CORVALLIS, Ore. — As Dave Wiens stood amid the thick, old-growth forests in the coastal range of Oregon, he was nervous. Before he trained to shoot his first barred owl, he had never fired a gun.

He eyed the big female owl perched on a branch, her feathers streaked brown and white. He squeezed the trigger and the owl fell to the forest floor, adding to a running tally of more than 2,400 barred owls killed so far in a controversial experiment to test whether the Northern spotted owl’s rapid decline in the Pacific Northwest can be stopped by culling its aggressive East Coast cousin.

Mr. Wiens, a biologist with the U.S. Geological Survey, grew up fascinated by birds. His graduate research in owl interactions helped lay the groundwork for this tense moment.

“It’s a little distasteful, I think, to go out killing owls to save another owl species,” he said. “Nonetheless, I also feel like from a conservation standpoint, our back was up against the wall. We knew that barred owls were outcompeting spotted owls, and their populations were going haywire.”

Advertise with us

Barred owls are common in forests east of the Mississippi River, including Pennsylvania. Mature barred owls are 19-20 inches long and weigh about 1½ pounds. It is a nocturnal predator, and its call of “who cooks for you” can be heard in the darkness throughout the Pittsburgh area.

“It’s an animal that feeds mostly on small mammals — mice, wood rats, squirrels,” said Henry Kacprzyk, a biologist at the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium. “They’re quite voracious when they have owlets and are feeding a lot.”

Their recent emergence in the Pacific Northwest has caused a serious ecological problem as they are displacing and hybridizing with spotted owls, their slightly smaller, less aggressive cousins that are threatened by habitat loss.

Since barred owls require trees for nesting and don’t migrate, the largely treeless Great Plains prevented them from expanding their range westward — until Europeans arrived.

“As Europeans settled in towns and along rivers, they planted trees, creating a ‘bridge’ or corridor that the owls could follow,” said Jim Bonner, executive director of the Audubon Society of Western Pennsylvania. “At the same time, [Europeans] displaced Native Americans, who had been burning the grasslands, and trees [became] more common.”

Advertise with us

In time, owls and their prey followed the tree highways. Eventually, the last barriers were bridged through southern Canada, and Eastern barred owls gained access to the Northwest.

“Once there, with ideal habitat similar to what they had in the East, they expanded quickly, compounding the problems the spotted owls were already facing,” said Mr. Bonner. “The range expansion was actually a 150-year process with a huge bang at the end.”

The federal government has been trying for decades to save the Northern spotted owl, a native bird that sparked an intense battle over logging across Washington, Oregon and California decades ago.

The spotted owl was listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act in 1990, earning it a cover on Time magazine, and federal officials halted logging on millions of acres of old-growth forests on federal lands to protect the bird’s habitat. But the spotted owl’s population continued to decline.

Mr. Wiens and other researchers began documenting the rise of barred owls, which compete with spotted owls for food and have displaced them in some areas.

Advertise with us

In almost all ways, the barred owl is the spotted owl’s worst enemy. They reproduce more often, have more babies per year and eat the same prey. They now outnumber spotted owls in many areas of the native bird’s historic range.

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s experiment, which began in 2015, has raised thorny questions: Can we reverse declines that have unfolded over decades, often partially due to actions by humans? And as climate change continues to shake up the landscape, how should we intervene?

The cull of barred owls raised such moral dilemmas when it was proposed in 2012 that the Fish and Wildlife Service hired an ethicist to help work through whether it was acceptable and could be done humanely.

Federal and state officials have intervened in similar ways to protect other species. They have broken the necks of thousands of cowbirds to save the warbler, a songbird once on the brink of extinction. To preserve salmon runs in the Pacific Northwest and perch and other fish in the Midwest, agencies kill thousands of large seabirds called double-crested cormorants. And last year, Congress passed a law making it easier for Native Americans and government workers in Oregon, Washington and Idaho to kill sea lions that gobble imperiled salmon runs in the Columbia River and elsewhere.

In four small study areas in Washington, Oregon and northern California, Mr. Wiens and his team have been picking off invasive barred owls with 12-gauge shotguns to see if the native birds will return to their nesting habitat. Small efforts to remove barred owls in British Columbia and northern California have showed promising results.

Advertise with us

The Fish and Wildlife Service has a permit to kill up to 3,600 owls. If the $5 million program works, it could decide to expand its efforts.

Mr. Wiens said he now views his gun as “a research tool” in humankind’s attempts to maintain biodiversity and rebalance the forest ecosystem.

“Humans, by stepping in and taking that role in nature, we may be able to achieve more biodiversity in the environment, rather than just having barred owls take over and wipe out all the prey species,” he said.

Marc Bekoff, professor emeritus of ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of Colorado, Boulder, finds the culling to be abhorrent and said humans should find another way to help owls.

“There’s no way to couch it as a good thing if you’re killing one species to save another,” he said.

Advertise with us

Michael Harris, who directs the wildlife law program for Friends of Animals, thinks the government should focus on what humans are doing to the environment and protect habitats rather than scapegoating barred owls.

“We really have to let these things work themselves out,” he said. “It’s going to be very common with climate change. What are we going to do, pick and choose the winners?”

Some see a responsibility to intervene, however, noting that humans are partly to blame for the underlying conditions with activities like logging, which helped lead to the spotted owl’s decline. Others see a no-win situation.

“A decision not to kill the barred owl is a decision to let the spotted owl go extinct,” said Bob Sallinger, conservation director with the Audubon Society of Portland. “That’s what we have to wrestle with.”

His Western Pennsylvania colleague, Mr. Bonner, shares that dilemma.

Advertise with us

“I understand [the USFWS cull] has had some success,” he said. “Unfortunately, as long as the pathway stays open [barred owls] will continue to return. I have no idea what would be involved in trying to reestablish a barrier. In some ways, it is much like so many other introduced species’ stories.”

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has decided to extend the experimental cull to August 2021.

“I certainly don’t see Northern spotted owls going extinct completely,” Mr. Wiens said. “Extinction in this case will be a much longer process, and from what we’ve seen from doing these removal experiments we may be able to slow some of those declines.”

The Associated Press contributed to this story.