PORTERSVILLE, Pa. — Lake Arthur was quiet at night except for the hum of distant trucks on I-79. Occasionally a splash licked the hull of Steve Gromer’s boat as we softly rocked in the darkness about 10 minutes out of the Route 528 boat launch.

Near the end of June, Mr. Gromer described three consecutive nights of exciting fishing for big channel catfish. He boated and released 10, he said, three or four per night between midnight and 3 a.m.

“The biggest one was 28 inches, 11 pounds,” he said. “It broke my net.”

Three nights later at about 11:30 p.m., I helped Mr. Gromer launch his 14-foot V-bottom and started rigging up as he motored into the darkness.

Advertise with us

“There’s a drop-off out here from before they flooded this valley to make the lake,” he said. “I drifted over a few times before I realized I was catching channel cats at the same spot every time I passed.”

Stretching to 3,225 acres in Butler County, Lake Arthur is known for its populations of largemouth bass, walleye, hybrid striped bass and muskellunge. The state Fish and Boat Commission ranks the lake high on its list of Best Fishing Waters for both channel catfish and their main meal, bluegills. A 2016 muskie trapnet and electrofishing survey found more channel cats (909 from 8 to 30 inches) and bluegills (1,559 from 2 to 9 inches) than any other species. Seventy percent of the channel catfish were 20 inches-plus.

The larger flathead and smaller bullhead catfish are native and prolific in Pennsylvania rivers and streams. When an impoundment is created, they easily populate the new lake or pond.

Channel cats are native to Lake Erie and most of the Mississippi River system. Easy and inexpensive to raise, they have been liberally introduced in waters east of the Appalachian Mountains and in Western Pennsylvania impoundments. From 2000 to 2019, 372,500 channel catfish fingerlings were stocked at Lake Arthur.

“The bigger they get the harder they get to catch,” said Mr. Gromer. “You can catch one accidentally when you’re fishing for something else, but when you target them like I do here you have to be very specific with your bait.”

Advertise with us

He anchored the boat over a submerged lip where waters drop abruptly from 5 to 13 feet and assembled a two-piece medium weight spinning rod spooled with 20-pound line. At the end he tied on a three-way swivel. From one swivel arm a 12-inch length of the same line dropped to a 1-ounce egg sinker. Six inches of line connected the other arm and a No. 9/​0 circle hook.

“When I can get them, I use 3- or 4-inch bluegills with a few slashes on the side,” said Mr. Gromer. “A bullhead will take any stink bait, and big flatheads like bigger baits. When I use small scored ‘gills, I get channel cats.”

His strategy, he said, is to anchor at 5 feet and cast into the pothole. A short lob drops the bait to 6 or 7 feet. A longer cast takes it down to 10 feet.

“There’s some wood down there,” he said. “I try to catch them at night when they’re coming up from the cool deep water looking for bluegills. The scoring puts a little smell in the water, but these channel cats want it live. The bluegill swims all around the swivel. Once I find the right depth where they can find it, I keep throwing to the same spot.”

His first hookup bent the rod before he set the hook. Mr. Gromer laughed as he reeled, netted and released the 20-inch channel cat. The next hit stole his bait. Within a couple of hours he’d released another channel catfish of 18 inches and two sublegal largemouths.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know why it works here,” he said. “It was an accident that I found this spot, but I keep coming back and catching channel cats.”

Catfish are believed to perceive their environment mainly through sight and taste receptors on their leathery skin and whisker-like barbells. Fish and Boat biologist reports say the average channel cat catch per hour was greatest in August on reservoirs larger than 500 acres, such as Lake Arthur. In reservoirs between 50 and 500 acres, the catch per hour spiked in July.

According to a Pennsylvania channel catfish propagation plan published in 2017, the popularity of trout fishing has declined by about 30% in recent years while the number of days targeting catfish had increased 24%. Channel cats are now the fifth most-pursued fish in Pennsylvania, and more are being cultured from eggs to juveniles at state fish hatcheries.

To encourage more interest in catfish, the Fish and Boat Commission launched a program of family catfish activities. The next is the Mentored Youth Catfish Fishing Opportunity at North Park Lake on July 20-21.

Since the 70-acre lake’s $21 million rehabilitation was completed in 2012, more than 28,500 fingerling and yearling channel catfish have been stocked. The fishing program will start with a minimal stocking of 12- to 14-inch adolescent channel cats at the Boathouse Pond. During a three-hour workshop, agency staff and volunteers will teach basic catfish fishing techniques as well as catfish biology and ecology, and demonstrate catfish cleaning, cooking and tasting. Loaner rods and reels will be available, and license requirements will be waived.

Advertise with us

“The mentored youth part encourages parents or other licensed adults to stay and take the kids fishing,” said Chad Foster, a Fish and Boat Commission education specialist. “We did a kids panfish program [at Pymatuning Reservoir] ... but they caught a lot of channel catfish. They’re bigger and fight better. The kids had a blast.”

For details about the Mentored Youth Catfish Fishing Opportunity at North Park, visit fishandboat.com and scroll down to Upcoming Events.