The last big melt-off of lake ice isn’t necessarily the first big event of spring.

This year, anglers in southwestern Pennsylvania were given a few good weeks of ice fishing. Two weeks ago, ice shanties were still up on Shenango Reservoir, Pymatuning Reservoir and Presque Isle Bay. Although rain, wind and 50-degree days began eroding solid ice in mid-February, anglers are still augering holes on some high mountain lakes east and southeast of Pittsburgh. But those days are numbered as well.

Ice-out starts with the disappearance of hardtop, but that’s just the beginning of a fundamental shift that occurs beneath the surface.

Cooler water is heavier than warm water and contains more oxygen. As ice melts, the resulting cool water sinks. Taking its place, water that is warmer and lighter rises to the top. The lake is said to “turn over.”

Advertise with us

In basins deep enough for warm and cool water to almost completely stratify, a thin thermocline layer forms between those water layers. During ice-out, however, warm water is rising, cool water is dropping and the whole lake is in flux. Fish are on the move, trying to find places that are comfortable and contain prey species.

Shortly after ice-out, Northern pike are the first fish to spawn. When water temperatures range from 40 degrees to a little over 50 degrees, they migrate from lakes to flooded marshes or shallow, weedy backwaters. They don’t nest. Females deposit adhesive eggs during daylight hours over plants and organic debris. Males dart through the weeds fertilizing the eggs. No parental care is given to the eggs or fry, but a biological report prepared by the state Fish and Boat Commission says the early spawn gives Northerns an advantage.

“Because pike spawn so early, their young are large enough to consume newly hatched suckers and other fish that appear later in the spring,” says the report.

As the pike spawn begins, ice covering shallow, shore-side waters is the first to thaw. Although the water is only a few degrees warmer than the rest of the ice-covered lake, plankton develop, insects start to hatch and little fish come to eat them. Those gatherings of small prey spark a mass movement of black crappies into those late-winter feeding sites. White crappies arrive a couple of weeks later.

Joe Fazio of Mount Washington eagerly anticipates ice-out at Lake Arthur in Butler County.

Advertise with us

“Water temperatures trigger the [crappies’] movement toward shallows and cover. I like to see 45-50 degrees,” said the publisher of Lake Arthur Crappie Anglers and Crappie Crushin’ TV Facebook group pages. “That is when I will start finding the blacks schooled up and on cover in depths 4-8 feet generally. The whites trickle in at a slightly higher temperature, and bluegill will pretty much follow suit.”

Fazio looks for bays that are the first to warm and have multiple cover options — weeds, wood, docks, rock piles and at least one hole that drops to 8 feet or more, giving crappies a place to retreat during cold fronts.

“The nicest days – warm sunny afternoons especially late in the day – have the potential to draw in the heaviest movements of crappies,” he said. “Cold, cloudy days typically produce less than satisfactory results.”

The crappies’ late-winter rush to warm, shallow water is not a spawning run. Fazio said they are there for one purpose: to eat as much as they can as fast as they can.

“They need to pack on as much weight as possible as quickly as possible in preparation for the rigors of the spawn,” he said. “They will be there for a few weeks and then will back out to mid depths waiting for the water to reach the ideal spawning temperatures in the spring.”

Advertise with us