Deer density is a matter of perspective.
Aging hunters may pine for the days when 60 whitetails ran past on opening day. Suburban landowners who see their flower gardens nipped to the stem may demand that municipal leaders remove those “rats with antlers.” Wildlife managers trying to balance deer and habitat in a particular park, community or management unit may see reductions to 30 deer per acre as a huge success, even though 20 per acre is better.
In a 20-year experiment that began to show results a decade ago, the Pennsylvania Game Commission intentionally reduced deer density in the state and brought the sex ratio closer to a natural balance. The tools used were mostly manipulations of hunting season frequency and duration, and the imposition of antler restrictions. What happened in Pennsylvania was and continues to be a statewide application of the principles of “quality deer management.”
Some hunters hate it, arguing license fee revenue is paying for a reduction in the number of deer they’re paying to hunt. Some wildlife management units still have more deer than they can handle; others don’t have as many as they could hold. But across the country deer researchers have continued to show interest in the management of Pennsylvania’s wild places.
It is now one week into this year’s early archery deer season in Wildlife Management Units 2B, 5C and 5D, a Game Commission conservation hunt scheduled for targeted deer density reduction. As archers climb into tree stands throughout Allegheny County, some of the most comprehensive research on whitetaile deer reinforces Pennsylvania’s reputation as one of America’s top deer-hunting states.
The Whitetail Report is compiled annually by the Quality Deer Management Association, a nonprofit conservation group that advocates for the use of QDM strategies across North America. According to the 2019 report, Pennsylvania’s antlered deer harvest increased from 137,580 in 2015 to 163,750 in 2017, a year when 23 of every 100 hunters in the state took a buck.
“Pennsylvania is one of only five states in the U.S. to harvest [around] 300,000 whitetails annually,” said Kip Adams of Tioga County, a wildlife biologist and QDMA’s director of conservation.
In the introduction to the 2019 Whitetail Report, Mr. Adams wrote that white-tailed deer are “the most important game species in North America.”
“More hunters pursue whitetails than any other species, and white-tail hunters contribute more financially than any other hunter segment,” he wrote. “Collectively speaking, white-tails are the foundation of the entire hunting industry.”
Pennsylvania ranks third among states in the 2017 buck harvest behind Texas (506,809) and Michigan (226,656).
“During the 2017-18 season, Pennsylvania hunters shot 8.2 deer per square mile,” said Mr. Adams. “Only one state in the entire U.S. shot more deer per square mile than Pennsylvania.”
Comparing Pennsylvania’s 2017 antlered deer harvest against the state’s five-year average, the harvest increased a significant 21%.
An important principle of quality deer management holds that healthy herds require bucks to survive into their reproductive years. The report finds that nationwide the age of harvested bucks is increasing, suggesting that antler restrictions and increased whitetail savvy among hunters is working. From 2015-17 in Pennsylvania, the percentage of deer that were at least 1½ years old when harvested has held steady at about 41%-44%.
“During the 2017-18 season, for the ninth year in a row, at least half of Pennsylvania’s antlered buck harvest was 2.5 years or older,” said Mr. Adams.
The whitetail deer is considered a “keystone species” because its actions impact every animal in its area. Wildlife managers control animal populations and habitat by controlling the deer. To control the deer, they control the does. Buck harvests have little to do with population density. The primary tool used by the Game Commission to manage regional deer populations is the allocation of antlerless deer permits. This year the Board of Game Commissioners increased antlerless allocations by 65,000 licenses, nearly 8% of the total, to 903,000 tags. In WMU 2B, which includes most of Allegheny County, the allocation was dropped from 58,000 in 2018-19 to 54,000.
The Quality Deer Management Association noted in this year’s report that Maryland harvested the most antlerless deer per square mile (5.7), followed by Delaware (5.2), and Pennsylvania (4.5).
“These are astounding harvest rates,” stated the report. “Regionally, the Northeast (2.4) averaged shooting the most antlerless deer per square mile, followed by the Southeast (1.6) and the Midwest (1.3).”
If the goal in Pennsylvania was to kill does before they could reproduce, the plan seems to be working. From 2015-17, about 36% of the antlerless deer killed were fawns. Those 1½ years or older: 18% in 2015, 20% in 2016 and 19% in 2017.
Pennsylvania hunters are taking increased advantage of those before-rifle-season conservation hunts. In 2007, 24% of the deer harvest occurred before opening day. In 2012, 31%. In 2017, more than a third of the deer harvested, 37%, were killed prior to opening day.
Consequently the number of deer taken on Pennsylvania’s opening day of firearm deer season is dropping: 18% in 2009, 14% in 2017.
“There are some very positive trends occurring,” said Mr. Adams. “Yearling buck harvest rates remain at record low numbers, and the percentage of 3½-year-old and older bucks in the harvest remain at a third of the total antlered buck harvest. Hunters are clearly reaping the benefits of more naturally balanced age structures in herds across the whitetail’s range.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.