallow inlet,” he said. “It was where fast water and slow water met, a good ambush spot.”

Advertise with us

The fish took a mid-sized, jointed black-silver Berkley Flicker Shad and jumped once before Schriber got it to the boat. He snapped a selfie and released the fish, certain it was a muskie. But what kind of muskie?

Esox masquinongy is a big voracious predator native to North American waters from Hudson Bay tributaries to the Mississippi River system. Stealthy, generally solitary and notoriously difficult to catch, muskies have a reputation for mystery. The Pennsylvania state record is 54 pounds 3 ounces, but it’s hotly contested. The world record muskie weighed somewhere between 67 pounds 8 ounces and 70 pounds 10 ounces, depending on which record-keeping organization you ask.

The muskellunge is one of Pennsylvania’s largest and fastest-growing fish, but unprotected larval muskies and fry are heavily preyed upon, even by each other. The state Fish and Boat Commission stocks muskies in rivers and lakes to supplement the population.

Fish and Boat also cultures and stocks sterile tiger muskies, which are hardier than their purebred parents, grow faster and are more willing to take an angler’s bait. Gary Smith, Fish and Boat southwest region fisheries manager, has an explanation for Shriber’s spotted catch.

“It is a purebred muskellunge,” he said, “based on the amount of scales on the cheek and gill cover, markings on the side of the body and size of the fish.”

Advertise with us

Fish and Boat stocked purebred muskie yearlings in the lower Allegheny River in 2022. Smith said those fish are now about the size of the muskie boated by Shriber.

“Our broodstock is Ohio strain muskellunge that are used to stock muskies in all Pennsylvania waters except Presque Isle Bay, where we use Great Lakes strain muskellunge,” said Smith. “Patterning – clear, spotted or barred – on the side of the body can vary quite a bit in juvenile muskies.”

Wisconsin anglers are more familiar with the spots. The state Department of Natural Resources stocks the spotted strain, augmenting reproduction in the fish’s native waters, Lake Michigan. Since the last Ice Age, many of the lake’s purebred muskellunge have been naturally spotted.

“It’s not a different species. It’s a strain, a color variation,” said Aaron Schiller, a fisheries biologist for Wisconsin DNR.

With heavy fishing pressure in Green Bay, a western arm of Lake Michigan, DNR stocks muskellunge to bolster the native population.

Advertise with us

“We stock [several] strains,” said Schiller. “Great Lakes muskies, the Wisconsin River strain, Leech Lake strain and spotted muskies. They’re not hybrids, they’re all purebreds. But [the strains] have different color variations.”

Shriber’s Allegheny River catch was not a Frankenfish. More likely, it was a purebred muskellunge with a spotty color variation and a great ambush-feeding spot.

Lake Erie (Erie County) More than a month before the western basin walleye migration reaches Pennsylvania waters, several boat limits were reported by walleye charter captains. Independent anglers found resident walleye throughout the water column, and reported hookups while trolling harnesses or white-chartreuse lures. Kayak fisherman Dan Morey of Erie said the ’eyes were in 5-25 feet of water along the eastside shore, and he boated one in the 30-inch range while jigging in 15 feet..

Lake trout were abundant. The Reel Nutz gang launched at North East Sunday and were trolling spoons and Spin-N-Glows with dipseys and riggers in 55-80 feet of water, when Tommy Delvecchio of Raccoon boated a 37-inch 25-pound lake trout. “It is by far the biggest fish we ever caught on our boat,” said owner Tom Campbell. On an outstanding lake trout day, the party also caught two 18-pounders, one 16-pounder and nine additional lake trout under 15 pounds.

Smallmouth bass were taken at 30 feet or less out of North East, and at dropoffs from Avonia Beach to Erie Bluffs State Park. In Presque Isle Bay, a 20-inch smallmouth took a soft plastic lure tossed near fallen wood in Misery Bay. Yellow perch were hard to find, but crappies continued to be caught off the north and south piers.

Advertise with us

Pymatuning Reservoir (Crawford County) Steven Brophy of Pittsburgh boated several walleye from 20-23 inches trolling at night off Tuttle Point Campground.

Ohio River (Allegheny County) Stripers, or striped bass, are big broad-bodied game fish from the true bass family. Here’s how to tell if you caught one: Holding the fish in two hands, look around your location. If you’re in Western Pennsylvania, you didn’t.

Ocean-running Atlantic striped bass migrate up and down the Susquehanna and Delaware rivers, and landlocked stripers are in Raystown Lake. The fish erroneously called “stripers” caught in Lake Arthur, Shenango River Lake and the rivers around Pittsburgh are either native white bass or hybrid striped bass, a sterile cultured cross of a white and a striped bass.

Fish and Boat breeds and stocks the fast-growing hybrids because they tolerate warmer water, grow larger than white bass and give inland anglers a chance to catch an exciting predator that can reach 10-12 pounds. With water temperatures at 50-55 degrees throughout the region, white bass and hybrid striped bass are fattening up before running upstream to spawn – the hybrids try to spawn, but can’t.

Rich Dibler of Center boated a nice hybrid May 11 while he and a friend trolled in muddy water near Sewickley. The fish stretched to 24 inches and weighed 7 pounds.

Advertise with us

Allegheny River (Allegheny County) Doug Shriber of Squirrel Hill released a 26-inch muskellunge caught May 12 while trolling a deep-diving lure along a seam of fast- and slow-moving water near a shallow inlet.

Chet Stofman caught two small rockbass on crawlers during Venture Outdoors’ Lunchtime Fishing program on the North Shore Riverwalk near the Water Steps and Acrisure Stadium. Scheduled from 11:30 a.m.-1:30 p.m. Wednesdays, the program provides loaner rods and tackle, free live bait and fishing instruction, and state fishing licenses are not required. Get details at ventureoutdoors.org.

Twin Lakes (Westmoreland County) Rainbow trout took deep-diving crankbaits, spinners and live bait. An 18-inch golden rainbow went for paste bait suspended 1 foot off the bottom on the lower lake Monday at around 7 p.m.

Monongahela River (Fayette County) A 32-inch flathead catfish took a worm gob fished from shore near the mouth of Redstone Creek late Tuesday evening.

File your fishing report and high-resolution digital photos (1MB minimum) at fishingreport@post-gazette.com. Include name, age (for under 18 years), town, species, size, body of water and details of the catch.