Pity the common carp. In its native Asia, the largest member of the minnow family and close cousin to goldfish was cultivated and feasted upon by emperors.

In the 2nd century, Roman armies carried live carp overland to be stocked in the Danube River as a sustainable food source during centuries of European conquest. In the 19th century, the U.S. government imported carp from Europe and stocked them in 25 states to feed a growing population of industrial workers.

During the last century, however, the adaptable omnivore was among the few aquatic species tough enough to survive in the industrial waste of American rivers. The common carp was so common it was widely believed to be a native species and mocked as a bottom-feeding trash fish.

In recent years Cyprinus carpio thrives in clean lakes, rivers and streams, and the reputation of the once noble fish is slowly being redeemed. The common carp is not among three invasive Asian carp species threatening to populate in the Great Lakes. Easier to catch than wary trout and plentiful close to home, the common carp is targeted by some catch-and-release fly fishermen who coax them to sip dry flies off the surface.

Advertise with us

“They have special fly rods and lines for carp, but I just use the 6-weight rod that I use for bass,” said Robert Ferman of Bridgeville. “Work and family take a lot of time, but sometimes I can find an hour or two and just walk down to the creek behind my house and play with the carp.”

In some quarters the big golden fish has regained its once-prime status. A small but growing number of anglers invest in high-tech, carp-specific bowfishing gear, including wide-bottom boats rigged with a raised platform, onboard generator and lights for night fishing.

In 2016, Jordan Miller of Washington, Pa., speared a 43-inch, 49-pound 11-ounce common carp in Youghiogheny River Lake on the Pennsylvania-Maryland border. The fish set a state bowfishing record certified by the Bowfishing Association of America. It was just a few pounds lighter than the 52-pound Pennsylvania hook-and-line record set on the Juniata River in 1962.

In 2022, new common carp records have been set in states bordering Pennsylvania.

Ayden Minick of Mt. Pleasant, Westmoreland County, wasn’t thrilled about fishing with friends on a rainy May day at Summersville Lake, W.Va. He changed his mind when he reeled in a common carp that set a new state record.

Advertise with us

As they arrived at the lake shore May 7, the water and its temperature were quickly rising, exciting the pre-spawn carp into a bottom-rooting frenzy. Minick cast to a drop-off at the end of a mudflat. His “pack bait,” a loose ball of dough expected to dissolve as an attractant, gradually revealed an artificial corn kernel concealing a hook.

By noon he had caught two nice carp weighing 19 and 26 pounds. Then his rod bent and the taut line cut through the water. The fish stayed down throughout a 15- to 20-minute fight before revealing itself at the shoreline.

Minick weighed the big carp at 47 pounds and got a few photos. Knowing that the state record north of the Mason-Dixon is 52 pounds, he was about to throw it back when he was stopped by a friend who knew more about West Virginia state fish records.

The carp was secured in a wet cradle while Minick waited for the catch to be verified by a Department of Natural Resources biologist. In that time the carp dropped a couple of pounds. It’s not unusual for fluids to drain from a fish that is tired and restrained, but its official rating of 45 pounds was shy of the 47-pound state record set in 1998. Nevertheless, in a state that documents weights and lengths of record-setting fish, Minick’s catch stretched to 41.2 inches, 2/10ths of an inch longer than the previous 41-inch record for a common carp in West Virginia.

On June 4, Logan Kuhrmann of Essex, Md., was bass fishing with a spinning rod and plastic worm off the Susquehanna River Flats in the northern arm of Chesapeake Bay. Hooking something heavy, he thought it was a big catfish. Kuhrmann said he was surprised to haul a 49-pound common carp over the gunwale.

Advertise with us

“We’ve seen some really big ones up in the Flats but we’ve never seen one this big, ever,” Kuhrmann said. “The bass fishing wasn’t great but this made my week.”

Kuhrmann’s fish crushed the previous Maryland Chesapeake Division common carp record of 44.4 pounds.