A 68-year-old fisherman trolling Lake Erie for steelhead hooked something unexpected: a state record brown trout weighing 20 pounds, 9 ounces. Confirmed by the state Fish and Boat Commission, the trout stretched to 33¾ inches with a girth of more than 21 inches.

Fish and Boat reported that on the morning of Aug. 8, Robert Ferraro of Erie, Pa., and three friends motored out of Walnut Creek Marina aboard his boat, Heartbeat. Targeting steelhead, they began trolling in 74 feet of water off the Condos, an anglers’ landmark east of Walnut Creek and west of the Presque Isle peninsula.

“We had been fishing in the same area the day before and caught some steelhead and walleye,” said Mr. Ferraro. “The water temperature at the bottom of the lake had become warmer overnight and we were not having as much luck. We were just about to go looking for cooler water when our luck changed.”

At approximately 8:30 a.m., Mr. Ferraro saw a big hit on his 9-foot rod strung with 14-pound copolymer line trolling a small spoon held by a downrigger at 56 feet. The fish immediately began to run, he said, taking 50 feet of line. It swirled to the surface but didn’t jump. Mr. Ferraro said his friends were able to net the big fish after a “stressful” 10-minute fight.

Advertise with us

“It was a huge thrill to catch such a big fish, but we didn’t know exactly what it was at first. We suspected it was a brown trout,” he said.

“We know they’re in here, but the biggest ones I’ve caught before were around 12 pounds, and this fish was over 20 pounds. It had a very dark back and some silver coloring on the body that made us question what it was for a minute. We knew if it was a brown trout, it had a great chance to be a record.”

On returning to Walnut Creek Marina, the fish was positively identified as a brown trout by Mark Haffley, Fish and Boat fisheries biologist.

“Older fish like this that have been out in the lake for many years can appear different, but upon examination, it had all the markings of a brown trout including a box-shaped tail, spot pattern and white pigmentation inside its mouth,” said Mr. Haffley. “It’s exciting to see a fish like this, a large female, which we estimate to be at least 6 or 7 years old.”

The trout was weighed on a certified scale in the presence of Waterways Conservation Officer Tyler Soety and Deputy WCO Brad Donor. It was officially recorded at 20 pounds, 9 ounces, exceeding the previous record set in 2000, also by an angler from Erie, by 11 ounces.

Advertise with us

As is required for state record consideration, Mr. Ferraro completed an official state record fish application including color photographs, which was reviewed by PFBC officials and confirmed. State record fish are judged only by weight and must exceed the previous state record by at least 2 ounces.

A lifelong angler, Mr. Ferraro said he is honored to hold the new state record, which he believes could be broken at any time.

“There are absolutely more fish like this out there,” he said. “I really hope it gives other people some motivation to get out and catch them. I think it really underscores how healthy our fishery is right now in Lake Erie.”

The brown trout stocking program was started in 2009 when some 100,000 disease-free brown trout eggs were donated by a New York hatchery. That year the first 7-inch browns, fin clipped for identification, were planted in Presque Isle Bay, Crooked Creek and the protected nursery waters of Godfrey Run and Orchard Beach Creek.

Every year since then, Fish and Boat has stocked approximately 100,000 fingerling brown trout — 10% the number of stocked steelhead — in Lake Erie tributaries and Presque Isle Bay to enhance the quality near-shore fishery. The browns are spawned at the Linesville State Fish Hatchery in Crawford County and raised at other state hatcheries and cooperative nurseries.

Fish and Boat has stated the browns add diversity for fall steelhead anglers fishing the tributaries, as well as Lake Erie anglers like Mr. Ferraro who fish for them in open water.