Some fish just won’t take the bait. Dangle it, flash it, bounce it off the fish’s nose and the most wary aquatic predators refuse to become the prey. When a big bass is caught, the lucky angler likely thinks the wise old fish was outsmarted by superior strategy and cunning use of tactics.
Not necessarily.
A fish’s ability to avoid the hook may be more than luck. Research has shown that some largemouth bass are genetically inclined to be easier to catch, a trait that enables other bass to grow disproportionately large.
As open season for largemouth, smallmouth and spotted bass opened Saturday across Pennsylvania, the most popular sportfish in America continues to befuddle beginners, guides and veteran pro anglers. Adapting to changing conditions is always a good idea, and experience counts. But while the fishing community continues to debate whether whoppers get big because of what they eat or where they live, a study at the University of Illinois found that some largemouth bass owe their longevity and size to their parents’ genes. Counterintuitively, the genes don’t make them grow bigger.
In a 20-year experiment, researchers discovered that vulnerability to being hooked is a genetic trait among largemouth bass. What they found was not an inherited propensity for fast growth among some bass. Some bass get big, they said, because other bass are more likely to get caught.
“The potential for angling to have long-term evolutionary impacts on bass populations is real,” said David Philipp, an ecology and conservation researcher at the University of Illinois, in a project overview published in the journal Science Daily. “If we truly want to protect this valuable resource into the future, then we need to understand that and adjust our management strategies.”
Read More
In the study, fishing was strictly controlled on a 15-acre research impoundment run by the Illinois Natural History Survey. Anglers reserved blocks of fishing time and put every fish caught in a livewell. The fish were measured, tagged to track how often each was caught, and released.
“We kept track over four years of all of the angling that went on,” Philipp told Science Daily. “Many fish were caught more than once. One fish was caught three times in the first two days, and another was caught 16 times in one year.”
After four years of documenting the catch, the lake was drained and researchers collected more than 1,700 fish.
“Interestingly, about 200 of those fish had never been caught, even though they had been in the lake the entire four years,” Philipp said.
Largemouth bass that had never been caught were classified as low vulnerability and encouraged to spawn in a separate research pond to create a line of low vulnerability offspring.
Bass that had been caught four or more times were designated high vulnerability and were spawned to produce a line of high vulnerability offspring. The young bass were marked and when big enough were stocked in the research lake. The selection process was continued over several generations.
“Controlled fishing experiments clearly showed that the high vulnerability offspring were more vulnerable to angling than the low vulnerability offspring,” said Philipp.
In fact, he said, throughout the experiment’s 20 years the separation in catch rate between the two groups grew larger. Low vulnerability fish, he said, seemed to become even harder to catch while there was only a small increase in the catch rate of the high vulnerability line.
The consequence of high angling vulnerability, said Phillip, has more to do with the spawn than with angler harvest. Females lay the eggs and males fertilize and guard them in their spawning beds. When the eggs hatch, the males continue to protect the fry from predation. Male bass that were more vulnerable to being caught were hooked and pulled off the nest long enough for bluegills and other predators to deplete the eggs.
“In the wild, the more vulnerable fish are being preferentially harvested, and as a result the bass population is being directionally selected to become less vulnerable,” he said. “We selected over three generations, but in the wild the selection is occurring in every generation.”
That could explain why over time, bass fishing in the same spots can seem to grow more difficult. The study has been used as a basis for opposing regulations that permit fishing, particularly bass tournaments, during the spawn. On Pennsylvania waters from April 9 to June 10, bass regulations require catch and immediate release only, no harvest and no tournaments.
The university researchers didn’t study smallmouth or spotted bass, nor speculate about why some largemouth bass were more likely to get caught. Could it be a matter of inherited inferior eyesight? Lateral line sensitivity? Genetically passed stupidity?
None of that probably mattered to Donald Shade of Waynesboro when he pulled an 11-pound 3-ounce largemouth out of Birch Run Reservoir in 1983. All that really mattered was that his fish set the state record.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.