When the leaves start to drop on Lake Arthur and shallow vegetation starts to die, the crappies move toward deeper vegetation.
At this time of year, with the Butler County lake nearly devoid of other anglers, Joe Fazio of Mount Washington finds most of the fish at depths of 15-25 feet, some suspended along structure.
“Yesterday they had pushed back in just a little to 11 feet. It has been warm and the water came back up a bit to 56 degrees,” he said.
Mr. Fazio, purveyor of the “Crappie Crushin’ TV” YouTube channel and Facebook page, said water temperature isn’t critical to crappies in autumn, unlike in the spring.
“When water in Arthur dropped from 80 to 60 degrees, they began to move. The reason they do this is because the shallow water vegetation on this particular lake begins to die off and the bait moves out,” he said.
“We know they follow the bait and we follow them. So in a nutshell, Lake Arthur has already turned over. All signs of algae bloom have vanished. This is the key indicator, along with the brown vegetation along the shoreline.”
Crappies have been a bit confused by fluctuating water temperatures, but soon they will settle on wintering grounds at 25-35 feet in areas with a soft bottom adjacent to channels, points and inside turns. Mr. Fazio said they usually suspend just above the bottom, sometimes a foot off.
“On your electronics, you may think it is a school of perch down there when in fact it is huge schools of slab crappies,” he said.
The best way to determine the species is to fish it.
Crappies now are feeding “ferociously,” bulking up for winter when food is less available and their metabolism is low, Mr. Fazio said. Black and white crappies are taking baits in about equal proportions, he said, but at this time of year big slab female black crappies are holding eggs.
“They need to feed heavily. Right now they are still grabbing minnows and alewives, so we need to match that,” said Mr. Fazio. “I run a drop shot (weight determined by wind conditions) with a floating jig tight-lined to the mainline, usually 1 foot up from the drop shot.”
He adjusts the depth to put the bait right on the fish. Good electronics are a must.
“Tip that floating jig with a medium to large fathead. These fish are hungry now and want the larger baits,” he said.
Mr. Fazio fishes the wind, allowing his baits to blow over the desired contour when possible. When the wind changes, he alters the drift pattern.
“Keep that drop dragging along the bottom with your main line at a 45-degree angle,” he said. “Make your drift, boogie back up wind and repeat.
“These fish are usually slamming the baits this time of year with full commitment. When they hit, you will know it.”








Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.