TOLEDO, Ohio — A federal judge in Ohio says an environmental group pushing for mandatory regulations to prevent toxic algae blooms on Lake Erie can move forward with its landmark lawsuit.

The judge in Toledo issued a ruling in December denying the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s request to dismiss the lawsuit.

The suit is over the eventual cleanup strategy for the lake. The Chicago-based Environmental Law and Policy Center contends the EPA is failing to uphold the federal Clean Water Act by not requiring the state of Ohio to do what’s called a “total maximum daily limit” program — a much more site-specific and tougher regulatory program than what Ohio has ever tried for the lake. The nation’s largest TMDL program involves a six-state program including Pennsylvania for the Chesapeake Bay.

The U.S. Department of Justice, which is representing the EPA in the matter, had asked the judge to dismiss the case, contending the agency is not required to impose such a program on Ohio. The judge, in a 31-page ruling, denied the government’s motion and said he will allow the case to proceed.

Advertise with us

The complaint “plausibly alleges that Ohio EPA has clearly and unambiguously refused to develop a TMDL for western Lake Erie,” the judge wrote.

Lucas County, Ohio, which filed a separate but similar complaint in April 2019, served as the Law and Policy Center’s co-plaintiff for several months. The next-door cities of Toledo and Oregon, Ohio, are recognized by the court as interested parties and the Toledo-based Advocates for a Clean Lake Erie is likewise involved in the case.

Howard Learner, Environmental Law and Policy Center executive director, said he’s pleased with the ruling and now hopes that the court will decide to force Ohio to adopt enforceable regulatory standards for the lake.

“It’s time for the U.S. EPA to follow the Clean Water Act and its requirements, and it’s time for Gov. Mike DeWine to step up and adopt enforceable standards to reduce phosphorus runoff 40 percent by 2025,” he said.

The Associated Press contributed.

Advertise with us