Spruce Creek in Huntingdon County is probably the best-known Pennsylvania trout stream that you’re not allowed to fish.
You’re only welcome if you’re a member of the many fishing clubs that post No Trespassing signs along 87 percent of the non-navigable 16.5-mile waterway before it empties into the Little Juniata River. And they’d probably let you fish if you’re a former U.S. president — Dwight Eisenhower and Jimmy Carter famously cast flies on the limestone stream.
At an April meeting of the state Fish and Boat Commission, a recently opened 800-foot public section of Spruce Creek sparked a rare public argument among commissioners and became Ground Zero in an ongoing debate over artificial lures-only regulations vs. all-tackle fishing.
Last week, commissioners surprised anglers on both sides with an 8-2 ruling mandating that the section will be managed under Catch-and-Release Artificial Lures Only regulations. No vote was held on a parallel proposal for Catch-and-Release All Tackle management.
“The intent of this management strategy is to provide anglers with a unique opportunity to fish over an exceptionally high-quality wild trout population where fishing mortality would not be a major factor determining population structure,” said Fish and Boat communications director Mike Parker in a statement.
The issue arose following the closing of Indian Caverns on Spruce Creek near Franklinville in 2017. The Western Pennsylvania Conservancy acquired the 13-acre property and allowed Fish and Boat to use part of the riparian land for public access to a portion of the stream that had previously been off limits to anglers. The 0.15-mile stretch was managed under standard Commonwealth Inland Waters regulations.
Read More
In January, Fish and Boat biologists determined that the short stretch of Spruce Creek qualified for the Class A Wild Trout Stream designation given only to the state’s cleanest waters where wild trout are known to propagate. The biologists recommended that commissioners manage those waters for Catch-and-Release Artificial Lures Only, the same regulations in effect on a short upstream stretch of Spruce Creek where Penn State oversees an Experimental Fisheries Area.
Some commissioners, however, balked at the idea of turning a standard all-tackle fishing area into a no-bait zone. Supporters of an ongoing all-tackle initiative think it’s time to pull back most special regulations and let anglers use any bait they choose.
In the last decade, multiple studies have questioned long-running assumptions about catch-and-release mortality, particularly the belief that when fish take live bait the meal is partially swallowed before the hook can be set. Deep hook removal can be difficult and messy, and many of those fish die. Conversely, it was believed that because artificial lures are swallowed less often, hooks can be easily removed from lips without causing much damage, making catch-and-release more successful among fly and spin anglers.
At the April commission meeting, angler Mark Jackson of Huntingdon County offered robust support for all-tackle fishing on the creek section, as well as the statewide removal of all special regulations banning the use of live baits. His new website, PaAllTackle.com, pushes for an “all-tackle initiative.”
Mr. Jackson’s website says that Pennsylvania has 217 stream sections totaling 440 miles managed with special regulations, and 79% do not permit the use of live bait. He says new research shows near parity in catch-and-release mortality among bait-hooked fish and those hooked by artificial lures.
On the website, he says it’s time to eliminate special regulations that “discriminate against the largest segment of trout anglers — bait fishermen and fisherwomen.” Mr. Jackson couldn’t be reached.
During a presentation for commissioners last week, Fish and Boat fisheries management division chief Kris Kuhn supported biologists’ recommendation for the Spruce Creek segment and contradicted some of the all-tackle data.
Mr. Kuhn stated that special regulation areas comprise 1% (206 of 16,005 miles) of all wild trout streams. Of the 1%, all-tackle use is permitted on 61% of those waters.
Artificial lures minimize lethal and sub-lethal effects of hooking compared with all-tackle use, said Mr. Kuhn. According to published literature cited in the presentation, an average of 13% of fish in sampled catches died when hooked by artificial lures. In hook-ups by bait anglers, the average was 36%. Special regulation areas comprise 4% of 4,656 miles of stocked streams, stated Mr. Kuhn, and 11% of those waters permit the use of all tackle.
The 800-foot Spruce Creek section will not be stocked, as per Class A Wild Trout regulations.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.