It took Pennsylvania three months to ratify the U.S. Constitution. It took 232 years of debate to legalize Sunday hunting.
Gov. Tom Wolf was expected to sign a bill into law late last week that would permit hunting on three Sundays per year. The hunts would not begin until at least 90 days after the governor’s endorsement, effectively extending the Sunday ban until the conclusion of the 2019-20 hunting seasons in January.
The bill’s supporters considered passage of the law to be historic.
“I’m absolutely elated,” said Rep. Bill Kortz, D-Allegheny, a longtime hunter and minority chair of the House Game and Fisheries Committee, and an important figure in moving the bill through the House. “It’s been a long time coming for all the folks working six days a week and the kids who don’t have off [on weekdays].”
Cosponsored by state Sens. Dan Laughlin, R-Erie, and Jim Brewster, D-Allegheny, Senate Bill 147 passed its final legislative hurdle Nov. 13, clearing the Senate by a vote of 38-11.
“Weekends are the only free time for many hunters,” said Mr. Laughlin, chair of the Senate Game and Fisheries Committee. “Those two days are essentially the only time that most working men and women can get out into the woods. The same could be said for many young people, the ones who represent the future of the sport.”
Read More
Previously Pennsylvania law banned Sunday hunting except when targeting coyotes, foxes and crows. It permitted some Sunday hunts on private wildlife preserves.
No trespassing
With Mr. Wolf’s expected signature, the Pennsylvania Game Code is amended to create a new primary offense, “hunting trespass,” with significantly higher penalties than for general trespass violations. Hunting will be permitted one day during the statewide firearm deer season, one in the statewide archery deer season and another day to be determined the state Game Commission.
The compromise bill included amendments requiring hunters to carry written landowner permission on the designated Sundays, authorizing enforcement by Game Commission personnel and police, and allowing dog owners to enter properties while unarmed in search of wayward pets.
Additionally, Senate Bill 147 requires the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee to perform a financial analysis of the Game Commission’s fees, fines, penalties, royalties, federal and state appropriations and other sources of revenue received by the commission, as well as expenditures including annual operating costs, investments, land purchases and capital projects, within 180 days after the bill is enacted.
Lifting the ban puts an end to one of the last Blue Laws originally enacted by Britain’s colonial government and continued by Pennsylvania to encourage citizens to attend Sunday church services. In the past 20 years, previous bills that would have ended the Sunday ban failed in the legislature.
This one hit the bull’s eye primarily because of a historic bargain made between Sunday hunting proponents and the powerful Pennsylvania Farm Bureau. Late in 2018, the bureau gave Mr. Laughlin and Mr. Brewster a list of conditions it would accept in exchange for dropping its long-held opposition to Sunday hunting.
“The last amendment [to the bill] was what we were looking for when the House Game and Fisheries Committee added language requiring hunters to gain written permission before hunting on the three [Sunday hunting] days,” said Mark O’Neill, Farm Bureau communications director.
“I spoke with Pennsylvania Game Commission Executive Director Bryan Burhans [Wednesday] and he said that farmers and other landowners could receive free No Hunting signs at regional Game Commission offices across the state.”
Mr. Kortz, part of a hunting group that leases farmland in Greene County, said he sees Sunday hunting as a property rights issue.
“We have the land, we take care of it, post and patrol it, we have food plots on it. Why can’t we enjoy the sport we love on that land on a Sunday?” he said. “It’s the same on state gamelands, purchased by the Game Commission specifically for use by hunters. There’s no farming. Why can hunters hunt there on Sundays? It doesn’t make sense.”
Hunting safety
For decades, opponents of Sunday hunting cited concerns about hunting safety. Senate Bill 147 did not mention the issue, and safety was discussed only briefly during the bill’s debate. Mr. Laughlin said despite resistance from some quarters there are signs that perceptions about Sunday hunting are evolving.
Prior to SB 147’s passage through the legislature, just three states — Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and Maine — continued to ban all or most hunting on Sundays. Following initial Sunday hunting test runs in the other 47 states, safety concerns were satisfied and Sunday hunting opportunities were expanded.
Joe Neville, executive director of the Keystone Trails Association, testified to lawmakers that his group’s members want one day outdoors without risk of being injured by a hunter. Casey Schneck, the association’s program administrator, said the new Sunday hunting law falls short of satisfying their concerns.
“It’s a matter of peace of mind,” he said. “I won’t say [hunting safety] is a big problem now on Saturdays, but it’s mainly the peace of mind that people enjoy. They want to be able to feel safe.”
Since hunter education training began in Pennsylvania in 1959, hunting-related shooting incidents have declined by nearly 80%, according to the state Game Commission.
“During 2018, there were a total of 27 hunting-related shooting incidents recorded, one of which was fatal,” said the agency’s 2018 hunting safety year-end summary.
The data showed an increase of incidents, from 24 in 2017 to to 27 in 2018, among some 800,000 hunting license holders. More than half of incidents reported in 2018, 59%, were self-inflicted.
By statistical comparison, the most dangerous part of a hunting trip is the drive to get there.
“In 2018, there were 128,420 reportable traffic crashes in Pennsylvania,” said a report in the 2018 edition of Pennsylvania Crash Facts and Statistics published by the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation. “These crashes claimed the lives of 1,190 people and injured another 78,219 people.”
On average in Pennsylvania in 2018, said the data, each day three people were fatally injured in traffic crashes with one fatality every seven hours. The report said 214 people were injured in traffic accidents, about nine every hour.
Any loss of life is regrettable, said Mr. Kortz, but he’s spoken with non-hunting outdoors users who felt the new Sunday hunting law was reasonable. A group of birders visited his Dravosburg office concerned about the safety of the Sunday hunts.
“I said, ‘Look, I want three days,’” said Mr. Kortz. “One in archery, one in rifle deer and one at the discretion of the Game Commission. That’s all. They said, ‘OK’ and got up and walked out. Other states have done this very safely. We can do this very safely.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.